Hand primer comparison

[Pilotscrappy]

Wanted to get some info before I purchase a new hand priming tool.

I currently am using the hornady tool, and it's okay for large rifle but blows for small rifle.
I don't know why but I have nothing but problems when making AR ammo.

I have narrowed my choices down to the rcbs universal hand primer, and the Frankford arsenal unit.

I have watched some vids on both and I'm leaning towards the Frankford arsenal, it looks super easy to switch between small/large primers.

Does anyone have either of the units and are you happy with them etc?
Any input on which one you would get?
Thx

 

[Onyx Z]

The RCBS hand primer isn't all that great for LR primers IMO. It is uncomfortable to use and a PITA to swap between small and large primers.

 

[CBeck]

I’ve been using the rcbs with no complaints until I switched to small primer Creedmoor brass. It doesn’t center up well for some reason. I just picked up the Frankford but haven’t used it yet.

 

[12Bravo]

The RCBS hand primer isn't all that great for LR primers IMO. It is uncomfortable to use and a PITA to swap between small and large primers.

I've used a RCBS hand primer for years. I agree that it's uncomfortable to use (can raise blisters if you prime a few hundred cases in a sitting) and it is a bit of a pain to change between primer sizes of shellholders, but the unit is built like a tank. I've never had any problems with blown primers, jamming, etc.

 

[Bradu]

My rcbs hand primer with the shell holders is great. However, I helped a friend get started reloading and his sucked.

 

[rulellis]

I find my RCBS pretty consistent and like it well enough to prevent me from considering switching to something that may have problems. I like it way better than priming on a press.

 

[ken4570tc in WY]

I have both and would donate the RCBS to a good cause. The Frankford Arsenal allows me to dial-in the seating depth to match variations of primers. In fact, I'll be running a test to see how much compression of the anvil gives the most consistent ignition across several brands during load development. I intend to report my findings. I bought mine from Cabella's but was looking again for it today and noticed it wasn't available from there or Midway USA. I suspect that it is being revised to utilize a milder return spring. The original produces hand cramps and Popeye forearms.

 

[Pilotscrappy]

Okay good info thanks guys I think I'll get the Frankford and give it a shot, worst case I'm sure it won't be any shittier than my current hornady model lol