Re: sightron scopes
<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: SpotcheckBilly</div><div class="ubbcode-body">The new SIII lineup is awesome. Best dollar value scope around. Lifetime replacement warranty. It'll handle your .300 WM without any problems.
+1 on Scott @ Liberty Optics. </div></div>
Not to damn with faint praise, exactly what is "awesome" about Sightron??
Good Glass - Yes, most excellent
Good tracking - Yes, most excellent
Lifetime Warranty - Yes, but inferior to Bushnell for example
MIL/MOA - Yes
MIL/MIL - NO
MOA/MOA - NO
SFP - Yes
FFP - NO
In short Sightron represents the best 2009 Glass and Tracking technology, coupled with circa 1999 reticle/adjustment engineering.
I see nothing awesome about the SIII line, from a tactical shooting perspective, which is Sightron's flagship. Too many folks confuse themselves by equating that if a scope has good clear glass, it therefore follows that it must be a great rifle scope. But folks forget that "seeing" is not the only function of a scope. A rifle scope is primarily an aiming device.
The "seeing" part of a scope Sightron has down pat. It is probably the best in it's price range. But in the aiming part of scope design, in fact it's primary function, Sightron is lagging behind the power curve.
I am sorry if this interlude is upsetting to the general Sightron "lovefest". Perhaps a scope can be "great" and not need FFP or MIL/MIL and/or MOA/MOA adjustments. But since this site is dedicated to Tactical shooting, as opposed to benchrest, and hunting, and other endevors. I think that pointing out a vendors product limitations, as a tactical aiming device, is as important as pointing out it's virtues.
None of this is to say that a Sightron scope is junk. Far from it. In spite of the limitations I pointed out, Sightron remains a good solid product. But also realize how much more awesome a Sightron SIII would be, if the company got a clue, and really designed their tactical scopes, as tactical scopes, instead of hunting scopes with turrets and Mildot reticles added as after thoughts.
All the above is of course IMHO and your tastes and needs may differ greatly from mine.
Thanks,
Bob