barrel decisions JP vs Odin

needham

Sergeant of the Hide
Full Member
Minuteman
Jan 24, 2020
158
59
I have narrowed it down between these two barrels
18 223 JP with thermal dissipator
18 DMR Odin Works

I like the "value" and fact that the JP comes with a matched bolt, and I really like the idea of the thermal dissipator.
The JP checks all my weight constraints, and checks all my boxes. I only question the accuracy and how good can I make it. I will be handloading for both barrels.
I have heard the JP stuff can get picky on ammo

The only knock on the Odin is weight for my wants (it really is a standard weight for everything else) .....it weights the same as the WOA spr barrel I had and really prefer not to go that heavy again with a build. If I was gonna do that I would probably run the 16 in WOA SMD and call it done...... but I like the idea of having a 16 and 18 of more of a precision minded gun.

Basically have a 18 in and a 16 in in a more precision centerd family if you will, to go along with my "blaster guns" I already have

With handloading the only question will be: I will truly tailor the load to the 18 in, will the same load shoot reasonable enough in the 16 in of the same brand?
Meaning if the 18 in shoot a load that is 1/2in ish what are the chances the same load will at least be sub MOA out of the 16in as well, being the same brand/manufacturer?

stupid and odd questions, I know. Help me decide.
What barrel would you choose between these two, for a family of barrels?
 
I’m a little biased but it will be hard to beat a JP barrel for accuracy....plus the matched bolt. I have several blasters with JP barrels and I don’t have any that are picky as far as Ammo is concerned. It would be an easy choice for me.

also...code: 68SS0717 will save you 10% on JP parts and accessories and 5% on complete rifles.
 
I have a JP 18" .223 precision barrel in a Larue upper (the Larue barrel was junk, btw) and it is now a consistent sub .5 MOA shooter with 77 gr SMKs. I love the JP performance so much that I just bought ALL JP parts to build a .260 Rem AR upper.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malcolm31
Update:
I been on the list for an 18 inch 223 Jp barrel since August. They are backordered on the matched bolts until November.

In the meanwhile I got a rainier arms ultramatch and will play with it.
If it shoots, I'll cancel the JP.

I still like the idea of a JP though so I might get anyways, lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: Malcolm31