Re: anyone use Quickload????
Well, in .223/5.56mm I've just found that one old 16.5-inch carbine pretty much duplicates LC M193 ball with 27.1 of one powder, but those same cartridges blow out of a newer carbine at a screaming fast and overpressure 3235 fps.
We're not supposed to get 20-inch speeds from a 16.5-inch barrel.
QuickLoad predicts only 50 fps difference from the 1.0-gr difference in fired case capacities (SAME cases) between the two.
Perhaps QL needs to include twist rate? The slow barrel is 1:12, the fast one is 1:7. I adjusted the Ba value to match the newer one's speeds and 25.2 gr is supposed to back it down to 3050 fps and safe pressure. We shall see. Wish I knew more about the rest of the burn rate variables to tweak to get QL to match my powder in my rifle(s).
So I'm seeing almost 200 fps difference in these. Just like how one 6-inch .357 revolver was 100 fps faster than another (from the same maker, no less).
Sometimes it's not "wrong", it's just DIFFERENT.