• Winner! Quick Shot Challenge: What’s the dumbest shooting myth you’ve heard?

    View thread

Movie Theater Which Star Wars is Best?

Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Empire, by far
<object width="425" height="350"> <param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/n6lzEhoXads"></param> <param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param> <embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/n6lzEhoXads" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="350"> </embed></object>
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: BCP</div><div class="ubbcode-body">WTF how could someone even vote for one of the new ones; they were garbage. </div></div>

No doubt. Kind of like the last Indiana Jones, not even close.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

I voted for Return of the Jedi. I know the Ewoks were cheezy but I loved the Moon of Endor. I think being a Biker Scout would be a kick-ass job.
smile.gif


My wife and I used to vacation in the Crescent City/ Smith River area with the intent of finding where the Endor scenes were filmed. Here's a picture of my bike in 2007, only a couple miles from where it was filmed. As a side note, much of the area you see in the movie was on private property and has been logged.

877396524_68Nge-L.jpg
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Sweet GS Jedi. I jumped a set of RR tracks on mine and broke one of the frame /engine mounts on the block. Its been rewelded, but it is a good reminder that the BMW urban assault vehicle is not totally bullet proof.

Back to topic, A New Hope is the shit. That is, after all, where it all began so many years ago (being the first movie released).
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Searcher</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Sweet GS Jedi. I jumped a set of RR tracks on mine and broke one of the frame /engine mounts on the block. Its been rewelded, but it is a good reminder that the BMW urban assault vehicle is not totally bullet proof.

Back to topic, A New Hope is the shit. That is, after all, where it all began so many years ago (being the first movie released). </div></div>

Thanks Searcher. As a side note I totalled that GS a couple months after this picture was taken...going way too fast off-roading in a BLM. Haha. They give the illusion of being a true dirt bike but you're correct that they are not bullet proof. I replaced that one with another '07 GS, which I recently sold for a 2010 F800GS. I'm in love with the 800...you lose a little of the highway comfort (although with a Corbin seat and aftermarket screen you don't give up too much), but for fire-roads and rough terrain it is a much easier bike to handle.

PS- Here is a link to a ride report I did on ADVrider with my new 800GS:
http://www.advrider.com/forums/showthread.php?t=582294

Sorry for the de-rail...back to your regularly scheduled thread. :p
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

By far the old trilogy, with empire, rotj, and anh coming in at 3rd.

Got i love star wars... il admit it im a huge nerd with props and shit! I even have around 100 unopened figures stashed away somewhere...

Jedi5150 thats endor right there!
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: vman</div><div class="ubbcode-body">By far the old trilogy, with empire, rotj, and anh coming in at 3rd.

Got i love star wars... il admit it im a huge nerd with props and shit! I even have around 100 unopened figures stashed away somewhere...

Jedi5150 thats endor right there! </div></div>

Don't feel bad, I'm something of a Star Wars nerd myself. I wish I still had all the action figures, some of those are worth a pretty penny these days. We gave most of ours to our cousins back when our folks decided to clean out the toy collection. lol I also used to play the SW roll-playing game back in high school with friends.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

I was sure that the new hope would be the number one, the empire is my least favorite out of the original 3, just seems like a filler between 2 bigger storied movies

all the 3 original are by far the best
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Empire is where all the drama really happens. New Hope was all character set and setting set up, Return was all the final face off. Empire shows the power of the empire, breaks out the hideous truth about Vader and Luke, creates tension between Luke and Leia, crushes you over Solo's demise, just a roller coaster of a ride.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Shot In The Dark</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Phantom Menace

I just love Jarjar Blinks </div></div>

Hand in your man card at the door on your way out
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

I am honestly torn between Empire and Sith. I know I know, the first three were garbage lol. But Sith was the fall of a Republic that had been around for thousands of years. We finally got to see Anakin go to the dark side and temporarily be a badass Sith. Unfortunatly he was written as a emotional bitch for half of it and ruined it. But overall it had the same dark conflict that Empire had. Just a though....
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

i agree, while when I was a kid I felt empire was disappointing, as i became older i appreciated the film immensely more than the other 2. Sith was great, the final clash was epic and I liked all the darkness.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

I voted for "Return of the Jedi" on the spur of the moment but I must concur with the majority about "Empire". I must also say though that being born in 1971 and seeing Star Wars in the movie theater was very influential. I loved it!!! Thats what got me hooked on the whole Star Wars thing. Now this next statement might twist some panties but I was too enthralled with the latest 3 movies. Call me an old timer I guess!
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: srt</div><div class="ubbcode-body">i agree, while when I was a kid I felt empire was disappointing, as i became older i appreciated the film immensely more than the other 2. Sith was great, the final clash was epic and I liked all the darkness. </div></div>
When I first saw Empire as a kid I had never seen a movie where the good guys didn't win. This was the first time the bad guys came out on top and it was sort of scary, the power of the dark side was powerful indeed.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Can't we all save judgement until after Lucas has redone and re-released at the theater all of the movies in 3D?

Hopefully, 3d will add character development to the first 3 movies.


I find it sad that I enjoy the Cartoon Network "Star Wars, The Clone Wars" series much better that the first 3 movies. The character development is so much better and the acting (due to a cartoon) isn't as bad as the movies.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: 11B3B4</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I would have to agree that the Cartoon Networks series is pretty darn good and develops the characters well. I recently started watching them. </div></div>

+1
who would've thought cartoon network could prove to be educational???

We need a final chapter story following "Return of the Jedi" and another prequel with Darth Sidius' Master, the one who could raise the dead...just sayin
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Jedi5150</div><div class="ubbcode-body"><div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: vman</div><div class="ubbcode-body">By far the old trilogy, with empire, rotj, and anh coming in at 3rd.

Got i love star wars... il admit it im a huge nerd with props and shit! I even have around 100 unopened figures stashed away somewhere...

Jedi5150 thats endor right there! </div></div>

Don't feel bad, I'm something of a Star Wars nerd myself. I wish I still had all the action figures, some of those are worth a pretty penny these days. We gave most of ours to our cousins back when our folks decided to clean out the toy collection. lol I also used to play the SW roll-playing game back in high school with friends. </div></div>

Feel bad??? Try thinking about how bad I feel for blowing up an AT-AT with serveral M-80s that were tied together to recreate the scene from ESB *SMACKS FOREHEAD*
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Hold on let me put on my Flame proof suit............Okay
Now, I would love them to go and remake episode 4. I know, I know its a classic and all but the lightsaber scene at the end of Sith was epic and the Final clash between OBi wan and vader in Ep 4 is just lame. I mean Obi wan basically ruined Aniken's life, and all he does is swipe at him with Obi wan holding his lightsaber straight up.
No No no, the person blamed for the death of his beloved and the cause of his acursed mechanical body would not get off so easily. That fight would be the be all and end all of fights. Storm Troopers heads getting cut off, the force crushing the life out of the bystanders, Obi wan hinting before the final blow that Padme had children, it could be awesome!!!! They should redo ep 4 and leave Empire alone.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Once someone starts reading the expanded universe books and learning more of the background and overall picture of what has happened in the prequals, the original three tend to be pretty weak. Flame suite on lol.

B4
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

Of the choices you gave: Empire.

The original is still the best.

Especially if you were lucky enough to see it in a real theatre at a time when bell-bottoms were 'in', hard rock was King, and the special effects were cutting-edge.
cool.gif
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

ALL of the ORIGINALS kick ass... why? because they contain stormtroopers, anything containing them in their ORIGINAL form (none of that bloody clone crap) can only be a winner, HOWEVER, Empire was gracious enough to introduce us to the likes of the classy AT-AT driver and Snowtrooper varients and Jedi brought us the stylish speederbike scouts!
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Graham</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Of the choices you gave: Empire.

The original is still the best.

Especially if you were lucky enough to see it in a real theatre at a time when bell-bottoms were 'in', hard rock was King, and the special effects were cutting-edge.
cool.gif
</div></div>

The original is there, wtf are you talking about?
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

my fave has always been return of the Jedi. I mean who cant love a movie that starts out with prisoners gettin thrown into a sandy vagina in the middle of the desert? and on top of that I destroyed my weener as a wee lad to leigha in her jaba get up. Shoulda named that movie "return of the brown eye" though
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

What I'd like to have is the original three on DVD with NONE of the 'new' special effects, scenes added or edited. Like Greedo shooting first! In what world does that make sense???

I wouldn't mind them being digitally remastered and cleaned up but that's it.
 
Re: Which Star Wars is Best?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: VAJayJayPunisher</div><div class="ubbcode-body">whats meaner, a wookie or a yetti?

who'd win in a fight, a zombie or a storm trooper?

is yoda GAY? </div></div>

What?????