• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

Sidearms & Scatterguns Sig P229 review

Cegorach

Sergeant
Full Member
Minuteman
Nov 29, 2009
754
7
33
Juneau, AK
I was in the market for a midsize 9mm and I ended up picking up Sig P229 e2. After handling a multitude of other options including Glock, M&P, and XD it was clearly the most comfortable in my hands.

Despite reading recent concerns about Sig quality I plunked down the princely sum required and took one home.

Initial inspection revealed a very nicely machined and finished gun. Everything fits together well and it exudes a quality feel. It's definitely a bit chunky and heavy, but that doesn't bother me as this will be range/outdoors gun.

Today I finally got out to the range and put 305 rounds through it. Ammunition included WW 115, FC 115, Blazer Aluminum 147, SPR 124, and Fiocchi Xtrema 147. It ran every round without a single stoppage. The only issue was the Fiocchi failed to lock back the slide on an empty mag. This didn't surprise me because it was obviously very lightly loaded.

Observations:
The trigger is very smooth and crisp, however it has a fairly long pull and reset. At some point I will send it in for a trigger job or an SRT.

Recoil was smooth and light. Clearly this is where the heft pays off.

As previously mentioned, the reliability has been great so far. Hopefully this trend will continue into meaningful round counts.

In a few weeks I will be taking a class with it and will be able to provide more feedback, but so far so good. Let me know if you have any questions.
 
Re: Sig P229 review

Fellow Senna fan:

I'm not a Sig freak, and I'm certainly aware of the so-called Exeter NH Sig "quality issues", but I haven't seen or been privy to them...

I own an early Sig GSR (1911), an Exeter gun, and it is fabulous.

My buddy has an Exeter 226 and 229, both of which in 357, both have been excellent. The 229 has ~5000 rounds through, and it has never malfunctioned. Great gun.

I really, really want to like Sig "P" pistols, but I'm just not a "sig guy". I hate DA/SA triggers, the magazines are too expensive for my blood, they're too heavy, and the bore axis is too high. Those are all very personal issues.

Undoubtedly however, Sigs are great. Glad you like it.
 
Re: Sig P229 review

I agree, I really wish they did the 229 in SAO. That would be the best solution to my trigger dislikes.
 
Re: Sig P229 review

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Cegorach</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I agree, I really wish they did the 229 in SAO. That would be the best solution to my trigger dislikes. </div></div>

I would get another one for sure if they did.
 
Re: Sig P229 review

I would like to try a DAK model. I love a Glock trigger. If DAK has a short and fairly light first stage, a distinct 2nd stage with clean letoff, I might become a Sig guy yet.
 
Re: Sig P229 review

Congrats on your new gun. I recently bought the same, but in 40s&w, and it's been great to shoot. Same thing; no failures, great range/nightstand gun, and smooth recoil. I too have been fortunate to not yet see any issues with mine. Enjoy!
 
Re: Sig P229 review

Love mine. Smoother recoil than my Glock 23,I added trijicon night sights, SRT trigger, and hogue grips. Very accurate for me
 
Re: Sig P229 review

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: turbo54</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I would like to try a DAK model. I love a Glock trigger. If DAK has a short and fairly light first stage, a distinct 2nd stage with clean letoff, I might become a Sig guy yet.</div></div>

It's long and light the second stage is a little shorter but a little heavier if you are looking to go DAK from Glock it takes a while to transition, and training is key.

I have transitioned from a Glock collection to a Sig DAK collection.
 
Re: Sig P229 review

I carry a 229 DAK in 357 for work. In about 7000 rounds I have had 2 FTFs which were caused by faulty primers. It took me a long time to get used to the DA but now that I have I love it.