Rifle Scopes Need input on S&B reticle/ H58

[ssgp2]

I'm looking into the 5x25x56 PMII/LP/MTC and can't decide between the P4F or H58.

I have the H37 on my USO SN3 and the H58 looks like an improvement on an already good reticle.

I know what to expect out of the P4F and willing to go along with that one.
I would like some inputs from someone who use the H58.

Thanks

 

[ssgp2]

Re: Need input on S&B reticle/ H58

Anybody!?

 

[One-Eyed Jack]

Re: Need input on S&B reticle/ H58

If you like the H37 reticle and the S&B uses the locking MTC turrets that use a pull-up collar (as seen at the 2010 SHOT show), then go for the H58. I cannot imagine that the S&B locking turrets work well with a standard reticle like the P4F. When I tried those MTC turrets at SHOT, my fingers kept pushing down on the collar ring, which locked the turret at the same time I was attempting to rotate the knob. On the other hand, they were perfect for the Horus.

I would first choose between the H58 and the P4F, then get the appropriate turrets: locking MTC for the Horus, and standard double-turn for the P4F.