• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

  • Site updates coming next Wednesday at 8am CT!

    The site will be down for routine maintenance on Wednesday 6/5 starting at 8am CT. If you have any questions, please PM alexj-12!

Hunting & Fishing Elk Hunting with a Handgun 2013

Dave in Idaho

Private
Full Member
Minuteman
Mar 17, 2003
76
37
Idaho
This year I drew a Cow Elk tag for area 48 in Idaho. The northern portion of this area was devastated by fire in early August. My part of area 48 was the southern portion. This hunt is in south central Idaho and is south west of Sun Valley, Idaho.

It was my first time hunting in this area. I have never been that successful as an Elk hunter. I have lived in Idaho 23 years and killed 2 Elk. I go every year but have never been as driven to hunt hard for Elk.
I put my wife, Mary, and I in for this tag and we were lucky enough to draw. She was excited but apprehensive about it. My previous success rate on Elk did not instill confidence in her that this would be any different than my past hunts. I had no defense for myself.
We took our family up on a day trip that was fun for everyone. My son found a bear track and several Mule deer were seen up close. My wife seemed a little bit more comfortable about this hunt but I think she felt that it might go better for her if I was not there to place a pox on it. Unfortunately her need for a strong back if she scored necessitated that she take me. WIN!
We went up on a cool morning in early August. She was able to watch a herd of about 30 Elk work across a river and onto private land. She was excited. The next morning it took no prompting to get her out of bed and headed north.

That morning my sons, 9 and 13 and I watched my wife kill her first Elk with a single head shot at 138 yards. She cheated by using her Remington 700 in .250 Ackley Improved. She chose the head shot for those that are wondering. She wanted an instant stop. She got it.

The Fam.jpg


My Turn
Equipment:
Gun: Ruger stainless Bisley 5.5” 45 Colt
Load: 19.5 gr W296 OT 360gr WFN GC
Shooting sticks, Zeiss range finder

I had practiced quite a bit with this gun and my confidence level was high. I shot a 3”group at 100 yards with it a week before. I only shot one group at this distance as I did not want to know that this was a lucky group for me. The gun with the burden of me behind the trigger shoots into 2”at 50 yards consistently.

Fast forward two weeks later and I was sitting in the same spot Mary had been. My brother was with me. It was an evening hunt. Early on we had a 2 point (western count) walk by us at a lasered 13 yards.
Shortly after that we heard several bugles and mews. They were coming. We did not know where they would appear but I felt like I could adjust my position a little if need be. I was facing the river and with a fairly large area that was all within my range. I had lasered several spots as references using my Zeiss LR. My brother was sitting next to me facing behind me and would advise if I any coming that way.
I suddenly noticed brown bodies moving thru an opening approximately 35 yards to my 2 O’clock. I told my brother that Elk were moving thru in front of me. He adjusted slowly moving to where he had a decent camera angle. As a side note. My brother, God love him, is a horrible camera man. But, you get what you get and you don’t throw a fit.

The group started moving out of the timber and toward the water’s edge. I watched several but did not get that warm fuzzy feeling about any of them. Suddenly that changed. I looked at a good sized ol’girl and knew that she was the one if I could get a shot.

She stopped broadside at 43 yards. I had practiced for a head or neck shot all summer. She gave me ample opportunity to make this shot. However, my adrenalin laughed at this notion and promptly dumped enough of itself that I did not feel I could maintain well enough for the neck shot. I moved the front sight down to her front shoulder and touched it off. The trigger broke perfectly and I saw the bullet strike the water behind her and geyser up. I was absolutely confident that the shot was good. I held for both shoulders to be broken and the bullet to take the heart.

She stumbled and turned to run back the way she came. Most of the group went with her. But, one cow and a spike bull came up toward us in the confusion. They stopped for several seconds in front of us. Distance was seven yards. They finally ran off and I barely noticed as I was busy checking this particular event off my Bucket List. Big Game with a handgun……Check!

Elk 2013.jpg

1st Big Game Kill Hand Gun.jpg


I am 46 years old, have hunted most of my life, I work in a dangerous profession and have seen and done things. Twice in my life I have experienced weak knees. This moment was my second. I found her graveyard dead 19 yards from where the bullet hit her.

Elk and the Big Colt.jpg


The Oregon Trail 360 grain WFN GC had broken the near shoulder, a rib, passed through the major arteries 2”above the heart, part of the off side lung, broken a far side rib, far side shoulder and exited. The entry hole was perfectly round. The hair had been cut perfectly in a circular fashion as if with scissors. I had held the front sight perfectly for a heart shot. In my excitement though I forgot that all my practice, mental and actual, had been with a 6 o’clock hold. My training had kicked in and I held where I wanted the bullet to go. Hence an impact 3” higher than intended. Still deadly and effective.
It was a great moment. I feel lucky to be blessed with a hunting family and to live in a state where I can do this.



That is all.
Dave
And now a short film entitled,
The Shot


107_0894_zpsbd7f849e.mp4 Video by Daveinidaho | Photobucket
 
Last edited:
Very nice. I have hunted deer in the lower 48 with a handgun and it is my favorite. Great job on your hunt and congratulation to you and your family.
 
Congrats to you Sir!! Handgun hunting can be addictive. I've taken game with semi autos, revolvers and specialty pistols. Never gets dull and a lot like bowhunting-getting in close. Congrats again, job very well done.
 
Great trip and congrats to both of you.

I have always wanted to try handgun hunting but haven't yet. might take the 357 with me deer hunting this year in case one gets close enough...
 
Hi Dave,

I live in 49 and am very familiar with the area. Congrats on your success--pretty sweet. Simple question and by no means do I mean to poo-poo your accomplishment: Did you check with F&G to make sure your tag was good for a short range weapon? I only ask out of curiosity, knowing they have SRW specific tags, so I'm wondering if they're excluded from normal tags.

Either way, congrats. I've been chasing those bastards with my bow for three days now with some good sightings, no real plays yet.
 
Idaho Savage,
No offense. This hunt goes from August 3rd to Sept. 15th. Any weapon. Cow only.
Hunt is #2108 if this helps.
Is the video link working for anyone? It is The Shot as it happened.
If not I would accept any input in how to make it work.
 
Idaho Savage,
No offense. This hunt goes from August 3rd to Sept. 15th. Any weapon. Cow only.
Hunt is #2108 if this helps.
Is the video link working for anyone? It is The Shot as it happened.
If not I would accept any input in how to make it work.

Now that is good to know! I saw a dude icing a cow a week or so ago at Guffy's and was wondering what tag that was. Video works and is great...just took a while to buffer. Calves are so gangly...funny watching them on the river rock. Now if I could only find a little parade like that....
 
Nice write up. Very descriptive with just enough humor. Congrats to you and your wife. Gonna have full freezers!
 
Great job! I love Idaho short range cow hunts myself . Handgun is about the only weapon left for me to try . So far I've taken a few with a shotgun and a pair with blackpowder and archery . Pistol would be a hoot .
 
Dave...... it don`t get no better than that....hope you bought a lottery ticket that nite........I`m envious as hell........family deal.....great..... LOTSA WORK....
 
Nice cow, keep the family hunting! I really like the bisley as well, Michigan deer don't care much for it though...
 
Nice job. I picked up a taurus raging bull 454 for whitetail hunting this year. After some trigger work, I am looking forward to my first pistol kill. You have me feeling bad using that vaquero though. I have a set of 45 colt vaquero's in closet from my cowboy action days. I was concerned about their power delivery before this post.

Ryan
 
Thanks for the comments by everyone.
Punisher29073, You will not find a bigger fan of the 45 Colt (The Big Colt) than I.
If your Vaquero's are the old larger frame you will be amazed at the potential they hold. I load WFN 300gr lead for an everyday load. It gets out at 1200 fps and will pass through anything I settle the front sight on.
I don't believe that the .454 will do anything for me that The Big Colt doesn't already do. With less pain.
My hunting load is not comfortable in a standard frame but is absolutely comfortable in a Bisley frame.
I would advise you that if the .454 seems too much, throw in a good stout .45 Colt load and prepare to be amazed.
John Linebaugh found in his extensive hands on research bullets in the 300gr plus weights driven from 1200 to 1400 fps are as terminally effective as the same bullets driven from 1400+ to 2000 fps. In his mind all those velocities buy you is flatter trajectory. At the cost of recoil. Wise man he is.
Enjoy.
 
Excellent! I have been chasing elk around the desert here in South West Wyoming for the passed couple days trying to stick one with an arrow, I have come close but not close enough to draw back. A big game handgun kill is on my list of things to accomplish. Great choice on the round and gun. A lot of people don't understand how hot it can be in a strong framed gun. My dad actually just gave me a Bisley in 45lc for my birthday a couple of days ago.
 
They are the older big frame guns. I will have to play with some loads. I can shoot the 45 colt loads in the Taurus as well. I was always concerned with the casings not being strong enough. The 454 doesn't bother me too bad yet, but I'm not going out shooting a box of shells at a time.

Ryan
 
Congratulations, great write-up and great pair of cows in the freezer :)

Big game with a wheel gun is high on my list. I might attempt it this year if bow season provides enough cushion that I don't need to crush something during centerfire rifle season (our only CF handgun time in PA)
 
Wow! Nice job both of you. I hunted cow elk with a handgun a couple years ago here in AZ but couldn't score. I had to break out the -06 to close the deal. I've taken 2 bulls during archery season, but a handgun elk is still high on my bucket list. I like your Ruger also, I have a blued version worked over by Linebaugh himself. It is a great shooting gun. Again, congrats on a nice handgun elk.
 
Very cool sir! I have hunted a bit with a few JDJ calibered contenders but the my biggest game to date was a nice mulie buck with the 6.5JDJ. It sure is fun, and I say you for sure took the more challenging road rolling with the stock six shooter, good on ya.
NT