• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

Surgeon VS Gap for 6.5 creedmoor

M

mmmmm

Guest
Hello, I'm going to be purchasing one of these guns in the next week and would like to know hands on experience from either. I'm for sure going to get it in 6.5 creedmoor. Both seem like good people to deal with. Next thing I would like to add is I for sure want a JAE700 stock. They feel and look amazing. That puts GAP in a bind a little bit because they don't keep any on hand so i would have to get a stock from j allen? prabobly a year I'm guessing? then wait another 6 months or so for GAP to build off of it.

Surgeon list J Allen stocks and I received an email today claiming 10 months for them to build one.

Do you the Estimated time of arrivals are accurate or am I going to be waiting a year and half on Surgeon? Bottom line GAP or Surgeon? And anyone know of anywhere quicker to get a JAE700 stock?

Thanks for your time, Patrick.
 
I own rifles from both companies and can tell you either one will do it right. Don't be afraid to pick up the phone and call them before you decide. Wait time and availability of the parts you want will make the decision for you I think.
 
Can't you just get another stock while you wait?

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2
 
I have called both company's and have been very impressed with both as far as customer service.

I guess I could get another stock but I'm not gunless right now. I rather just have the exact one i want built from the get-go. I still have a Savage 10 BA that will shoot half moa to quarter inch. Just human nature to always want the best i guess!
 
You will love either one. If you are set on the JAE then let Surgeon build you one. They are the only builders that I have seen turn out multiple builds using them. If Surgeon has some on order/incoming I would think that's your quickest option.
 
I have a surgeon .260 and GAP 6.5 CM Neither is anything short of amazing. No hesitation from me either way. And actually, they are my 2 favs. Other people can build guns and can be just as accurate, But those 2 have a great track record. But that's no secret either. Good luck
 
The JAE 700 just started to roll out. I know ordering right now is a year wait. Only way to get one faster is hope you find someone selling it and that will be rare.
 
I have a ga crusader 6..5 and it has produced .95" 10 shot groups at 520 yards. I wouldn't trade it for the world.
2B7E1B24-F195-4507-BE06-A10E60D1C44B-938-00000079C796B323_zps9015d301.jpg

E8ABE749-E2B0-4CBD-8DDB-08D8D1E13F4A-357-0000002B7A0C2C83_zpsee24e4b5.jpg
 
Last I heard, Surgeon has suspended all orders due to a massive backlog. You may have a tuff time getting something from them at this point in time.
 
Have had a GAP 6.5 Creedmoor for longer than anyone and I know I can say that as ours were the first ones they built in 2008. GAP's work is second to none and the rifles they build are very accurate. Highly recommend them.
 
Thank you all for all your input. Going to do some more reading and make my final decision soon. Keep the opinions coming!
 
For my 100th post, I thought I would participate in a thread that I can really lend some solid "experience" to. I have been reading and lurking on SH for well over 3 years. I just joined last year so I could make sure nobody else used my screen name, and because I figured it was time to start asking questions. I felt that I had searched enough, read enough and learned enough about how you guys operate that I had paid my dues and would not be a "newb" burden to the sometimes cantankerous long timers I have seen unload on folks here. I am still learning, but I love this place and feel like there is a shitload to learn here.

That being said, I have direct experience with 2 out of the 3 items the OP mentions in his initial post, so I can share from a place of experience and not speculation. Here goes.

The JAE 700 just started to roll out. I know ordering right now is a year wait. Only way to get one faster is hope you find someone selling it and that will be rare.

I would suggest this (finding one used) will be EXTREMELY rare, because I can't see anyone who waited as long as you have to wait to get one, being even marginally disappointed enough with it to sell it anytime soon. I ordered 2 of them when I ordered. I waited the time I was required to wait and then I built the rifles I wanted to build around them. I will NOT be selling either one of mine anytime soon. If any of you are motorcycle enthusiasts, then you will remember when the Ducati 916 first came to America. It was like a fine piece of art. I was a motorcycle racer back then, and was partially sponsored by Suzuki. I wanted a 916 but had to wait until the 996 came out to buy one. I did, and it was like owning a fine piece of Italian art. I would have never sold that bike. It was just that bitchen. Mine was stolen 2 years after I bought it and I was gutted. Unless someone steals my JAE's, I will own them for a very long time. See pics below.

Last I heard, Surgeon has suspended all orders due to a massive backlog. You may have a tuff time getting something from them at this point in time.

The first rifle I wanted to build around the JAE was a Surgeon Scalpel. It could equally be argued the only chassis I could dream of resting a work of art like the Scalpel in was a JAE. The Surgeon is just that bitchen too. Call me weird, artsy, a fag or whatever you want, but I like nice things and I am willing to pay the price. A Surgeon Scalpel resting in a JAE-700 is no less bitchen than my Ducati 996 was, and I had it (the 996) dressed out in all of the carbon fiber bad assness (including Termignoni exhaust) that you could get at the time. (again, see pics below).

Next, I had a major dilemma. I had another JAE-700 that needed a mate. Since I already had a flagship rifle, with a flagship action and all of the good stuff that goes along with it, I decided to do a custom Remington 700 build because I needed to see just how close a factory action could come to measuring up to the Surgeon. Yes I could have sold off some toys to pay for another top shelf action, or purchased another Surgeon, but I felt that would have been silly. Why not prove to myself that a good R700 touched by the golden hands of a solid builder (machinist) could be just as good if not better than a fancy high brow barreled action? That was it. I had my mind set and was on a mission.

I called several builders, all of whom are held in high regard here on the Hide, and I settled on Chad Dixon from Long Rifles Inc. From the get go, I knew Chad was the real deal. He spoke the language I spoke (hot rods, race bikes and machine tools). His advertised turn around time was wayyyyyyy acceptable, and his attitude was bad ass. We clicked, and I knew he was going to get my money. He knew it too. I had a new (Bartlien 5r 1:10) barrel that I had previously secured from Bugholes in hand, and had a bone stock Remington 700 SPS tactical with 60 rounds down the pipe ready to come apart and be sent his way that night. He had it all in his hands 3 days later, and I had a Jewel trigger drop shipped to him from Brownells the following day. I also sent Chad a dummy .308 round that I built with a Hornady 178 BTHP seated to the lands in my Surgeon, so that he could match the chamber on the new build as close as possible so that I could potentially share rounds between these 2 rifles. The clock was ticking.

Long story short, a short time later, I had my new barreled action, (which was the first action to come off Chad's new bad ass machine center) in my hands, and that night it was mounted in the 2nd JAE-700 chassis. It is a thing of beauty. (see pics below).

I am going to do a full range report write up in the next few days on the Long Rifles rig, but I am going to wait for the 2nd range trip so I can confirm a few things before I do. The bottom line is that with 150 rounds down the pipe on it's first outing, being hardly broken in, this fucking thing is a laser beam. It truly is ungodly accurate, and is nothing short of amazing.

What I am trying to get across to you here, is that you might just want to reconsider the long wait on a custom action build. Get a Remington 700 in any flavor you want, order a barrel from Bugholes, send it all to Chad and buckle your fucking seat belt. He hung the barrel, blueprinted the action, chambered it with a Bisley Palma match reamer, fluted the bolt, installed the side bolt release mod, trued up and enlarged the scope mount holes, cerakoted the whole deal with 2 different colors, installed the Jewel trigger, test fired it and had it back in my hands in record time. All while setting up 2 new machines, and taking phone calls from me every other day because I am OCD and need my hand held sometimes.

In summation, I love the JAE-700's, I love the Surgeon and I love (no homo) Chad Dixon from Long Rifles Inc. The only thing I will say right here and now is that neither one of these rifles is any better than the other as far as accuracy is concerned with me pulling the trigger. I have exactly 800 rounds down range through the Surgeon and exactly 150 rounds down range through the LRI build. If history holds true and these rifles get more accurate with more rounds down range, then my Surgeon is going to be in trouble soon as far as "favorite" rifle status is concerned.

If that happens, I will not really be surprised. Chad is just that good.

If this feels a little like thread jacking, please forgive me. I just wanted to share my experience with 2 out of the 3 things you have on your list sir...... Here are some pics:

<img src="http://www.boogalootactical.com/pics/JAE%20Rifles/IMG_3370.jpg">

<img src="http://www.boogalootactical.com/pics/JAE%20Rifles/IMG_3372.jpg">

<img src="http://www.boogalootactical.com/pics/JAE%20Rifles/IMG_3375.jpg">

<img src="http://www.boogalootactical.com/pics/JAE%20Rifles/IMG_3376.jpg">

<img src="http://www.boogalootactical.com/pics/JAE%20Rifles/IMG_3378.jpg">

<img src="http://www.boogalootactical.com/pics/JAE%20Rifles/IMG_3381.jpg">


P.S. In case you just can't tell the difference, the Coyote Tan and black rifle is the Surgeon, and the Black on Black w/Tungsten bolt is the Long Rifles Inc. build.
They are both Ducati 996's in my opinion. One is Ducati Red and the other is Ducati Yellow (ya gotta be a biker to get that one).
 
Last edited:
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR WRITE UP!!!! That was well put together, I appreciate it! I ended up calling Surgeon today and ordering my dream gun. I have no doubt that a REM700 in the hands of a good builder could match a Surgeon, but for whatever stupid reason I just want in my head that I'm working with possibly one of the best made rifles ever. And if I miss I KNOW it will be my fault lol. I dont think I can be much more accurate than quarter inch groups at 100 but we will see. My savage 10 BA in 6.5 can get quarter inch and if I was smart I would have just kept shooting it, but I just wanted my first high end Bolt gun.
 
Why isn't APA a choice? I've owned all 3 before and can honestly say that all are great......but Jered is most definitely going to be my choice from now on. It's just the one on one experience with him & his OCD attention to detail that I like. Plus, he designs and builds some wonderful precision rifle parts. He just doesn't put parts together with skill
 
I switched over to surgeon actions for all of my serious rifles. I own 2 Surgeon built rifles + a Surgeon action rifle built by Dana English.

Having owned 2 GAPs previously, I can say that function and accuracy are indistinguishable between the two builders.

The 260 I had built by Surgeon had a somewhat choppy job in the stock's bolt inlet. Its really unfair that I mention this because
I'm sure Surgeon would fix it ASAP. The GAP 260 I had was somewhat fussy when stuffing a mag in it when hurried (my fault...perhaps).
I shoot the piss out of my guns if I can, so cosmetics mean very little to me.

You can find threads where LowLight (and others) are critical of Surgeon actions. My experience is that the are awesome, NEVER a problem.
 
I buy my rifles to rub against when my wife is away so looks matter to me
 
You are going to find fan boys on either side of the fence. Both builders are reputable and some of the opinions you get here are not formed with the best of information. It is easy to tell who is the fan boy of what is so be assured that it will come down to lead time, price, and cool factor for determining your purchase.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2
 
You are going to find fan boys on either side of the fence. Both builders are reputable and some of the opinions you get here are not formed with the best of information. It is easy to tell who is the fan boy of what is so be assured that it will come down to lead time, price, and cool factor for determining your purchase.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2

I agree with the fan boy thing. I am just saying, if you stay in this sport long enough you will find your favorite builder eventually. As I stated all are great builders, just make sure you go with a well established builder with a solid reputation. Don't let lead time be the ultimate factor in your decision. The reason why their lead times are so great is because the attention to detail and reputations keep them busy. Other builders besides Surgeon Rifles & GAP that i've either owned or shot and was extremely happy with are APA, SAC, & Gradous. Yes there are others but this is what I have hands on with
 
You can't go wrong with the Surgeon or GAP. I see you decided on Surgeon. I have one from them in 6.5 creedmoor and it loves factory 140 amax. I have shot a few groups under a 1/4 at a 100, but I don't shoot paper very much so I am not sure if it will do it consistently with the factory stuff. I can tell you if you miss it is your fault. I have had a few groups at a 1000 that had me in disbelief. Mine likes 142 smk, 42.7 H4350, with a .02 jump.
 
I agree with the fan boy thing. I am just saying, if you stay in this sport long enough you will find your favorite builder eventually. As I stated all are great builders, just make sure you go with a well established builder with a solid reputation. Don't let lead time be the ultimate factor in your decision. The reason why their lead times are so great is because the attention to detail and reputations keep them busy. Other builders besides Surgeon Rifles & GAP that i've either owned or shot and was extremely happy with are APA, SAC, & Gradous. Yes there are others but this is what I have hands on with

Or their lead times are long because they poor boy it and run a $5-6M business like they are still running it out of their garage. Some guys choose this route and let you know up front and others act like big companies but yet they can't (or wont) tell you the status of your order. When you pay $5000 for what is essentially a high priced toy, you expect service. I won't deal with unprofessional businesses and if they want to act that way they should stay in the garage.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2
 
I agree with you and disagree at the same time. Again find a reputable builder for the best possible outcome. As for long lead times several factors affect the inconsistent lead times, such barrel makers, chassis/stock makers, action makers, trigger builders, etc. Once they receive the parts remember some of these shops are just one or two man operations and they are more than just machinists. I consider them modern day artisans who have mastered their skill craft, journeymen by trade. Precision rifles take lengthy precision work. Any asshole can run a lathe, I've seen it. But it takes a master trades man to build a one off custom rifle that is capable of precision shots at the ranges some of us engage targets at. If you want the best possible product made out of the best possible materials using time tested old techniques it takes time, i.e. cut rifling, custom reamed chambers, polished trigger jobs, precise bedding, etc. If waiting is a problem, you can easily by a Remington 5r with a track record of .5-1 moa out of the box accuracy. But when we get to repeatable "precision long range engagements" you are going to have to pay and wait for that true .25-.5 moa repeatable rifle.
 
Can't go wrong with either. I have a GAP Crusader and a Surgeon 7wsm. Both are great. I think the only difference in accuracy is the time I spent for load development and the inherent differences in the calibers. As far as quality both are top notch.
 
I agree. The gun business is loaded with unprofessional businesses. GAP and Surgeon are not unprofessional however.

Custom pistol smiths as a group, are the worst IMO.

Or their lead times are long because they poor boy it and run a $5-6M business like they are still running it out of their garage. Some guys choose this route and let you know up front and others act like big companies but yet they can't (or wont) tell you the status of your order. When you pay $5000 for what is essentially a high priced toy, you expect service. I won't deal with unprofessional businesses and if they want to act that way they should stay in the garage.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2
 
Thank you all, my biggest wait will be the j allen stock but it will be worth it! Its gonna look and feel amazing! I cant wait to get it! In the meantime my savage 10 BA is drilling 1000 yard targets so I'll be practicing!
 
Just thought of this but if you aren't afraid to wait you may want to talk to APA.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2
 
Go with the builder who gives you the shortest wait time. When you get into the top 2% stratosphere of builders your considering, you could (quite literally) flip a coin on which one to go with. I have an RWS Gunsmithing 338 LM built by Robert and would recommend him without reservation as well.