It’s possible that your hand guard is too thin. If the “keys” are bottoming out in the cutouts in the bottom of the rail before the top of the keys are completely snug against the inside of the handguard than the rail could remain loose even if tightened all the way. The obvious question is are you sure they are tightened all the way? My assumption is you wouldn’t be here asking if you hadn’t already made sure of that, so my guess is either the key mod rail is out of spec or the handguard is too thin. Vltor released the specs open source when they released keymod, but I guess that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re always followed. What kind of handguard is it?