Re: DPMS 308 LR AT 1000 yards
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Hamilton</div><div class="ubbcode-body"><div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: dieselten</div><div class="ubbcode-body"><div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Tx_Flyboy</div><div class="ubbcode-body">dieselten,
Mr Slash peddles that nonsense to the fan boys at Arfcom so he can sell them his $100 buffers that are "better". </div></div>
I disagree.
The factory DPMS 308 guns are way over gassed. This beats the hell out of the guns and brass and causes the bolt to open earlier.
Think about it, the rifle functions perfectly with a buffer that weighs twice as much and with a spring with double the tension. How could the original as issued rifle possibly be set up correctly?
There is a recent thread in this forum from a gunsmith trying to set up an adjustable gas block on a DPMS 308 and he had to set it at 1/4 turn from full closed.
Just because Slash sells this stuff on arfcom, doesn't mean it don't work.
</div></div>
Because what you are saying isn't true.
The Slash recoil spring is NOT twice the spring rate.
Bolt carrier + buffer + firing pin = total reciprocating mass.
The total reciprocating mass is only increased a small amount with his heavy buffers.
If you were to actually double the reciprocating mass, you would reduce the cycle energy by 1/2.
If you have a descent handle on physics, I'll elaborate.
A recoil spring with twice the spring rate would require twice the kinetic energy to cycle the same as the original.
If what you are saying was true then these AR10's are getting more than 2 times the cycle energy that they need, which they are not.
The buffer gives a place for the spring to compress, prevents the carrier key from impacting the charging handle, eases the impact of the reciprocating mass with the rear of the buffer tube, augments the total reciprocating weight, and probably it's most important function: acts as a dead-blow hammer to prevent bolt carrier bounce.
(That's why those weights within the buffer have a little room to flop around).
The carrier should achieve a velocity of around 21 ft/sec, accelerates over a distance of about 0.10" (depending on reciprocating mass), and this all happens in < 0.5 milisec depending on barrel length, and gas port location.
Free travel = 0.125"
Camming distance = 0.125"
Extraction begins at about 0.25"
Rotating the bolt, while the bolt is under pressure can cause all kinds of issues.
The AR series of rifles operate dead nuts on the minimum margins required.
When I run the numbers for a 3oz. heavier buffer, I don't see a big change in the performance anywhere.
However if the bolt carrier had just 0.1" more free travel built into it's camming slot, one could see over 50% more dwell time before camming begins, and all this buffer shit would disappear.
It is hard to get away with 0.100" but half that is surely there, and it would make more difference than any buffer.
My rifles run great with the stock bolt carrier and spring.
My brass comes out looking like a bolt guns, with a little ejector swipe.
If you want to know if your rifle is over gassed, measure the gas port and compare it to the standard for that caliber/gas port location/barrel length. </div></div>
your handle on the subject seems fine to me, except that my slash buffer weighs 6.1 ounces and the stock buffer from my DPMS AP4 weighed 3.4 ounces. So It is not exactly twice the weight...my bad. And I have no way to quantify the actual spring rate but the Armalite spring is so much heavier I thought the rifle was frozen the first time I tried to charge it. It is longer also, the rifle will barely engage the bolt hold open, but it has never failed to.
How do you address the other thread I referred to, where the gunsmith had to close the adjustable gas block on an otherwise unaltered DPMS 308 and it ran correctly at 1/4 turn open? This is not right.
I stand by my statement that these guns are way over gassed.
TX flyboy - just cause your rifle functions fine and never jams does not mean it is operating optimally. Go ahead and live in denial.