Opinion on Bear Creek Arsenal?

I know there are many here who refuse to even consider rifles that cost less than $8,000, a right arm, kidney, and your first born, because some think cost always equals quality. But for those of us that don’t have Porches for daily drivers, super model wives (and side pieces), billions in the bank, and to whom nothing less than Barrett's and Chey Tacs will do, have to budget on occasion.

The question is just how cheap is TOO cheap? At what point are you just buying garbage or rolling the dice? Where is the happy medium?

I have become interested in playing with the 8.6 Blackout but the trouble is most of the offerings are very expensive from “premium” brands and at the end of the day, other than the caliber they are all pretty much the same rifle, an AR-10, and most of the parts will probably interchange, and I just can’t justify spending $2,000-$3,000, or more, on a rifle just to experiment with a new caliber, but I also don’t want to buy garbage.

But there is the problem, because as far as I can tell the only budget manufacturer is Bear Creak Arsenal, and they don’t exactly make me confident, they claim sub MOA accuracy, and some people I have seen report that, but others report 4 MOA accuracy, canted gas blocks, unstaked gas keys, and rifles so over gassed that you end up with soot on your face like your shooting black powder. And I don’t know which is the more common experience. I’d love it if PSA made one, maybe not the best, but at least adequate and good enough to experiment with, but they don’t, at least not the last time I checked, but Bear Creek Arsenal?

What has your experience been with them? Are they worth messing with? If they ship a bad rifle will they fix it? What is that process like and what’s the turnaround time?

The intended purpose is mostly to experiment with the caliber, but also just for fun and maybe some tactical style shooting, doubt I would try for more than 500 yards or so at most, and probably less, but if it could hit a thousand that would be cool. A range toy really, but I do want it to work and be reasonably accurate, not planning on winning any competitions with it.
 
How cheap is too cheap? Depends on
A) your use case, if you are shooting deer and your longest shot is 100 yard I would argue that almost anything will do depending on you answer to B.
B) what is your experience level? I novice equipped a with a slightly more expensive rifle may make shots better than with a dirt cheap POC just because you don’t have to overcome as many hindrances.
C) What are your use case growth expectations? If your nature says that once you start on something the need to do more becomes an obsession you should invest a bit more up front and eliminate the low hanging toys as you will end up buying stuff which has little resale. If however you know that the answer to question A will
Never change. Find a good used rifle being sold by someone who lied on Question B.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WeR0206 and simonp
With all the deals on surplus and LEO turn-in AR-15s nowadays, parts galore, deals from BCM, if you are budget-minded, there is no reason to sacrifice your self-esteem and time wasted by rolling the dice with known failure brands.

You can get a complete AR-15 from a reputable manufacturer for $599 from AimSurplus.

You can get a complete upper with BCG, CH, and rail system for $399.

Lowers are almost free now if you just look around, don’t even have to search hard.

You can get suppressors for $400-$600 even.

Remember, it’s your time and money spent on ammo, range fees, gas to and from, and reputation in front of your friends and family if your crap is malfunctioning and not performing.

One thing you can really control in all of that is the quality of the firearm and parts you buy. With how good of deals there are on known brands, there is zero reason to mess around with sub-par garbage that craps the bed so regularly.
 
This is to be taken with a grain of sand. I was willing to risk a few bucks and order a 17hmr upper for a sage rat build. I heard about the bad QC and loose barrel nuts and such. When I got it I pulled it all apart and rebuilt it. I took it to the range to see if it was going to be good enough for the hunt. Was pleasantly surprised it held MOA. Dont think I could expect anything better. Again though this is just my single experience, and I went in knowing what I was buying.
 
With all the deals on surplus and LEO turn-in AR-15s nowadays, parts galore, deals from BCM, if you are budget-minded, there is no reason to sacrifice your self-esteem and time wasted by rolling the dice with known failure brands.

You can get a complete AR-15 from a reputable manufacturer for $599 from AimSurplus.

You can get a complete upper with BCG, CH, and rail system for $399.

Lowers are almost free now if you just look around, don’t even have to search hard.

You can get suppressors for $400-$600 even.

Remember, it’s your time and money spent on ammo, range fees, gas to and from, and reputation in front of your friends and family if your crap is malfunctioning and not performing.

One thing you can really control in all of that is the quality of the firearm and parts you buy. With how good of deals there are on known brands, there is zero reason to mess around with sub-par garbage that craps the bed so regularly.
The 8.6 Blackout is an AR-10 caliber, not an AR-15.
 
I have 2 ar 10s in 6.5 cm. I checked everything before shooting them. The first one was a little tight. Cycled it a hundred times or so and it loosened up, shoots moa and cycles perfectly. The other was ready to go out of the gate, shoots just as well. They are very big on making sure things are right and will take care of any problems. I think they offer a pretty fair value. I saw a serious empirical review of barrels with some top names involved and a BCA barrel. The BCA barrel was above the average in the testing. I have manufactured many things in my many years. I can produce a more than acceptable product every time, but every 5th or 6th time there is something superior there. I think barrels are that way. Like a useful dog, they're almost irreplaceable but they wear out sooner or later. If it doesn't shoot right, send it back. Good luck
 
I have never had one, but a close friend has bought at least 2 bca ar15s and an ar10. Maybe more.

All shot moa or better.
He varmint hunts a bit so he does shoot them.

Thats all I know.

Edit to add: I forgot, he had a hammer snap in half on one of them. Replaced it and good to go after that.
 
Last edited:
The best thing about BCA is that they stand behind what they sell. From what Ive seen anyway.

You just have to manage your expectations. Just don't dont be surprised if you shoot the barrel out in 5k rounds or break a bolt or some other part prematurely.

I'd also take all if the claims of MOA accuracy with a large grain of salt. Finding an AR barrel that will hold that kind of accuracy for more than a few rounds isn't easy. A good barrel and ammo combo will do a solid 2 MOA for 10 or more rounds consistently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bfoosh006
I bought a 22WMR upper and it shoots just fine for what it is. Ran a few mags trough it with an FRT and the only hiccup has been some hammer follows, but that’s not an upper issue
 
I have a couple of uppers that I've bought for hunting. Never had any problems in 5 years or so. Sub moa. Used customer service one time to replace the upper. I didn't like some rust spots in a brand new barrel. It was fast and easy exchange.
 
The only thing I've personally purchased from them are a couple of glock barrels. And those were to just build up movie clones because my son thought they were cool looking when he was young. That being said, they shot fine for glocks.

A friend has a Bear Creek Upper. He hasn't put many rounds on it, but it is respectable for the price. It's not a MOA gun, but I'm kind of surprised with how many people here are saying their cheap gas guns are MOA or better.