• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

Maggie’s You know you have a bad gunsmith when....

You would think that some of these guys would realize the liability in bad gun smithing!
 
........... ...............
 
Last edited:
When you pick up a custom hunting rifle after having it coated with "arctic coat" that was his name for it I suspect it was duracoat but when I noticed the bolt release just came out of the receiver he handed me a small container of mixed small parts and said it "might" be in there I was so pissed I left words escaped me actions were ill advised, I had to send it back to the factory to get fixed right lesson learned choose your gunsmith wisely there is one in fairbanks that sucks big moose balls!

My Inlaws live in Fairbanks -- can you pm me on the hacksmiths as well as your referred smiths? I am going to keep a couple of rifles up there and would like to get some work done?
 
Last edited:
You show up at his shop to pick up your rifle and its empty, closed. No forwarding address. Nowhere to be found.
 
A buddy of mine found out what a bad gunsmith was when he fired his new gun and it blew the clip bottom out and the escaping burned his face and eyes. The barrel had a little more than 1/8" gap between the bolt and barrel. The first few rounds he fired came out with a belt and he did not notice this because he was looking at the primers to see it it had any pressure. The pressure was fine it was the gunsmith that was unbelievably stupid to pull a stunt like that.
 
Wow, this thread is terrifying. Maybe there should be a list of questionable businesses so that others know who to look out for.
 
When you have a bad chamber job on a Savage prefit, send it back to the maker to have them tell you it isn't even one of there barrels and proceeds to call the gunsmith and bitch them out. Then the gunsmith calls and tells you he accidently used a barrel that retails for about 200 less. Many months later you get an email telling you that your Savage action was torn in half while truing it on his lathe. A replacement Savage action is found by the smith which doesn't fit the chassis rendering the internal box mag worthless. After more than a year the rifle is finally together and working. Curiosity to why the bolt body was painted black without my request led me to the Savage serial number search. Low and behold my replacement Savage action is a Stevens 200...NEVER AGAIN!!! Luckily the original prefit had a bad chamber, otherwise I would have been screwed over even worse.
 
Asked for a stainless thread protector for my heavy barrel AR, contoured for a seamless mating with a re-crown.
Work order written up that way.
Went to pick up the barrel (a month later).... HA.... knurled texture aluminum, no re-crown, barrel is about a half mil longer than the thread protector....
Another month later, it comes back right... other than the burrs on the re-crown at the end of the rifling.
I ended up smoothing the burrs with a brass screw & some lapping compound.
It shoots better, but still like crap. but hey... it shoots good enough for coyote & wild hog.
 
The smith offers to send you money for replacement parts......2 years ago I sent a smith a contender barrel and a liner to have a 25 acp barrel made, long story short barrel and liner are lost and I get to find new parts.
 
When you take a HK USP in to get switched from V3 to V1 and get told "sorry I only work on name brand stuff"
 
How are some of you guys not in prison? I would probably strangle the guy if he did that kind of shit to my guns, I am thankful that I found this website and a reputable smith because of it.
 
Home "gunsmith/idiot" tale...
Mid December a guy phones and gets a quote on having his action drilled and scope fitted. Aparrently he decided it's too expensive...
1'st of January he phones and arrives at the shop with stitches all around his right eye... Not just a nick, all around his eye stitched up and gun in hand.
He apparently decided it can't be such a big job and proceded to what looks like the following:
He tried to drill the action with hand held drill, a few times and a few places, like where the drillbit broke off in one of the holes and he decided to just move the holes.
Tried to tap the holes, and broke off 2 taps in two holes and moved those holes as well.
When he ran out of realeastate on the acttion and still not have tapped holes, he decided that modern chemistry will be the answer in the form of epidermic Epoxy.
With scope mounts glued to his 30-06, off to the range...

I guess I don't have to explain the stitches around his eye..?

Cost:
Medical expenses 2x original quote
Wielding up holes in action 1x original quote
Reblueing after wielding 1/2x Original quote
drilling & tapping & mouting 1x Original quote
+ R1000 (+/- $120) Asshole tax on having to do all of this after the guy got a very reasonable quote.
 
dropping off the rifle to get the action "bedded" only to find foreskin in the bolt release the next morning.

Somewhat along the same lines:

Comedian: My gunsmith is sooooo bad

Audience in unison: How bad is he?

Comedian: I asked him to bed my rifle and I found a condom in the chamber!!!
 
Last edited:
Send you Bnib 586 in for an action job. Comes back with a double action pull so light it will not pop a federal primer. When I asked the guy about it, he says well after its left my shop I cant warranty the work because i don't know what you might have done to it....And the asshole has a national reputation..
 
You know you have a bad gunsmith when....

...your revolver has been sitting in his backlog for 10 months when he emails you back to tell you he cannot find it.

He's not bad at gunsmithing, just organization. Once he finally found it, his work was good (after 17 months total), though I ended up reworking the action myself as I'm a certifiable perfectionist.
 
Last edited:
Dug this stock outta the junk pile for the pic. You know you have a bad gunsmith when he tells you he touched up the bedding on your rifle but when you get it back you notice the inlet on the bottom metal is all cut to hell and back due to him bedding it cock eyed and the trigger rubbing

IMG_20130604_051228_589.jpg
 
When there is a shooting at his shop involving his wife, charged with 2 counts reckless endangerment and and simple assault.
Karma's a BITCH!!!!
 
One guy I knew had a new barrel with a comp installed in his 1911. Got the pistol back and during test firing the first round, shit hit the fan and almost took the comp off.

He didn't know what happened and send the barrel and the comp to me to look at for him. I told him that it is customary to line ream the comp to size after installing it:)

He then was pissed to hell and confronted the gunsmith about it. He replyed that I didn't know you wanted me to do that too and it would be an extra 120 bucks................
 
When you get more parts back than you sent.

When things are modified/changed that in no way have anything to do with your request

When the work looks like a dremel was involved

Fuck you Cliff in Florida