If you had your choice and money wasn't an issue, which would you buy?
- Thread starter WolverineAtWork
- Start date
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
Giraud, Dillon wouldnt even be a consideration
Giraud, Dillon wouldnt even be a consideration
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
Giraud hands down the best at any price.
fill out your profile
Giraud hands down the best at any price.
fill out your profile
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
Giraud is the only way to go-- perfect example of you get what you pay for.
Giraud is the only way to go-- perfect example of you get what you pay for.
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
I have had both.
I honed the Dillon sizing die to 0.336" for Lapua brass and it worked great. However, when I used other brands of brass, or ended up neck turning to get rid of some donuts, I had to do a second sizing to set the neck tension. Switched from the Dillon to the Giraud for greater flexibility.
Apples-to-apples, both are two operations. With the Dillon, you size/trim and then maybe do a light chamfer. With the Giraud, you size and then trim/chamfer/deburr. In the bigger picture, you aren't saving any operations with the Giraud. But, it does do a nicer job as the cut is more square. You can get a square cut with the Dillon with a LOT of fiddling.
If you weren't going to bother chamfering, it could be argued that the Dillon saves you an operation. You might do this for plinking ammo, but not for precision ammo. I wouldn't attempt to trim and then load the cases successively on a progressive though, as the Dillon trimmer often left quite a bit of shavings inside the cases.
I have had both.
I honed the Dillon sizing die to 0.336" for Lapua brass and it worked great. However, when I used other brands of brass, or ended up neck turning to get rid of some donuts, I had to do a second sizing to set the neck tension. Switched from the Dillon to the Giraud for greater flexibility.
Apples-to-apples, both are two operations. With the Dillon, you size/trim and then maybe do a light chamfer. With the Giraud, you size and then trim/chamfer/deburr. In the bigger picture, you aren't saving any operations with the Giraud. But, it does do a nicer job as the cut is more square. You can get a square cut with the Dillon with a LOT of fiddling.
If you weren't going to bother chamfering, it could be argued that the Dillon saves you an operation. You might do this for plinking ammo, but not for precision ammo. I wouldn't attempt to trim and then load the cases successively on a progressive though, as the Dillon trimmer often left quite a bit of shavings inside the cases.
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
Excellent gents, thank you.
Looks like the wife is getting me a Giraud for our 15th anniversary. Woohooo..
Excellent gents, thank you.
Looks like the wife is getting me a Giraud for our 15th anniversary. Woohooo..
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
I did, and chose the Giraud. No regrets!
I did, and chose the Giraud. No regrets!
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
Giraud....I toyed with the idea of the Dillon on my 650 but glad I made the right choice and bought the Giraud. Speaking of which, I need to go load some ammo!
John
Giraud....I toyed with the idea of the Dillon on my 650 but glad I made the right choice and bought the Giraud. Speaking of which, I need to go load some ammo!
John
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
I dont load enough to justify one, because my 308 cases simply dont require trimming often. But I had a Giraud, it is the GAP of reloading tools. Unreal the ease with which you can simply blow through cases. And they are ALL PERFECT. Great tool.
I can see the advantage of having something incorporated into the press though. Never tried the Dillon, but the Giraud is unreal. One of the few accessories I have ever seen live up to such major hype.
I dont load enough to justify one, because my 308 cases simply dont require trimming often. But I had a Giraud, it is the GAP of reloading tools. Unreal the ease with which you can simply blow through cases. And they are ALL PERFECT. Great tool.
I can see the advantage of having something incorporated into the press though. Never tried the Dillon, but the Giraud is unreal. One of the few accessories I have ever seen live up to such major hype.
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
Giraud all the way! Best piece of reloading equipment ever designed and the best money I've ever spent on reloading period! Get one, you won't be disappointed.
Giraud all the way! Best piece of reloading equipment ever designed and the best money I've ever spent on reloading period! Get one, you won't be disappointed.
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
For high volume, the Dillon is the way to go. I have mine on a 650 with the case feeder attached. I can resize and trim over 1200 cases per hour. A vacuum attached is a must, otherwise you will get the brass shavings mentioned earlier.
I do not have Giraud, but plan on getting one for 338 Lapua. 308 and 223 will continue to be done on the Dillon.
For high volume, the Dillon is the way to go. I have mine on a 650 with the case feeder attached. I can resize and trim over 1200 cases per hour. A vacuum attached is a must, otherwise you will get the brass shavings mentioned earlier.
I do not have Giraud, but plan on getting one for 338 Lapua. 308 and 223 will continue to be done on the Dillon.
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: BVEAL</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Giraud all the way! Best piece of reloading equipment ever designed and the best money I've ever spent on reloading period! Get one, you won't be disappointed. </div></div>
+100!
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: BVEAL</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Giraud all the way! Best piece of reloading equipment ever designed and the best money I've ever spent on reloading period! Get one, you won't be disappointed. </div></div>
+100!
Re: Giraud vs Dillon trimmer
I run the Dillon on my 650 for .223 and it works fantastic. However, that's mainly for AR use. For my .308 long range bolt gun ammo I'm trim by hand. If I ever do step up to a powered trimer for .308 I'll probably go with the Giraud.
I run the Dillon on my 650 for .223 and it works fantastic. However, that's mainly for AR use. For my .308 long range bolt gun ammo I'm trim by hand. If I ever do step up to a powered trimer for .308 I'll probably go with the Giraud.
