308 Shoulder Measurement

RackOpsTactical

In God We Trust, All Others Bring Data
Full Member
Minuteman
Oct 27, 2018
399
68
New to 308 loading (not reloading in general) and haven't seen this before. did an initial string of 18 1 round groups of 39.6 gr Varget to 43.0 in .2 gr increments. found a couple of flat spots and picked 41.9. Shooting a Savage model 10 24" brl.

So did a string of 10 rds using Lapua brass, 2.800 COAL, 178 Gr Hornady ELD-M, CCI BR-2, 41.9 gr Varget. I got an average velocity of 2570 with an SD of 8.6.

this was all done with virgin brass which had been mandrel sized only.

I was expecting these 30 rounds to fire form the brass. Before and after firing I used the RCBS precision mic (which I like better than the hornady headspace comparator). however i get exactly the same readings of -0.001 to -0.002 before firing and after firing. even with the "hot" 43.0 load. All of the fired cases fit just fine into my LE Wilson case gauge.

I guess what i'm asking is why am I getting the same reading before and after firing? Only thing i can think of is that the chamber is the exact size of the Lapua brass.
 
-.001 to -.002 is probably your chamber size. Here are my thoughts - your mileage may vary.

I use the RCBS device for measuring case length. When I use new-ish brass, I get the same result you do - measure before, get -.001 to -.002. Shoot it. Measure it again, get -.001 to -.002 because that is my chamber size. I always get this result with my 300 win mag brass. If you shoot it enough without FL sizing, it will start to measure 0 then .001 then maybe .002. I would be a bit surprised to see it get longer than .002.

When I am sizing, I put the rifle in a cleaning rest next to the press. I use a tool to remove the firing pin assembly from the bolt. I size a case then wipe the lube off and chamber it with the mostly bare bolt. If I drop the bolt handle, I want it to stop by itself between half and 3/4 of the way down and then close with one finger. If am really fussy, I will also remove the ejector plunger.

I have two remington 700 308s. Brass fired in one gun measures almost exactly 0.000 with the RCBS gauge. Brass fired in the other gun measures -.002. If I make brass for the longer chamber, then put it into the gun with the shorter chamber the bolt will still close in the shorter chamber but it requires a little effort - more than 1 finger. And it shoots great. I moved a scope today and shot a .440 7-shot group with ammo like that - all of the bullet holes fit on a .750 square. I know some of you guys regularly get groups better than that - for me this was good.

When I made the shorter chamber, the bare bolt almost closed on my headspace gauge so, I just use my headspace gauge to set up my die. Insert the case holder into the press, insert the headspace gauge into the case holder, lower the handle, back off the die lock ring, screw the die in until it contacts the headspace gauge, raise the handle, while holding the die in position run the lock ring down, turn the die into the press a tenth of a turn (.007) then tighten the set-screw and lock the ring. Remove the die from the press, put a .005 shim under the lock ring and hand tighten. Here is the math - chamber length minus .007 plus .005 equals chamber length minus .002. Size a piece of brass, wipe off the lube, try it in the gun. It will probably be a little too long - the bolt handle won't drop far enough. Using a new piece of brass and a .004 shim, try again. It will probably be perfect. If I measure that piece of brass with the RCBS gauge, it will probably measure -.002 or -.003.
 
-.001 to -.002 is probably your chamber size. Here are my thoughts - your mileage may vary.

I use the RCBS device for measuring case length. When I use new-ish brass, I get the same result you do - measure before, get -.001 to -.002. Shoot it. Measure it again, get -.001 to -.002 because that is my chamber size. I always get this result with my 300 win mag brass. If you shoot it enough without FL sizing, it will start to measure 0 then .001 then maybe .002. I would be a bit surprised to see it get longer than .002.

When I am sizing, I put the rifle in a cleaning rest next to the press. I use a tool to remove the firing pin assembly from the bolt. I size a case then wipe the lube off and chamber it with the mostly bare bolt. If I drop the bolt handle, I want it to stop by itself between half and 3/4 of the way down and then close with one finger. If am really fussy, I will also remove the ejector plunger.

I have two remington 700 308s. Brass fired in one gun measures almost exactly 0.000 with the RCBS gauge. Brass fired in the other gun measures -.002. If I make brass for the longer chamber, then put it into the gun with the shorter chamber the bolt will still close in the shorter chamber but it requires a little effort - more than 1 finger. And it shoots great. I moved a scope today and shot a .440 7-shot group with ammo like that - all of the bullet holes fit on a .750 square. I know some of you guys regularly get groups better than that - for me this was good.

When I made the shorter chamber, the bare bolt almost closed on my headspace gauge so, I just use my headspace gauge to set up my die. Insert the case holder into the press, insert the headspace gauge into the case holder, lower the handle, back off the die lock ring, screw the die in until it contacts the headspace gauge, raise the handle, while holding the die in position run the lock ring down, turn the die into the press a tenth of a turn (.007) then tighten the set-screw and lock the ring. Remove the die from the press, put a .005 shim under the lock ring and hand tighten. Here is the math - chamber length minus .007 plus .005 equals chamber length minus .002. Size a piece of brass, wipe off the lube, try it in the gun. It will probably be a little too long - the bolt handle won't drop far enough. Using a new piece of brass and a .004 shim, try again. It will probably be perfect. If I measure that piece of brass with the RCBS gauge, it will probably measure -.002 or -.003.

Thank you for this reply.

When loading do you set your resize die to the -0.002 or do you go past that to like -.003 or 4? I don't crimp so i'm just concerned about how to set neck tension if the die isn't touching the case after firing.
 
The die is touching the case after firing. It reduces the body diameter and pushes the shoulder back.

Yes of course. what i'm asking is: because the case after firing still fits in the case gauge it doesn't need the body diameter or shoulder touched. however i want it to move back a bit so that it retains neck tension.
 
If your die setting sizes your cases for zero clearance in the chamber and you shoot in a clean environment then you’re gtg. I like .002” shoulder bump because I want the clearance in the chamber. Neither as anything to do with neck tension. Zero clearance at the shoulder or .002”, does not matter.
 
You will still get neck tension running it through the die even if you aren't bumping the shoulder. You may not size the neck all the way to the shoulder junction with a full length sizing die but a bushing die doesn't size that far down anyways.
 
either i'm not explaining it right or you're not getting what i'm talking about. I was asking bax if when he sized the case he was still getting the correct neck tension. given that he and I are not touching the shoulder or the shoulder is slightly in the negative from SAMMI, did his die touch the neck to give the correct tension.

my forster FL die is on back order or I would just test myself.
 
Neck tension is measured as the difference in diameter between the bullet OD and the neck ID. Shoulder bump does not affect neck tension.

The neck is sized by the die while the shoulder is pushed back.
 
let's just part as friends...

I’m not trying to insult you but you really need to understand the mechanics of sizing. Maybe you know how this and we are just not communicating effectively but here it is:

When you ram a fired case into a sizing die the first thing that makes contact is the case body. The die, being smaller, squeezes the case body which in turn causes the shoulder to pop forward. As the case continues deeper into the die the case neck makes contact. The die sizes the neck as case bottoms out against the shoulder inside the die. But you are not done yet. The final 1/32nd or so of case movement is where the die pushes the shoulder back to its final setting. In order for that to happen the whole neck has to be sized all the way down to the shoulder.

Since you said that your fired shoulder length is the same as your sized shoulder length, it must mean the die sized the whole neck.
 
i'm not upset i think i'm just asking the question wrong so rather than get mad i figured we'd just leave it there. the reason i can't test is i don't have the die as it's on back order right now. I understand what's happening when a sizing die does it's work. what i was wondering is that if the fired shoulder length is the same before and after firing, would the neck get touched by the die given that the case body and shoulder wouldn't get touched by the die.

no worries, i'll find out once i have the die in hand.
 
Your shirt size has no bearing on your hat size. Head shoulders knees and toes, all separate things.

Just because you run the brass into your die and the shoulders didn’t get pushed back doesn’t mean that you didn’t size your neck back down. Anytime you put a case into a normal full length die far enough to feel resistance the neck is going to be getting sized back down. The entire length of the neck gets sized down before the shoulder even gets touched.
 
i'm not upset i think i'm just asking the question wrong so rather than get mad i figured we'd just leave it there. the reason i can't test is i don't have the die as it's on back order right now. I understand what's happening when a sizing die does it's work. what i was wondering is that if the fired shoulder length is the same before and after firing, would the neck get touched by the die given that the case body and shoulder wouldn't get touched by the die.

no worries, i'll find out once i have the die in hand.

In your original post you said the shoulder length did not change after firing, therefore your chamber must have the same shoulder length as your Lapua case.

That seems to be the case, based on your before and after measurements. However, if you measure the case body at the base and the shoulder you’ll see the case increased in diameter by a few thousands. Even though the shoulder length didn’t change the case diameter did.

Because the diameter increased, when you size the case the shoulder length will increase inside the die as it squeezes the sidewalls. The die will push the shoulder back for sure. No doubt about it.

The whole neck will be sized.
 
Thank you for this reply.

When loading do you set your resize die to the -0.002 or do you go past that to like -.003 or 4? I don't crimp so i'm just concerned about how to set neck tension if the die isn't touching the case after firing.

This is a long post, sorry about that. You asked about neck tension.

The function of full-length sizing is to reduce body diameter, push the shoulder back, and reduce the neck diameter. All of these changes are small values. In your case, the shoulder did not get longer - you measured the length with your gauge and you see that it is the same after firing as it was before firing. However, the case body and the neck both expand in a radial direction. In my case, I am shooting a 308. My chambers have a .340 neck inside diameter and after firing my brass measures .340 outside diameter. When I lube the case and force it into the die, my neck OD is reduced to about .330 - roughly, I don't recall exactly but .330 is close enough. With a .330 OD, the next ID is about .300 - more or less. This happens without respect to the shoulder length. Same for the body diameter, it is reduced regardless of what happens to the shoulder. For what it's worth, by the time the brass shoulder is pushed far enough into the die to run into the die shoulder, the neck is completely sized.

After running my brass into my full length die and reducing the neck OD, I screw an expander body with mandrel into my press and run every piece of brass over that mandrel. The mandrel diameter is about .305. Brass is slightly elastic so the mandrel expands the neck ID from about .300 to about .305 or .306 with some elastic tension. When I pull the case off the mandrel, the elastic tension relaxes and the neck ID becomes .304. I check a few cases with a .304 pin gauge just to be sure.

Firing and sizing causes brass to migrate from the middle of the body toward base and toward the shoulder and neck. This moving brass forms a donut at the base of the neck. In the olden days they were called "dreaded donuts". There is probably a new name now. When you size the case, the OD of the neck is forced to be a cylinder or nearly-cylindrical-cone with the inside of the neck thin at the top and fatter at the donut. Forcing the neck over the mandrel has the effect of making the neck ID cylindrical and the neck OD irregular. That is fine and actually helps with bullet seating and centering the round in the chamber prior to firing.

I have a 308 with a SAAMI minimum length chamber and another one that is .002 longer. With my RCBS gauge, the short chamber measures -.002 and the long chamber measures 0.000. Insert my headspace gauge (the GO gauge) into the shorter chamber and the bolt almost by not quite closes when the barrel is torqued to 30 ft-lbs. With the longer chamber, the bolt closes when the gauge is in the chamber. Brass fired in the shorter chamber comes out about chamber length or just a smidge longer - about 0.000 using the RCBS gauge. Again, brass is elastic. I set the die so that when I lower the press handle, the shoulder length is about minus .002 from the chamber length. When I remove the case from the die, the elastic tension relaxes and the case comes out chamber length plus or minus .001. Brass is imperfect so individual pieces get slightly different results.

Since I have two guns with different chambers, sometimes I make different ammo for chamber A and B and sometimes I make ammo that is between the lengths. On the gun with the long chamber, the bolt closes freely. On the gun with the shorter chamber, the bolt is a bit firm.

Right now I have about 150 pieces of brass ready for charging. There is an auto-throw / auto-trickle device in my future. Friday night I rearranged my scopes. Saturday, I shot for 100-yard zero and slipped turrets. Today I fired 90 rounds, about 55 rounds in the long-chambered gun and the rest in the other gun. After shooting today I now have good gun data for both guns on steel every 100 yards out to 1k.