I have both and have to say I like both. To me each of my rifles like different comps depending on how they are configured. I did extensive comp testing this year on a very light 16" AR for three gun competition and the Lantac, Rolling Thunder, Miculek, Seekins and JP all performed very well. If I had to pick only one the Lantac would probably be it because it is effective, light and is a little quieter than the others.