I have one with the bdc reticle. Bottom line, imho, a great scope. Glass is excellent and eyebox is very forgiving. Love the 28 mm tube diameter. Criticisms I have read are that it is heavy (it is) and that the reticle at 8X is too thick for precision shooting (maybe). The reticle (FFP) lends itself well for use as a rds at 1X with the circle dot reticle. Of all the scopes that I own, this is my favorite, albeit for the weight penalty. As far as toughness, it is a Trijicon, and seems very well built and quite rugged. To improve upon what I have would require an investment substantially in excess of the cost of this scope. Mine is not going anywhere.