Re: Best place to buy just a Rem 700 action
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: nhm16</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I never said it would shoot better, and neither did Special Deliver -- you put those words in our mouths. I agree the barrel and chambering are more important. I shoot F-Class with a bunch of loose sloppy Savages and the action is not what causes me to drop points.</div></div>
No Special said:
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Special Delivery</div><div class="ubbcode-body">If yor going to true it up for a custom build, its cheaper to just buy a Stiller, which is must nicer than a trued Remmy. </div></div>
I didn't say you or Special D said a custom action would shoot better. I asked "Nicer how? Looks? They don't shoot any better" in response to Special Delivery's comment.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: nhm16</div><div class="ubbcode-body">However, it's not inconceivable that members of this site who want to blueprint a Remington will want to have numerous other features or upgrades added not related to accuracy. My only point is that the more you have done to a Remington, the worse of a deal it is over just buying an aftermarket action. Of course the flip side is that with a Remington you can do more or less customization, whereas with a custom you are paying for all the features a particular action comes with whether you want it or not.</div></div>
Yes some people here on the Hide take a lot of pride in their dodads like the clip on plastic tactical bolt knobs advertised here on the Hide. Features that add noting to reliable repeatable precision shot placement add no value to me but that's just me YMMV. I'll trade a side bolt release and fluted bolt for a good two-stage Huber trigger any day.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: nhm16</div><div class="ubbcode-body">A Tac30 is $950 MSRP from Stiller with a recoil lug. Bugholes is selling them for $900. I have bought two from the annual group buys here for less that either price.
Let's say you buy a Remington action for around $350. Add $250 (avg.) to have a gunsmith true it up. Add another $25-50 for an aftermarket recoil lug. That's probably the minimum that people will do to "blueprint" a Remington, and yet you already have ~$625-650 into it. If that's all you do and all you want to do, then yeah, no point in spending ~$300 more for a Tac30.</div></div>
Yes I agree that if a buyer wanted a lot of features which add nothing to the accuracy, function or reliability of a rifle a moderately priced custom action might almost be price competitive with a Remington action with every possible feature added to it. But like Japanese cars none of these "features" add to the function or reliability of rifle.
Based on your post it sounds like you agree that as I posted a Remington action will cost less and leave the buyer more money to buy stuff like a decent barrel, stock or trigger.
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: nhm16</div><div class="ubbcode-body">However, if you're reading this website, you might want a cool tactical bolt knob, so that's another $150 avg. installed, at which point you have $775-$800 into it. From the pictures I've seen, that's very common. Alternately, a PT&G bolt (without any extras like fluting) and aftermarket knob will set you back anywhere from $150 (2-piece, traditional bolt knob) to $220 (1-piece plus knob) plus installation and small parts like M-16 style extractor, etc, at which point you are right at or over $1,000.
So, even without an aftermarket bolt or any the other features that differentiate an aftermarket action from a trued Remington, that trued Remington can easily cost around $800, within spitting distance of the cost of new Tac30. If you have even more done to the Remington, you'll probably end up spending more.</div></div>
So basically you are saying that if a shooter wanted the best shooting action and only cared about shooting performance the cost difference using your pricing is about $300 less for a Remington action that will shoot and perform just as well as the custom action. My point exactly, the Remington action will shoot just as well and cost less. Why spend more to add features to the action when they don't do anything to make the rifle shoot better? Looks? Tacticool? You pick. Which leads us to:
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: nhm16</div><div class="ubbcode-body">What the relative resale prices of Stillers and Remington actions have to do with the price of California real estate I don't know, since we weren't talking about California real estate. </div></div>
That was in response to your comment that a rifle based on a custom action will hold its resale value better than a rifle based on a trued Remington action. But this is not always the case, look at the used TacOps rifles listed here on the hide which typically sell for the same price and more than a new TacOps rifle. But for the most part custom rifles even custom rifles with custom actions make very poor investments and generally depreciate just like cars and other durable goods and typically do not appreciate like California real estate does.
HTH!