Re: Butler Creek sizes for S&B 5-25x56 PMII
I've got a size 17 on the eyepiece and a 46 on the objective. My 5x25 PMII came from S&B with Butler Creek caps in the box. In my opinion, the size 17 is too tight of a fit and I would try a size 18 on the eyepiece.
Oddly enough, my 4-16x42 PMII came with a set of bikini scope caps instead of the Butler Creek flip covers that came with my 5-25x56