• Winner! Quick Shot Challenge: What’s the dumbest shooting myth you’ve heard?

    View thread

Best ear protection?

Re: Best ear protection?

i used regular factory ear plugs you can find em for cheap or free in those noise factories, They work perfect for in door shooting. Also bought a surefire ep4 didn't test it out yet hopefully soon.
smile.gif
 
Re: Best ear protection?

I purchased a pair of Pro Ears Predator Gold from Midway on Sunday night and I should be able to test them this weekend.
I am currently running the Howard Leights and I like them but shooting my .308 with a brake I wanted more protection. The stated 26 db reduction was the highest in its class for a compact pair of muffs.
I will report back when I get a chance to test them.
SScott
 
Re: Best ear protection?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Sunnyside Scott</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I purchased a pair of Pro Ears Predator Gold from Midway on Sunday night and I should be able to test them this weekend.
I am currently running the Howard Leights and I like them but shooting my .308 with a brake I wanted more protection. The stated 26 db reduction was the highest in its class for a compact pair of muffs.
I will report back when I get a chance to test them.
SScott </div></div>

Looking forward to this review.
 
Re: Best ear protection?

The Peltor Spottacs worked fine yesterday on a breeching shot in an interior hallway. It was kind of wierd because the charge caused the ears to attenuate for longer than a rifle shot does. They still worked perfectly.

The Howard Leights came in today, but I don't know if I am going to use them on the shot tonight, or stick with "tried and true".
 
Re: Best ear protection?

I've got X2 Peltors, both have had one side go out = so now i have one (1/2 from each)
frown.gif


Just picked up Howard Leight, 1/2 batteries needed, auto shut off, walkietalkie jack (works good, magnified hearing

so far i like them a lot better
smile.gif
, they are little heavier
 
Re: Best ear protection?

For years I've used plugs + muffs, usually Hearos or Macks (both -32dB) under a Peltor-10 (-29dB) when spending lengthy periods at the range. (FWIW the combination is NOT additive but more like an addition -5dB or so over either alone.) For short sessions the plugs alone have been the ticket. But recently I acquired a pair of SensGard ZEM SG31s (NRR 31) which are so much more convenient than rolling plugs for insertion. Lots of friends have been adopting them recently as well.

SensGard%20SG31_633530080793264296.jpg
 
Re: Best ear protection?

Just got a chance to compare my Peltor Sporttacs to the Howard Leight Impact muffs.

The Impact seem decent for the price, however they are nowhere near as good as the Sporttacs at either noise suppression or sound amplification.

Once I installed the gel ear seals on the Peltors it put them in a totally different class. I am looking forward to the next eight hour range day.

I am not giving up on the Impacts, but the fit is sloppy and suppression is insufficient for covered firing points and braked rifles.
 
Re: Best ear protection?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Cmonroe</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Spend three days straight in a pair of Howard's and you will gladly spend the money on Sordins and never look back.</div></div>

Spend a year with tinnitus so bad it sounds like a high pitched siren going off when you are trying to get to sleep and you will use the hearing pro that gives you the best sound reduction, not the one that offers the most comfort.
 
Re: Best ear protection?

For years I worked around aircraft and currently use the Howard Leight muff for pistol and rifle. I got a catalog yesterday with these Surefire EP3> EP6 in the ear plugs and was wondering has anyone tried these and what are your thoughts?
 
Re: Best ear protection?

I tried the first generation of Surefire plugs. They work ok in open air. Do not use them in covered firing points with rifles. They are not sufficient.

I have a set of Howard Leight "leightning" muffs. They are excellent for non-electronic ears. They are what I have my boy use most of the time.

Carter, having just used the Leight "Impact Sport" next to my Peltor Sporttac I can tell you there is no comparison. The electronics in the Peltors are better. The noise suppression is better. They are more comfortable. The Sporttacs are just better all around. However they should be. They cost twice as much. The Gel Seals I put in them cost almost as much as the Impact Sport.
 
Re: Best ear protection?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: LoneWolfUSMC</div><div class="ubbcode-body">
Carter, having just used the Leight "Impact Sport" next to my Peltor Sporttac I can tell you there is no comparison. The electronics in the Peltors are better. The noise suppression is better. They are more comfortable. The Sporttacs are just better all around. However they should be. They cost twice as much. The Gel Seals I put in them cost almost as much as the Impact Sport.</div></div>

The point wasn't so much about the Leights... I haven't even used them. The point is that many people judge the hearing pro on factors other than how well they protect hearing. That should be the primary concern, in my mind.

I managed to develop tinnitus in one shooting session by experimenting with some plugs that weren't giving me enough protection. My ears haven't stopped ringing for months.

I have always hated wearing hearing pro... it is very disorienting and makes you less aware of your external environment, but I have always worn it. It is frustrating to me that just by making the mistake of wearing something that wasn't protective enough (not forgetting to wear any), I am going to be hearing a ringing sound for the rest of my life.

Sordins and Peltors, the two favorite tactical muffs that get thrown around here a lot offer a relatively low level of protection. This is just something I thought I'd throw out there.
 
Re: Best ear protection?

I understand. I have had Tinnitus since I was 18 thanks to Uncle Sam. I am keenly interested in preserving what I have left.

Cheap foam plugs are still some of the best protection available. However I have serious problems with the lack of situational awareness that they cause. When I am on the range alone, I do sometimes revert to plugs. They allow me to get deeper in the "bubble".

NRR isn't all it's cracked up to be. I have worn ear pro with higher NRR than others and to my ears that isn't correct. Part of it may have to do with my personal fit and part may have to do with manufacturers inflating their claims. I really don't have any way to validate that.

The best thing I can say is keep some plugs in your pocket. If you feel that it's too loud, then swap them out or double up.
 
Re: Best ear protection?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: LoneWolfUSMC</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I understand. I have had Tinnitus since I was 18 thanks to Uncle Sam. I am keenly interested in preserving what I have left.

Cheap foam plugs are still some of the best protection available. However I have serious problems with the lack of situational awareness that they cause. When I am on the range alone, I do sometimes revert to plugs. They allow me to get deeper in the "bubble".

NRR isn't all it's cracked up to be. I have worn ear pro with higher NRR than others and to my ears that isn't correct. Part of it may have to do with my personal fit and part may have to do with manufacturers inflating their claims. I really don't have any way to validate that.

The best thing I can say is keep some plugs in your pocket. If you feel that it's too loud, then swap them out or double up. </div></div>

Yes... NRR is not always right. The plugs that I got screwed on had a high NRR, but did not create a proper seal in my ear canal. I had been using the cheapy CVS plugs, but recently switched to the Howard Leight Ultras. The Ultras are much better. I highly recommend them.

I also understand the situational awareness aspect as well. I put hearing protection on and I get a feeling of numbness. I think the Sordins and the Peltors are great for on duty Law Enforcement where you are not going to be in a firefight where 100+ rounds are going to be discharged. There, situational awareness is the determining factor.

For practice, range shooting, and competition, where 100's and if you count the surrounding fire, 1,000's of rounds are being discharged, the higher level of protection should be the deciding factor. I guess just like anything, you have to look at what you are really using the equipment for. I think for the majority of the folks on here, the level of protection should be the dominant criterion, but it really depends on the situation.