• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

  • Site updates coming next Wednesday at 8am CT!

    The site will be down for routine maintenance on Wednesday 6/5 starting at 8am CT. If you have any questions, please PM alexj-12!

Question on Redding competition shell holders

A

Ape_Factory

Major Hide Member
Full Member
Minuteman
May 23, 2020
1,287
781
San Antonio, Texas
Looking at them, they're all "+" meaning if you raise the ram and tighten the die down to where it's touching, and that headspace is larger than what you're looking for, these won't help. Is that a correct assessment?

Just to clarify, and these are relatively random numbers, doing the above, I'd get a HS of 1.066 but I WANT 1.076. Assuming the Redding shell holders are not going to help.
 
You set the die to correctly locate the shoulder when sizing. Then you swap in shell holders that are higher topped than the standard holder so that the die hits the shell holder for solid contact every time.
 
In your example the +.010 would (should) give you exactly that 1.076 if your getting 1.066 with a normal (+.000) shell holder. Basically if your oversizing your brass and want less shoulder bump then the bigger the number on the shell holder then the less it bumps the shoulder.
 
I looked at these shell holders and concluded that they won't help in most situations. It just adds to the confusion. If your die gets put in place and never moved again, then maybe. Other than that you will have a slightly different die orientation every time you set up.

If you use the same shell holder each time is one thing to keep consistent. The other key factor is having a reliable way to measure progress.

I personally concluded that accurately measuring is a lot more valuable (and a better investment) than trying to get a shortcut with an expensive set of shell holders.
 
No. The shell holders are meant to decrease headspace. The + is how much more you can size your brass, in case your chamber is smaller than the die. If you want to increase the headspace, simply unscrew the die some.
 
jakelly said:
No. The shell holders are meant to decrease headspace. The + is how much more you can size your brass, in case your chamber is smaller than the die. If you want to increase the headspace, simply unscrew the die some.
Click to expand...
I guess I’m wrong about this and they’re designed to add headspace. I’ll have to look at mine again when I get home. What’s weird is I’m pretty sure more than half of my set was shorter than my standard RCBS holder.
 
I do use Hornady's comparator for shoulder and ogive and am addicted to measuring. Was just wondering if there was a reliable, repeatable way to get the same head space that didn't involve screwing in/unscrewing the die to set head space. Doesn't sound like there is.

If it works like spife says it would below, assuming that would add a bit of consistency to the headspacing process or no? I currently get a batch, out of say 1,000, that'll be off by a thousandth or two and have been lubing the die every 20 or 30 rounds from the top as I don't use the expander ball. Using the RCBS rock chucker press.

I'm really striving for consistency as I use a Geraud trimmer which goes off the shoulder when trimming.
spife7980 said:
You set the die to correctly locate the shoulder when sizing. Then you swap in shell holders that are higher topped than the standard holder so that the die hits the shell holder for solid contact every time.
Click to expand...
 
I think they work pretty well at maintaining consistency, IME having some cam over with the comp shell holders is more consistent then having the sizer screwed up off of a
shell holder.

The biggest advantage to me is when your loading for different rifles with the same dies and not having to adjust dies every time. I just write down in my loading book what # shell holder for that particular rifle/barrel and never move my dies.

They aren’t perfect, on one of my sets the +.002 and +.004 are more like .004 apart so In one of my 22-250’s my options are .001 or .005 of bump and in one of my other sets the +.010 is more like +.013 but it works good with some belted mags.
 
Anyone know how the shell holders fit into a Dillon 650? or a Forester single stage? I am guessing they dont from looking at the presses but they would be handy if they did.

Tks
 
Beating a dead Horse here but, for those who are still confused on how these Comp shell holders work, the standard deck height of a shell holder is .125". It is from the deck (where the base of the case sits, to the top of the shell holder).

The Comp shell holders lowers the deck height, in .002" increments giving longer datum to base numbers. So, from a .125" standard shell holder, The Comp shell holders go +.002"= .127", +.004= .129", +.006= .031", +.008= .133" and +.010= .135".

The deck is lowered, NOT the top of the shell holder, that remains the same so you get the same top of the shell holder to the bottom of the die contact.

You see how that works in the video in post #6.

If you have a die that will not give you SAAMI minimum at full cam over, the Comp shell holders will not work for you.

On one of my F/L dies, I can set SAAMI minimum with the +.006" shell holder. I'm then able to have .004" on either side of the +.006". This works for me with different brass and for brass that has been annealed, I can adjust shoulder bump without having to move the die.

With the #1 set Comp shell holders, I reload for 4-308 rifles, 260 Rem., 30/06, 270 Win. and 338/06. These shell holders give me flexibility with all of those cartridges.

Last year, I had an issue with a F/L die that wouldn't size down to SAAMI minimum. I sent the die back to the Mfg. who skimmed the die .009". When I got the die back, it worked fine. You can also sand down a regular S/H also.

I think someone already mentioned that there's no manufacturer that makes shell holders that that decreases the TOP of the shell holder.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: supercorndogs, obelisk57 and BassinDmax
FLIGHT762 said:
Beating a dead Horse here but, for those who are still confused on how these Comp shell holders work, the standard deck height of a shell holder is .125". It is from the deck (where the base of the case sits, to the top of the shell holder).

The Comp shell holders lowers the deck height, in .002" increments giving longer datum to base numbers. So, from a .125" standard shell holder, The Comp shell holders go +.002"= .127", +.004= .129", +.006= .031", +.008= .133" and +.010= .135".

The deck is lowered, NOT the top of the shell holder, that remains the same so you get the same top of the shell holder to the bottom of the die contact.

You see how that works in the video in post #6.

If you have a die that will not give you SAAMI minimum at full cam over, the Comp shell holders will not work for you.

On one of my F/L dies, I can set SAAMI minimum with the +.006" shell holder. I'm then able to have .004" on either side of the +.006". This works for me with different brass and for brass that has been annealed, I can adjust shoulder bump without having to move the die.

With the #1 set Comp shell holders, I reload for 4-308 rifles, 260 Rem., 30/06, 270 Win. and 338/06. These shell holders give me flexibility with all of those cartridges.

Last year, I had an issue with a F/L die that wouldn't size down to SAAMI minimum. I sent the die back to the Mfg. who skimmed the die .009". When I got the die back, it worked fine. You can also sand down a regular S/H also.

I think someone already mentioned that there's no manufacturer that makes shell holders that that decreases the TOP of the shell holder.
Click to expand...
If I buy the competition shell holder set, is there still a need to get a Reddings standard shell holder? Do you use the standard Redding shell holder at all after you got your competition set? Also I already have RCBS and Lee shell holders for the same caliber, although I know they have difference in dimensions.
 
obelisk57 said:
If I buy the competition shell holder set, is there still a need to get a Reddings standard shell holder? Do you use the standard Redding shell holder at all after you got your competition set? Also I already have RCBS and Lee shell holders for the same caliber, although I know they have difference in dimensions.
Click to expand...
Technically you can use whatever shell holder you want for your other dies you just have to use that same one every time. I use a regular shell holder for decapping and bullet seating. Easier to remember that rather than one of the 5 competition sizes.
 
Ckleeves said:
I think they work pretty well at maintaining consistency, IME having some cam over with the comp shell holders is more consistent then having the sizer screwed up off of a
shell holder.

The biggest advantage to me is when your loading for different rifles with the same dies and not having to adjust dies every time. I just write down in my loading book what # shell holder for that particular rifle/barrel and never move my dies.

They aren’t perfect, on one of my sets the +.002 and +.004 are more like .004 apart so In one of my 22-250’s my options are .001 or .005 of bump and in one of my other sets the +.010 is more like +.013 but it works good with some belted mags.
Click to expand...

Mauser48 said:
Technically you can use whatever shell holder you want for your other dies you just have to use that same one every time. I use a regular shell holder for decapping and bullet seating. Easier to remember that rather than one of the 5 competition sizes.
Click to expand...
But during shoulder bumping, which is the only reason why I would get these competition shell holders, does the standard shell holder come into usage at all? Do you use it to set up shoulder bumping? I am debating whether I should buy a Redding standard .125 shell holder if I already have two other brands of shell holders for the same caliber.
 
obelisk57 said:
But during shoulder bumping, which is the only reason why I would get these competition shell holders, does the standard shell holder come into usage at all? Do you use it to set up shoulder bumping? I am debating whether I should buy a Redding standard .125 shell holder if I already have two other brands of shell holders for the same caliber.
Click to expand...
You could set up the die with any of the competition shell holders and adjust your bump as necessary with the different sizes. The overall height of the shell holder is the same on all the redding competitions, the difference is where the case head actually sits inside the shell holder. I set the die up with the .010 shell holder (holds the case farther away from the die) and work my way in until the desired bump is achieved. So no, you don't need a standard shell holder for sizing.
 
obelisk57 said:
But during shoulder bumping, which is the only reason why I would get these competition shell holders, does the standard shell holder come into usage at all? Do you use it to set up shoulder bumping? I am debating whether I should buy a Redding standard .125 shell holder if I already have two other brands of shell holders for the same caliber.
Click to expand...
Just think of the standard .125 shellholder as another shoulder bump step option. The Redding +2 SH is .127 and if that happens to size a case with the base-to-shoulder datum measurement .002 longer than what you want, then that means the standard .125 SH is just right.
 
Last edited:
Mauser48 said:
You could set up the die with any of the competition shell holders and adjust your bump as necessary with the different sizes. The overall height of the shell holder is the same on all the redding competitions, the difference is where the case head actually sits inside the shell holder. I set the die up with the .010 shell holder (holds the case farther away from the die) and work my way in until the desired bump is achieved. So no, you don't need a standard shell holder for sizing.
Click to expand...

Unless you have a Forster sizing die and several of my rifles.
 
Marine52 said:
Just think of the standard .125 shellholder as another shoulder bump step option. The Redding +2 SH is .127 and if that happens to size a case with the base-to-shoulder datum measurement .002 longer than what you want, then that means the standard .125 SH is just right.
Click to expand...
I haven't received my Redding competition SH set I just ordered. What prompted me to ask this question is that but when I set up the .002 shoulder bump for my 7mm08 using the standard Lee SH, but accidentally switched to the RCBS SH, the bump increased to .004-.005. So obviously these SH's are not the same. But now I know, I should have stuck with the same SH. So using your example, hypothetically, if the +.002 (.127) Redding SH is .002 too long, and I DON'T have a standard Redding .125 would either RCBS or Lee .125 SH work? Or I need to buy a Redding standard SH to accomplish that? Thanks again.
 
No, you don't need to buy a standard Redding shell holder. Use the 2 (Lee & RCBS) shell holders you already have. There can be a little variation in standard shell holders as you found out. As long as you're getting the shoulder bump you need, you're good. You just adjust your die.

If you can't get enough bump with a regular shell holder, you have to either skim off the bottom of the F/L die or take a standard shell holder and sand off a few thousandths off of the top. It doesn't happen a lot, but it can happen. I had it happen on one die I have. I sent the die back to the Mfg. who skimmed .008" off of the bottom of the die. The die worked properly after that.
 
FLIGHT762 said:
No, you don't need to buy a standard Redding shell holder. Use the 2 (Lee & RCBS) shell holders you already have. There can be a little variation in standard shell holders as you found out. As long as you're getting the shoulder bump you need, you're good. You just adjust your die.

If you can't get enough bump with a regular shell holder, you have to either skim off the bottom of the F/L die or take a standard shell holder and sand off a few thousandths off of the top. It doesn't happen a lot, but it can happen. I had it happen on one die I have. I sent the die back to the Mfg. who skimmed .008" off of the bottom of the die. The die worked properly after that.
Click to expand...
Awesome! Thanks for the feedback.
 
obelisk57 said:
I haven't received my Redding competition SH set I just ordered. What prompted me to ask this question is that but when I set up the .002 shoulder bump for my 7mm08 using the standard Lee SH, but accidentally switched to the RCBS SH, the bump increased to .004-.005. So obviously these SH's are not the same. But now I know, I should have stuck with the same SH. So using your example, hypothetically, if the +.002 (.127) Redding SH is .002 too long, and I DON'T have a standard Redding .125 would either RCBS or Lee .125 SH work? Or I need to buy a Redding standard SH to accomplish that? Thanks again.
Click to expand...
I think you may have answered your own question. The RCBS and Lee SH’s in theory are .125 exact but can be out of spec. I would go ahead and get a standard Redding SH. They’re only a few bucks. And yes, once you have a die set up and have the bump you want, don’t switch shellholders.
 
@obelisk57. This thread is old and the info below is pretty much a summary of earlier posts but I hope it helps.

There is so much confusion on the use of Redding comp shellholders. Primarily because of Redding’s worthless description/instructions on their use

From Redding: “ Each shellholder has a distinct black oxide finish and is clearly marked to indicate the amount it will decrease case-to-chamber headspace”. What? totally incomprehensible.

The Comp Shellholders sold by Redding and the modular Shellholders from Area 419 work the same way. They lower the floor of the shellholder that the case base sits on. So for one marked +4, the floor is dropped 0.004” and generates a sized case with 0.004” less bump (longer base-to-datum length) relative to a standard .125” shellholder. This difference is important because you don’t have to touch the die to see the change and you can adjust bump w/o having the die in firm solid contact with the shellholder. However, many of us like that solid contact and these comp shellholders can be interchanged w/o adjusting the die because the shellholder shelf that contacts the die is not shifted.

Note: if you are not getting sufficient bump (ie your case base-to-shoulder datum measurement is longer than you want and you have firm die-to-shellholder contact (camover), then these comp shellholders will not help, with one exception: The Modular Shellholder kit from Area 419 does come with a -2 insert which reduces the shellholder depth to .123, effectively giving you .002” more bump than a standard SH.

The diagram and the numbers below were produced by a New Zealand shooter on another forum using his Mitutoyo micrometer. The column “headspace effect” really should read “shoulder setback effect.”
 

Attachments

  • Redding Competition Shellholder.JPG
    Redding Competition Shellholder.JPG
    177.1 KB · Views: 31
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Holliday, obelisk57, FredHammer and 1 other person
Marine52 said:
@obelisk57.

From Redding: “ Each shellholder has a distinct black oxide finish and is clearly marked to indicate the amount it will decrease case-to-chamber headspace”. What? totally incomprehensible.
Click to expand...

What’s so hard to understand about that? Reloading requires the user to understand what headspace is and how a shell holder and sizing die interact. If a person is unable to figure that out they have no business reloading especially with specialized tools.
 
918v said:
What’s so hard to understand about that? Reloading requires the user to understand what headspace is and how a shell holder and sizing die interact. If a person is unable to figure that out they have no business reloading especially with specialized tools.
Click to expand...

I know what rifle chamber headspace is and I know what case base-to-shoulder datum length is. But how do you decrease case-to-chamber headspace? I’ve never heard of this term. I‘m ready to learn. Show me a reference in a known loading guide, manual, or any quote from a reputable shooter who uses this term. Redding’s use of the term decrease is unfortunate because many new reloaders see that term and think these shellholders somehow help to decrease the case shoulder datum relative to the chamber headspace when compared to a standard .125 shellholder. Also, the comp shellholders are universal and not related to your rifle’s headspace. They are directly related to the standard .125 shellholder and the numbers show the INCREASE in case base-to-shoulder datum measurements when compared to the standard SH.
 
They increase shoulder length which in turn decreases headspace which is the SPACE between the caseHEAD and the breech face.
 
Marine52 said:
@obelisk57. This thread is old and the info below is pretty much a summary of earlier posts but I hope it helps.

There is so much confusion on the use of Redding comp shellholders. Primarily because of Redding’s worthless description/instructions on their use

From Redding: “ Each shellholder has a distinct black oxide finish and is clearly marked to indicate the amount it will decrease case-to-chamber headspace”. What? totally incomprehensible.

The Comp Shellholders sold by Redding and the modular Shellholders from Area 419 work the same way. They lower the floor of the shellholder that the case base sits on. So for one marked +4, the floor is dropped 0.004” and generates a sized case with 0.004” less bump (longer base-to-datum length) relative to a standard .125” shellholder. This difference is important because you don’t have to touch the die to see the change and you can adjust bump w/o having the die in firm solid contact with the shellholder. However, many of us like that solid contact and these comp shellholders can be interchanged w/o adjusting the die because the shellholder shelf that contacts the die is not shifted.

Note: if you are not getting sufficient bump (ie your case base-to-shoulder datum measurement is longer than you want and you have firm die-to-shellholder contact (camover), then these comp shellholders will not help, with one exception: The Modular Shellholder kit from Area 419 does come with a -2 insert which effectively reduces the shellholder depth to .123, giving you .002” more bump than a standard SH.

The diagram and the numbers below were produced by a New Zealand shooter on another forum using his Mitutoyo micrometer. The column “headspace effect” really should read “shoulder setback effect.”
Click to expand...
Thanks for such a detailed explanation!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marine52
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

B
Reloading Equipment Redding Competition Shell Holder Set .308 WIN P/N 11601
Replies
2
Views
397
981kirk
981kirk
roosterpig
Help Needed - Sticky Bolt CLOSE
Replies
174
Views
4K
FLIGHT762
FLIGHT762
A
Effing Redding dies
Replies
119
Views
4K
smoothy8500
smoothy8500
D
Beginner - need equipment recommendations and advice
Replies
104
Views
3K
SporterII
S
750SS
Accessories FS - Hodge Podge of Reloading Stuff
Replies
10
Views
1K
tacguns
T
Top Bottom
Back