• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

When is a dent in brass “too much”? PHOTOS

quikcolin

Sergeant of the Hide
Full Member
Minuteman
Dec 16, 2018
157
69
London, Ontario
Hey guys,

I have some 6.5cm Hornady brass used to break in my Stag10. While adjusting my gas block I chew up some of the brass a little bit.

These are the photos of the worst of it. I’m wondering (as a new reloader) when is a dent too bad to reload?

There are also some “scratches” on the neck of all rounds fired, as seen in photo.

Could I, SHOULD I reload this brass?
 

Attachments

  • D272887A-6884-4179-9621-2D42AF56B712.jpeg
    D272887A-6884-4179-9621-2D42AF56B712.jpeg
    288 KB · Views: 124
  • F70896B4-4FE3-43A6-8A0A-E97BE5750615.jpeg
    F70896B4-4FE3-43A6-8A0A-E97BE5750615.jpeg
    565.1 KB · Views: 125
  • 88FDF479-F3D7-432F-9BD8-80CB2E989B29.png
    88FDF479-F3D7-432F-9BD8-80CB2E989B29.png
    1.9 MB · Views: 136
  • 2D89C354-A420-4C52-AE2B-B894F6CC3FC8.png
    2D89C354-A420-4C52-AE2B-B894F6CC3FC8.png
    1.7 MB · Views: 120
Hell yeah. Load that shit up!! That's nothin. Your resizing die should iron out most of that stuff. If it doesn't.... Load anyway. That's fine, in my opinion. You do whatever you feel is right.
 
Any body dent that has sharp creases to it is an immediate reject. The concern there is that the brass has been plastically deformed in the crease and will rupture/crack after a few firings. But that's an extreme case.

Smooth, shallow dents like yours will iron out just fine as soon as you pull the trigger.
 
Any body dent that has sharp creases to it is an immediate reject. The concern there is that the brass has been plastically deformed in the crease and will rupture/crack after a few firings. But that's an extreme case.

Smooth, shallow dents like yours will iron out just fine as soon as you pull the trigger.
-----^ my brain meant to say this, but I'm far less eloquent than this guy.





More coffee.
 
Thanks so much guys! That’s a relief. I’m load it! So gas guns are a little more harsh on brass I take it (new shooter and reloader here).
 
Not an issue at all but use it for sighting in or foulers or just to fire form. After firing you will never see it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: quikcolin