• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

SCAR 16S Review with Video Demo

Centuriator

Dude...you're being very un-Dude.
Banned !
Full Member
Minuteman
Jul 3, 2012
2,799
1,629
Middle 'Merica!
<span style="font-weight: bold">Range Report</span> on SCAR 16S I saw on a forum a guy selling a SCAR 16S with Tango Down Battle Grip, Tango Down rail covers and with a spare magazine. He said he had only put a few magazines through it and realized he would rather have the cash, so he sold it to me at a great price. I was more than a little concerned that he was feeding me a line, but...the rifle arrived and truly, it is brand new, and obviously nearly unfired. I got it out to the gun club on Friday and here is my report. Much of what I say is going to be based on the fact that my first SCAR was a 17S.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Ergonomics</span> First thing I noticed was how much lighter the 16S is from the 17S, a nice change, handles very well.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Field Stripping</span> Took it all down and for some reason it was much easier to break down than the 17S, the parts are not quite as tight, which made for easier disassembly. VERY clean internals, lubed it up and packed it in the car to head to the gun club later in the day.It was interesting to compare how all the parts in the 16s are basically just "mini me" version of everything in the 17, duh! But still...everything is extremely well made, the bolt group, the extractor, are all nice and heavy duty, in their own right.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Shooting</span> Experience Wow...the recoil is negligible and the muzzle break keep everything nice and flat. Sights were putting rounds to left of POA, adjusted windage to the right, quite a bit actually, and I was getting on the center of the target from 25 to 50 yards with irons only.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Ammo Feeding</span> I intentionally fed it everything I had: M855 MilSpec, TULA, WOLF, WPA ... put nearly 400 rounds through it and not a single problem, at all. Functioned flawlessly.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Accuracy</span> Obviously, the rifle is more accurate than I am. I intentionally did not bring an optic with me, wanting just to see how the irons were doing. No problems.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Trigger</span> Trigger is lighter than my SCAR 17s, but the reset point is not as noticeable and so I had a few times when it had not reset before I pulled it again in rapid fire strings.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Magazines</span> I brought only the two FN magazines that came with the rifle, very well made, steel bodies. No issues. It took my (much) less expensive USGI aluminum magazines without fail. I really like how the mags drop very quickly out of the mag well, faster than my Daniel Defense M4 V1, and it seems the mags do not go in as deeply. I can imagine how, in the right hands, you can do lightning fast mag changes on this thing.

<span style="font-weight: bold">Comparing</span> it to my M4/AR Frankly...no comparison. The 5.56 shooting experience with the SCAR 16S is simply head and shoulders above that of an AR15 platform. It feels more solid to shoot, even more manageable recoil (not that there is all that much to begin with).

Here's the video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F166jA0z4hM
 
Re: SCAR 16S Review with Video Demo

The first question that jumps to my mind. As an owner of an AR15, is it worth it to buy a Scar 16 in addition to the AR? You say its much better, but if you own the 15 is it worth it to add the Scar?
 
Re: SCAR 16S Review with Video Demo

Well it is/was for me. I'm thinking of selling my AR now.
 
Re: SCAR 16S Review with Video Demo

I own a SCAR 16S as well as:

Noveske Lo-Pro Recce
Knight's SR-15 E3
Colt SP-6920MPB
Daniel Defense DDM4 V3

As much as I love the SCAR because it gets ooh's and aah's at the range, the Noveske is by far the most accurate rifle I have. They are all fun to shoot and yes, the SCAR may have slightly less recoil but I can't say it's superior. Once I buy the Geissele super scar trigger, I might change my mind. I did notice that the SCAR won't take Thermold mags while my Colt had no problem with them. Side charging handle is much better than AR system. I'm not sold on piston vs DGI since I clean them fully after shooting. It's the difference between a little dirty and a lot dirty I suppose. Just my personal preference.