Sidearms & Scatterguns Gen 5 Glocks
- Thread starter kingzero
- Start date
I'm underwhelmed by this. I'm a huge Glock fan but I can't for the life of me figure out why they would offer an ambi slide stop/release but not an ambi mag release? That is my biggest complaint of any Glock and probably one of my favorite features of HK (but not worth the HK prices).
Had a chance to shoot the 17 and 19 on Saturday. Nice guns, they shoot like Glocks.
Only drawback, besides the parts comparability thing... that slide treatment is super super smooth and slick. Slipperier than the Gen3 nonstick pan finish. I'm half-expecting some sort of revision to address either the traditionally-tepid serrations, or the slickness of the coating. For the ECQC crowd, maybe it's not a bad thing, especially with the beveled slide, muzzle-side. It's gonna be hard to stop this gun at contact distance.
Also noticed some mild slide peening developing on the range gun, 200 rounds in. Maybe this is from the return to a 2-pin system? Given Glock's stated intent not to offer the platform in 40SW, maybe this won't be a problem.
Only drawback, besides the parts comparability thing... that slide treatment is super super smooth and slick. Slipperier than the Gen3 nonstick pan finish. I'm half-expecting some sort of revision to address either the traditionally-tepid serrations, or the slickness of the coating. For the ECQC crowd, maybe it's not a bad thing, especially with the beveled slide, muzzle-side. It's gonna be hard to stop this gun at contact distance.
Also noticed some mild slide peening developing on the range gun, 200 rounds in. Maybe this is from the return to a 2-pin system? Given Glock's stated intent not to offer the platform in 40SW, maybe this won't be a problem.
If I'm reading the article right, the mag release is reversible like in the Gen 4s. You just have to choose which side you want it on.
I hope Glock isn't caving to the government demands trying to change a great gun to get a gov contract. I think that fix was already in. My guess is that's part of why the finger grooves are gone. I know some people hate them but I've not had any issues.
Regardless, I think it'll run like a Champ with Glock on it. Time will tell if I'm right.
The releases have always been interchangeable. But why not just make them ambidextrous? If you are accommodating lefties for the slide stop why not the mag release as well?
My guess is that the spring pin that gives the mag release tension can't give tension both directions. The current design has to be one way or the other. On my department, every lefty had shot with a right hand mag release for so long, they chose to keep that configuration. Years of muscle memory would be difficult to change. I certainly feel for left handed shooters especially with AR rifles. Some things just aren't easy.
I want one! There's enough refinement that I'd buy one in a heartbeat if I wasn't in California.
List of what is new:
Slide
Frame
Finish
Trigger bar
Connector
Trigger return spring (which is now more of an assembly)
Plunger (not sure if same as g43)
Slide release
Slide lock
Slide lock spring
Trigger housing
Locking block
Locking block pin
Striker
Barrel (Marksmanship Barrel)
Recoil spring assembly
List of what is new:
Slide
Frame
Finish
Trigger bar
Connector
Trigger return spring (which is now more of an assembly)
Plunger (not sure if same as g43)
Slide release
Slide lock
Slide lock spring
Trigger housing
Locking block
Locking block pin
Striker
Barrel (Marksmanship Barrel)
Recoil spring assembly
I never liked Glocks, always felt like they were behind the curve. The gen 2s my department still uses are almost the same as the gen 4s I've shot. The gen 5s looks live they've made a lot of worthwhile improvements. As long as the they're still reliable, they look great. A long time coming.
Shot them this last weekend. IMO, Not worth changing from Gen4's.
Negatives:
Wasnt more more accurate than my Gen4
Like the finger groves
Not at all happy about parts incompatibility with previous Gens
I like larger magwell than the Gen5 offers
Positives:
trigger does not stack
ambi slide release
I could see how this could be a good option as an issued gun if your agency does not allow any modifications at all, other than than IMO it's a non starter
Negatives:
Wasnt more more accurate than my Gen4
Like the finger groves
Not at all happy about parts incompatibility with previous Gens
I like larger magwell than the Gen5 offers
Positives:
trigger does not stack
ambi slide release
I could see how this could be a good option as an issued gun if your agency does not allow any modifications at all, other than than IMO it's a non starter
The grip looks nice, and i appreciate that they changed up the sights. I was never a big fan of the factory sights on the glocks. My 19 came with the factory threaded barrel, and i really like the factory suppressor sights glock used.
I like it! I have some Vickers sights that will replace the plastic ones this week.
[IMG2=JSON]{"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"http:\/\/i.imgur.com\/NokXHW6h.jpg"}[/IMG2]
[IMG2=JSON]{"data-align":"none","data-size":"full","src":"http:\/\/i.imgur.com\/NokXHW6h.jpg"}[/IMG2]
I really like the optional Ameriglo Bold Sights as well
Big fan of the Vickers sights here! Probably sticking with my Gen 4 though.
im surprised he didnt whip it at some steel plates then bitch when it broke.
people complaining that it "looks like the old glocks" dont understand what glock does........they dont see Gen1/2/3/4/5 as "new guns".......they see them as the same gun with revisions made to it.
think of it like a car.....a 2016 honda civic is more or less the same as a 2017 honda civic........but the 2017 is slightly updated..........its the same with glocks.
glock has a rock solid and proven design.....and their guns are selling.....they dont need to come out and reinvent the wheel with new models
Last edited:
you do realize the "perfection" is glocks "constant pursuit of perfection".......and not glock actually claiming their guns are perfect......right?
Forgot the sarcasm disclaimer. I'll take my foot off your nerve.
Why would firearm manufacturers be any different than other manufacturers? A salesman's job is to convince people their product is the best and not buying one will lead to an unsatisfying life, loss of sexual desire, poor skin health, etc, etc, etc...
