• The Shot You’ll Never Forget Giveaway - Enter To Win A Barrel From Rifle Barrel Blanks!

    Tell us about the best or most memorable shot you’ve ever taken. Contest ends June 13th and remember: subscribe for a better chance of winning!

    Join contest Subscribe

Suppressors impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

skinney_7

Hammer down.
Commercial Supporter
Full Member
Minuteman
  • Aug 23, 2008
    1,829
    932
    44
    SD
    www.oneillops.com
    Barry Dueck, Dir of the suppressor division @ surefire, shot 4 cans, the 21oz FA556-M6, 16oz FA556-212, 14oz Mini, 12oz Micro, he also shot a group only using the surefire muzzle break, all were fired using the same rifle and all had the same POI. good watch.
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    i saw it too...POI shift was non-existent and group size was incredible. i was impressed
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    not sure the distance but the one 3 shot group was all in one hole, and most of the others were touching, what they did was set up a silhouette target and put about 7 individual dots on it and fired the muzzle break @ one mark and then each can @ one mark and so on until all the suppressors were tested, then @ the last mark they shot a 3 shot group from each can, and it was a hole about the size of a quarter, i would say the distance was 50M-100M, hard to tell how far when the cam is zoomed out, makes it look farther than it really is, still impressive i may have to look into one of these if this is the case with all their cans.
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    I have used them for years and they do not shift POI much if at all. I need to check out the mini and micro cans.
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    <div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: One_Feather</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Checking up on the new micro, would be cool on my 7in SBR </div></div>

    I would not recommend the micro for that barrel length. I would go with the 212. The Micro was designed for longer barrels because the Marines are running 20inch ar's. With that short of a barrel you might have a secondary explosion from the unburnt powder.

    Chuck
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    <div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: delta9mda</div><div class="ubbcode-body">the poi shift is a good selling point but how good at suppression are they? </div></div>

    Are suppressors are all hearing safe so under 140 decibals. Usually depending on atmospheric conditions and ammo they are somewhere in the neighborhood of 30-35db of sound reduction.

    Chuck
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    <div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: delta9mda</div><div class="ubbcode-body">the poi shift is a good selling point but how good at suppression are they? </div></div>

    +1

    140 db would be some 60 dbs above hearing safe. 140 dbs would be the equivalent of a jet engine. Figure 130 dB at a jack hammer levels. To be helpful here, an unsurpressed .22 lr would clock in at a little less than 130 db.

    Unfortunatley POI testing in the absence of real time dB data is useless. As an example, overbore insures excellent POI while greatly reducing suppression values. One just needs to know how quiet a unit is before POI testing begins. Having said that, four (4) different cans on one rifle and not a wisp of POI change is most astonishing, really remarkable, incredibly astounding.

    Ear Safe is about to be redefined as well..
    http://multimedia.3m.com/mws/mediawebserver?66666UuZjcFSLXTtmxfyoXM_EVuQEcuZgVs6EVs6E666666--
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    RT51, 140dB is the OSHA max for impluse type noises like gunshots. The document you refer to is constant noise, not impluse noise. Under 140db is hearing safe. Adopting your standard of 80db would mean no currently available suppressor for any centerfire cartridge is hearing safe, as none exceed 40db of suppression. Clearly that is not the case.
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    CoryT,

    You are correct and for fear of hyjacking the thread, I'll keep this short. From what I am reading, that is all about to change. Impulse is being lowered to the very same 85 dB threshold if the impulse occurs more routinely than once every four (4) hours in the work place. That would be twice within the standard 8 hour day. As we are all aware, impact by Osha for, say rivet guns and/or jack hammers have already required protection and both of those are below the 140 dB threshold. In short, rapid fire or full auto would be 10 dB higher than standing with your ears 30" from a jack hammer head (120 dB) going at it. All of us know that the 140 dB rating is a crock and that anybody that sits out there and beats out a steady beat will do big damage.

    The returning numbers are telling the full story and there are at least two big projects that I am aware of that are commited to tackle this one head on. Why the change? Because the data is startling and disturbing, with nearly two thirds of returning vets from Britian having severe to permanent damage and, for the Americans, it is coming in as the #1 disability. My point is simply this, 140 dB isn't good enough for any manufacturer. Better than nothing? yes. Good, no and certainly not hearing safe. Its starts with suppression, well before POI, making a POI can is much easier than making a very quiet can with great POI repeatability. That is all I am saying.

    I think it is great that Surefire has excellent POI results, I too would want anybody to meter the very can they are testing POI with. I'll go one further, dB tesing now will, I believe, migrate to duration of pulse as well. Pressure, duration, frequency, POI, etc., etc.

    I'll stop within this thread, apologies.



     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    i saw the show, and what i dont like is they were shooting a heavier contour barrel, so the poi shift would be minimal. im not saying they arent good suppressors, i just dont see me being able to repeat results with a regular patrol type barrel, like most users would be using. and how does one know the dealer (the guy firing) wasnt adjusting poa for the poi shift. im just saying, at the end of the day hes still a salesman. it just doesnt make sense that free floating and such is so critical but hanging a pound on the end of a barrel doesnt affect it. on a heavy barrel i can see it. but on a regular barrel it has to have more affect
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    <div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: lone_soldier</div><div class="ubbcode-body">i saw the show, and what i dont like is they were shooting a heavier contour barrel, so the poi shift would be minimal. im not saying they arent good suppressors, i just dont see me being able to repeat results with a regular patrol type barrel, like most users would be using. and how does one know the dealer (the guy firing) wasnt adjusting poa for the poi shift. im just saying, at the end of the day hes still a salesman. it just doesnt make sense that free floating and such is so critical but hanging a pound on the end of a barrel doesnt affect it. on a heavy barrel i can see it. but on a regular barrel it has to have more affect </div></div>

    If you are ever around Ft. Bragg shoot me a pm. When I do demo's we shoot our suppressors on M4 contour barrel's as well and there is very little POI shift. Also I let the guys that I am doing the demo for shoot the guns also so you can see first hand we are not adjusting our point of aim to compensate.

    Chuck
     
    Re: impressive surefire demo on outdoor channel.

    <div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: RollingThunder51</div><div class="ubbcode-body">CoryT,

    You are correct and for fear of hyjacking the thread, I'll keep this short. From what I am reading, that is all about to change. Impulse is being lowered to the very same 85 dB threshold if the impulse occurs more routinely than once every four (4) hours in the work place. That would be twice within the standard 8 hour day. As we are all aware, impact by Osha for, say rivet guns and/or jack hammers have already required protection and both of those are below the 140 dB threshold. In short, rapid fire or full auto would be 10 dB higher than standing with your ears 30" from a jack hammer head (120 dB) going at it. All of us know that the 140 dB rating is a crock and that anybody that sits out there and beats out a steady beat will do big damage.

    The returning numbers are telling the full story and there are at least two big projects that I am aware of that are commited to tackle this one head on. Why the change? Because the data is startling and disturbing, with nearly two thirds of returning vets from Britian having severe to permanent damage and, for the Americans, it is coming in as the #1 disability. My point is simply this, 140 dB isn't good enough for any manufacturer. Better than nothing? yes. Good, no and certainly not hearing safe. Its starts with suppression, well before POI, making a POI can is much easier than making a very quiet can with great POI repeatability. That is all I am saying.

    I think it is great that Surefire has excellent POI results, I too would want anybody to meter the very can they are testing POI with. I'll go one further, dB tesing now will, I believe, migrate to duration of pulse as well. Pressure, duration, frequency, POI, etc., etc.

    I'll stop within this thread, apologies.



    </div></div>

    I would believe that basing a change in the hearing safe impulse noise level, based on the statistics of returning veterans would be skewed.

    Why, because the majority of people have shot their weapons unsuppressed and there is exposure to heavier weapons, explosions, incoming fire etc.

    I have fired thousands of rounds suppressed with weapons ranging from pistols to light machineguns and my hearing is normal.

    It is good that there is current research on the impulse noise levels, exposure times etc. and discussion on what really is "safe", but it is fair to say that exposure to impulse SPLs of 126-138 dB ( the range in most suppressed centrefire weapons range ) than the level 155-160 dB level of unsuppressed centrefire weapons.

    Could you disclose your occupation, do you work with suppressors?

    Best Regards!

    Tuukka Jokinen
    Ase Utra sound suppressors