So I am looking for something similar except I can live with standard capped turrets. I'd like to keep weight down under 18 oz, lower the better. Here's what I've gotten from my research so far:
Trijicon: best in class from people that use it, however it does not have a BDC and it's capped turrets preclude it from being used at range with decent accuracy.
Vortex PST: People swear by them, but I was unimpressed with the glass (not a huge deal in 1-4 IMO). I thought the reticle was thin, and that's the biggest complaint I've seen about it.
Leupold VX-R: Would also be perfect if it was a true 1X
That Steiner 1-4 looked great until I saw the weight. At 22.2 oz, I might as well stick with the SWFA 1-6 of the same weight that I'm currently using.