Re: ARMY?
February 16, 2010, 2:44 pm
It’s the Economy, Soldier
By TIM HSIA
Brendan McDermid/Reuters The United States Armed Forces Recruiting Station in New York’s Times Square.
The recession has greatly altered the American political and social landscape, but one of the few segments in society that has not been affected is the military.
In fact, the bad economy has aided recruiting and retention for the military. This comes as no surprise, given that service members are keenly aware of the uncertain economic environment outside the military.
With unemployment affecting one in five men in the United States between the ages of 25 to 54, staying in the military and dealing with the risk of another deployment becomes all the more palatable in comparison to being unemployed.
Today this seems to no longer be the case, and the dark economic times have changed many civilians’ attitudes.
My previous unit’s re-enlistment non-commissioned officer told me that he noticed there had been a jump in re-enlistments after we returned from a deployment. He found this surprising because re-enlistments in a combat zone are often given additional cash bonuses and are tax-free, so it would make more sense for a soldier to re-enlist while deployed. What was even more surprising to him was that the soldiers who were re-enlisting were often those who, while deployed, would insist to him that they were set on leaving the military.
He told me that the deciding factor was the influence of spouses, and financial concerns that were not fully considered during the deployment itself. “The same soldiers who swore that they would never set foot in my office are suddenly in my office once we are back from the deployment, and when they come, they are often accompanied with their wives. These wives realize that the economy is rough and that finding a job will be difficult, and so they push their husbands to reconsider leaving the military,” he said.
The relative prestige associated with serving in the military, and the high costs of college tuition which can be offset by the new G.I. Bill are added reasons for society’s shifting view on military service.
When I graduated high school in 2000, I could count on one hand the number of classmates who had decided to join the military. The economy was on autopilot and the American dream of owning a house and finding a good career was something every classmate believed was attainable.
Read Forbes: America’s Best College
Recently a fellow high school classmate with a college degree spoke with me about the military. Since graduating college, he had struggled to find a job and I could tell that he was really drawn to the idea of a steady paycheck and the possibility of learning a trade.
Perhaps the most telling evidence that the economy has changed people’s attitudes toward the military is when Forbes considers West Point to be its top university, partly because its graduates have no student loans hanging over them.
After this conversation with my high school classmate — and after also contemplating whether to stay in the military — I gradually came to the realization that among my peers I am fortunate.
Read: It’s the Economy, Undergraduate by Wes Morgan
While I was deployed I felt, and wrote, sentiments similar to those voiced by some in a recent post by Wes Morgan concerning disenchantment toward civilians for their lack of concern over the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Now, after being back in the United States for almost a year, I have come to believe that it’s not for the lack of caring that Americans are not more involved with the war, rather that there are more pressing and immediate concerns like employment prospects, mortgages, and providing for their families.
Moreover, what does that vague term “involvement” mean? Perhaps the most involved one can be is by pasting a yellow ribbon bumper sticker on a car or taking a moment of silence when reading about the death of a soldier. Or is a sense of involvement impossible, and perhaps the only reason I am so absorbed with the military is because of the simple fact that I wear the uniform every day?
Any anger or resentment toward citizens who cannot locate Baghdad or Kabul on a map is unjustified because it is impossible to be more “involved” in the war than being an educated taxpaying citizen. When the government is struggling and debating freezes on spending, it is perhaps unfair to ask Americans to do anymore than simply continue supporting the military with their tax dollars. Moreover, I’m sure that many Americans are ambivalent about how their tax dollars are spent in terms of national defense considering the many blunders related to major weapon projects.
For my parents, siblings, and civilian friends, life’s demands are greater than just reading every factoid concerning the latest suicide bomber attack.
While I still believe that many Americans are completely oblivious to the suffering and pain of people overseas, this does not mean that I should be resentful of this innocence. Rather I should count my blessings and hope that the violence which entraps the people of Afghanistan and Iraq never reaches the shores of this country.
Capt. Tim Hsia is an active duty infantry captain serving in the United States Army. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not reflect the official policy or position of the Department of the Army, Department of Defense, or the United States government. We welcome your comments.
http://atwar.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/1...dier&st=cse