Re: I bought a NF 4-15x50 for 394.00 no joke
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: dreamlander</div><div class="ubbcode-body"><div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: palmik</div><div class="ubbcode-body"><div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: dreamlander</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Agreed, if it was someone I had any regard for I wouldn't have bought it for that price in the first place. I would have gave him more or told him to sell it elsewhere for more.
Palmik you say you tend to let your ethics get the better of you, well I don't think your ethics should be questioned for not giving it back, but the seller's should be for wanting to take it back.</div></div>
Ethics does indeed play a part. It is the same concept as receiving too much change from a store clerk accidentally because he miscounted. Once the transaction is done, you are under no obligation to give it back. You should hand it back anyway because knowingly walking out of the store with positive cash flow is similar to swindling, imparting a negative impact upon another individual's livelihood who hadn't violated yours. You would be taking advantage of someone's error for personal gain. You may be correct by justifying that you haven't broken any laws, and cannot be held liable for punishment, but you may have ruined someone else's day. I think the world would be a better place if people held concern for the welfare of their neighbors, rather than banking on any opportunity regardless of the ramifications of their actions. If there were no laws against murder, would you feel righteous shooting a guy dead at a red light because he cut you off on the parkway? I hope not, because I wouldn't.
"If people are good only because they fear punishment, and hope for reward, then we are a sorry lot indeed." -Albert Einstein</div></div>
I agree with you 100%. I strongly believe in morals. Not the religious kind that don't want you to have sex or drink alcohol but the real ones based on honesty and the golden rule. I am definitely a person that gives the change back. But I think you might have missed my point. It seems to me it was an honest sale. So I guess I don't understand why the seller had a right to want the scope back. Maybe I am missing something about the transaction though, not sure. For example If you bought a car, drove it home, then the dealer shows up at your door and wants the car back because Joe Blow is willing to buy it for twice the price you paid. I don't think it would be immoral to keep the car.
I think we are squared away now. Great Einstein quote by the way.</div></div>
If the guy made an honest mistake, that is a separate issue. He is imposing his problems on others because of his own ineptness. It is a shitty thing to do, but he has nothing to lose by trying to fix the situation; I don't see any real harm done by trying, just as long as he is willing take on the full onus for his error if it doesn't work out. It is then at the discretion of the buyer to accommodate him with no obligation to do so. However, if he attempted to go back in time and fabricate some sob story or ultimatum, just so he can break a transaction in order to catch a missed opportunity, that is an outright scumbag move. Even if the seller pulled this dirtbag maneuver, the buyer has to weigh the utility factor if he has any relationship with the seller. If it is believed that the buyer's noble efforts will be marginalized and taken for granted, then he should lambaste the seller for attempting to break a contract and keep the scope. If his noble efforts will be greatly appreciated, and keeping the scope will invoke guilt and shame, then he should give the scope back.
It sounds as if this seller doesn't like to take responsibility for his own actions, and unfortunately, he probably won't ever change. So I would have no problem keeping the scope. If the roles were reversed, it is highly probable that this same seller would keep the scope from the buyer regardless of the buyer's integrity. Needless to say, I think the original buyer should distance himself from this dirtbag.