Re: Looking for advice/opinion on a ankle holster.
I've carried a J frame in ankle holsters a lot. Overall, it's not a terrible way to carry, but pocket is way-mo-betta except if you spend a lot of the time in a car. Presenting a pistol from an anklel holster while seated is pretty good actually.
The two I have are the Galco and the Fobus. The better of the two depends on footwear. When I used to wear Doc Marten boots, the Fobus was great, and very secure. It would STAY PUT and retention was fantastic - but only a sharp tug was required to get the gun out. However, the Fobus is kinda bulky. Boot cut jeans concealed it well - though I am a legcrosser and always had to pay attention to be sure my jeans were covering the pistol when I crossed my legs.
I wear cowboy boots now, and the Fobus is worthless. They don't have much "flare" where the top melds into the bottom, whereas the Docs did. Honestly, the Galco isn't much better with cowboy boots. However, the Galco can be worn inside the boot, and theres no WAY thats gonna happen with the Fobus.
Neither work well with lowtop shoes/tennis shoes. My bare, or socked ankle (I'm 6'2" 210lb - so I'm neither skinny nor fat) is just too small in diameter for the holster to wrap around securely. Plus, socks slip against skin easily, so the holster, even if snugly fastened around the sock, still slips all over the place. Maybe you could get used to that but it drove me CRAZY.
Honestly, I think the pocket holster is a better solution (except for seated in car), but if for whatever reason you can't pocket carry - ankle is ok. Overall, Id say I prefer the Fobus. I love the retention without a thumb break, and it just always felt more stable. Downside was bulk.... oh, and even thougb it never failed, I never trusted the neoprene velcro straps on the Galco...the straps are stretched and always in tension - just didn't seem right. The Fobus had a really long and thin but NOT stretchy strap that would wrap ALL the way around, then put though a D ring thing, which made it feel SECURE - and it was.