Shooting out to 1000 yards I shoot just as tight of groups with my ATACR standard MOAR as I did with my NP-R1 and NP-R2 reticles on my 5.5-22 NXS scopes. I find the thicker reticle is very nice for getting on target easier and more quickly.
I have found over the years after shooting many different brands, models, and magnifications of scopes, that I can hold the same tight groups out to 1000 yards even with thicker reticles and low magnification settings.
Bolt gun shooters are always amazed how I shoot groups just as tight as their groups at long distance with my GAP AR10 (.308) with a S&B PMII 3-12x. They all have much higher power scopes on their rifles compared to mine.
Don't get too hung up on having to have ultra thin reticles and high magnification scopes.