Attached piston vs floating piston, Upper

Alderleet

NCOIC of Shitposts
Full Member
Minuteman
Feb 12, 2010
909
64
Downrange
I've been toying with the idea of doing an AR build, but i still remain true to my favorite roots of the piston operated rifle.

However, when looking at piston driven upper assemblies, i have seen 2 separations. Attached OP rod, and floating spring-returned OP rod.

I was curious on those of you who've had the opportunity to mess around with both - What are your thoughts? What is the advantage of either, over the other?