• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

new to AR -15 reloading

Hopar

Sergeant of the Hide
Full Member
Minuteman
Jan 18, 2023
105
56
SF Bay
I am getting ready to start reloading for my 15.

What dies do you recommend I get.


Rifle info:

JP bolt and BCG
Barrel Krieger 1:7.7 20" Wylde
Adjustable gas block
Aero precision lower and upper
Vortex Viper
 
I de-cap separately before cleaning with a dedicated de-capping die. If I don't have chambering issues, I'll use a full length (FL) sizing die. If I have issues or don't know which AR the ammo will be used in, I'll use a small base (SB) sizing die. If you're shooting precision, I'd look into a National Match die set with a micrometer seating die, but the barrel needs to be chambered for such. When I crimp, I use a separate crimping die.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I de-cap separately before cleaning with a dedicated de-capping die. If I don't have chambering issues, I'll use a full length (FL) sizing die. If I have issues or don't know which AR the ammo will be used in, I'll use a small base (SB) sizing die. If you're shooting precision, I'd look into a National Match die set with a micrometer seating die, but the barrel needs to be chambered for such. When I crimp, I use a separate crimping die.
What do you mean "chambered for national match"?

When sizing the neck, what is your tension so the bolt slam doesn't move the bullet forward? Or is that not an issue
 
How experienced are you at reloading? I've an old set of Hornady dies for thirty years. A few years back I got an RCBS X Die so I won't have to trim so much. In addition to dies I'd get this book.
 
Is crimping necessary for AR's?

I have loaded for my bolt 223 but never for a AR and I am fixing to start. Will be loading 77tmk's. I have read some say it is and some say it does not matter but this was years ago.
 
How experienced are you at reloading? I've an old set of Hornady dies for thirty years. A few years back I got an RCBS X Die so I won't have to trim so much. In addition to dies I'd get this book.

Been reloading for BA for about 4 years.
 
Aim for practical accuracy and I'd likely just start out with Hornady Custom dies, full length resize set, #546228. If you keep your brass sorted and don't use the expander ball, you can set the final tension with a neck-sizing mandrel from 21st Century Reloading. I'd still do a very light crimp with something like the Lee factory crimp die which can be used if you're not trimming each to the exact same length every time.

It's really no different than loading for bolt except you're often doing it in far greater numbers. Efficiency is the key and ultimately a progressive press is the way to go from a purely time standpoint. How much you do to the case is up to you. I've gone so far as to ream/unify the primer pocket of all my cases which can get very tedious. I usually trim as well. You can do less of course, whatever suits your goals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I'd actually avoid Redding. Their quality has gone downhill as of late. My last set of Redding dies were so tight that well-lubed cases were getting stuck in them and the amount of force needed to even insert the case was far beyond normal. Had to send them back.

Forester is really solid if you want to spend more than Hornady and have a high quality die that won't break the bank. I use those for the bolt gun stuff. But Hornady dies are priced right, ubiquitous, can get a micrometer for the seating die and they work as advertised. They'll produce sub-MOA ammo with them no problem. And if you screw one up, they're cheap to replace and the small parts are easy to find and stock.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ZA206 and Hopar
I'd actually avoid Redding. Their quality has gone downhill as of late. My last set of Redding dies were so tight that well-lubed cases were getting stuck in them and the amount of force needed to even insert the case was far beyond normal. Had to send them back.

Forester is really solid if you want to spend more than Hornady and have a high quality die that won't break the bank. I use those for the bolt gun stuff. But Hornady dies are priced right, ubiquitous, can get a micrometer for the seating die and they work as advertised. They'll produce sub-MOA ammo with them no problem. And if you screw one up, they're cheap to replace and the small parts are easy to find and stock.
I haven't seen that but the last set I bought was 458 SOCOM roughly 2 years ago and they are just dandy.

I use Hornady for pistol primarily, because its just pistol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I want to say mine was six months ago? But I have a bunch of Redding stuff and even their threading isn't up to the same level as Hornady let alone Forester.

The Forester stuff is like butter (still affordable too!) and is allegedly better for concentricity hence me using it for the bolt/precision stuff. But dies can be a deep rabbit hole and you can spend a ton of money on them. I waited for over a year to get a .308 silicone carbide resizing die from Dillon, LOL. That's like 1.5 suppressors at today's approval rates!

But seriously, I have multiple sets of the Hornady 223 dies for progressive, single stage, etc...and they've all been consistent with zero issues. I can swap them back and forth and nothing changes. I'd start out with simple, precise and inexpensive and see if it fits your needs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
@xsn10s can'tsee the book you mentioned.
It's "Black Magic: The Ultra Accurate AR-15" and you can get it on amazon. I use the RCBS X dies so I won't have to trim cases after the initial trimming. but you could also go for a bushing style competing dies set. That way if you want to load for 20 Practical you'll just need to get different bushings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I haven't needed small base dies. But they could be needed depending on the chamber. I think RCBS makes a small base X Die too. I'd say the biggest thing about loading for the AR15 is make sure you FL resize enough for your rifle. Some bump their shoulders .003-.004". Some just do a standard FL resize. I'd make sure to use semi auto loads and just use your head. Catastrophic failures are pretty explosive on AR's. So do some research and go slow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
If you going to load on a progressive press, cry once and buy a set of Dillon carbide dies. Omg they make resizing so much easier. Previously I had used a Redding small base sizing die.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
Any 223 dies will get the job done. If youre using new brass there's no need for small base dies(they eventually lead to brass failure if used too much). I like to control neck tension so i use redding or le wilson but i also have a set of lee deluxe 223 dies that work fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I hear that SBD may cause issues, but if the regular die doesn't size the brass enough, what other options do I have?
 
I hear that SBD may cause issues, but if the regular die doesn't size the brass enough, what other options do I have?
I'm not aware of any other options. But like I said earlier I haven't needed a SBD. My regular Hornady die works fine. As did my RCBS X die.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I hear that SBD may cause issues, but if the regular die doesn't size the brass enough, what other options do I have?
Wylde chamber reamer dimensions vary between manufacturers. As an example, I'll use the base diameters of two reputable manufacturers, JGS and Manson.
JGS .223 Wylde base diameter - 0.3810"
Manson .223 Wylde base diameter - 0.3777"
Small base dies are typically 0.003" smaller than a regular FL die. Whether you need one or not can come down to whose reamer the barrel maker used.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
I'd actually avoid Redding. Their quality has gone downhill as of late. My last set of Redding dies were so tight that well-lubed cases were getting stuck in them and the amount of force needed to even insert the case was far beyond normal. Had to send them back.

Forester is really solid if you want to spend more than Hornady and have a high quality die that won't break the bank. I use those for the bolt gun stuff. But Hornady dies are priced right, ubiquitous, can get a micrometer for the seating die and they work as advertised. They'll produce sub-MOA ammo with them no problem. And if you screw one up, they're cheap to replace and the small parts are easy to find and stock.
Agree. I got a set of 6.5CM dies from them last spring and the resizing die had to be sent back b/c of the same issues. Their QC has gone down immensely. I'd go with Hornady or Forster and get a micrometer seating die.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar
What do you mean "chambered for national match"?

When sizing the neck, what is your tension so the bolt slam doesn't move the bullet forward? Or is that not an issue

Here is my testing on if the bullet moves when chambering. (There are 3 videos, each seated differently and or crimped vs not).

AR Setback Test
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hopar