Re: Optics for deploying soldier
Not sure why anyone would want to run a setup with less magnification in astan, he is going to need all the magnification he can get. EOTECH with a magnifier is a heavier combo and doesn't offer any advantages over the ACOG. In my scout platoon we used 1x6 Elcans, EOTECHS with magnifiers, ACOGS, Aimpoints with magnifiers, and I used a CQBSS on an 18' Noveske upper. Most ended up with ACOGs or the Elcans on by the end of it. If I was using a standard M4 it would have had an ACOG on it.
Line guys don't usually do a lot of research on what works. They see something and follow suit because it looks cool. It doesn't matter if it is boots, packs, or optics. If they see ODA guys using it, it will be the new fad.
I did a lot of research and ended up with my CQBSS, it offered everything I needed and wanted for what I was doing, and it worked out perfectly. If I was doing valley clearing instead of sitting in overwatch positions like I was, it wouldn't have been something I looked at. The ACOG covers it all very well, door kicking and engaging targets at distance.
Hope this helps.