• Get 25% Off Access To Frank's Online Training

    Use code FRIDAY25 and SATURDAY25 to get 25% off access to Frank’s online training. Want a better deal? Subscribe to get 50% off.

    Get Access Subscribe

Grayboe vs McCubed

deltawiskey

DILLIGAF
Full Member
Minuteman
Feb 13, 2017
1,288
1,511
Michigan
I find this interesting...as I see it, the McMillan's are in competition with each other.
Has anyone been following these two stocks? Im curious as to what the pros and cons are between the two.
basically, what one would you choose and why?
DW
 
I'm not familiar with the mc cubed stocks and saw the post above discussing McMillan stocks, so answered accordingly.

However, since you now know that the McCubed are polymer and the Greyboe are composite, that right there tells you of a major difference between the two. Material of construction makes a difference.
 
I have a new Greyboe. Filler used to touch up even on the edges. Barrel channel off. A call to their recommended vendor resulted in way too many syllables.
HS gets bad press but I wish I had one on my bench right now.
 
The inletting on the Greyboe stocks is very generic. If you like the A5, T4/2 EH1 style stock, they are are perfect. Basic, yes. Cheap also. The bottom metal inlet is perfect on mine. Its the barrel, bolt handle, action and ejection port inlet I an referring to as generic.
 
I have a new Greyboe. Filler used to touch up even on the edges. Barrel channel off. A call to their recommended vendor resulted in way too many syllables.
HS gets bad press but I wish I had one on my bench right now.

I have my Rem 700P LTR in a Grayboe Renegade stock. I can also say that my barrel channel is slightly off, although its still completely free-floated and purely cosmetic. I have consistent, repeatable accuracy with the stock and I am happy with it for the price. The inletting for my DBM is also perfect with a nice snug fit. They also have precision installed nuts in the forend that I have used to attach my bipod rail, and they seem rock solid.

Overall, im very happy with the Grayboe stock, and I don't think it can be beat for the price. I would like to see left hand versions, and also adjustable cheek pieces though!
 
I wonder about the trend shifting towards full polymer stocks vs fiberglass. Factory stocks have been full polymer for a while and they seem to get the job done, I am not sure what that means for aftermarket stocks. I am guessing that with the proper bedding or blocks it would not make much of a difference other than cost. I listened to the podcast on the grayboe stocks and apparently they are exactly the same as the McMillan a-5 being produced on license from McMillan. Still, if the fit and finish aren't the same quality as McMillan I would tend to go with the original. At least you know with the Mc3 stock that it would have the quality of McMillan even with another medium.
 
Thanks for all the feedback!
What my take from all this is that the McCubed will hopefully have better overall quality than the Grayboe.
And most likely a guy will still be better off to spend the extra cash and get the original McMillan stock.
DW
 
Hopefully something is offered in LH by either company. I have a Grayboe on my LH 700, but I had to do the conversion myself. Barrel channel is straight, and inlet quality didn't matter because of the work involved to convert to LH. It needed bedded and painted anyway.

I'd like to get a different stock for my LA 700LH CDL, and either of these are in my price range. I just don't want to go through a conversion again.
 
I wouldn't say they are competing, I'd say they are keeping in the family. McMillan sold McMillan Firearms to Strategic Armory Corp back in 2013.

I have a Grayboe Renegade and think its great for the price. Its a little heavy at 4lbs but it's been rock solid.
 

8 month old thread but I’m looking to upgrade my stock to something with a wider palm swell than the magpul. I ll just move the magpul to a 223 trainer for the time being but could anyone chime in on the question quoted above?
 
8 month old thread but I’m looking to upgrade my stock to something with a wider palm swell than the magpul. I ll just move the magpul to a 223 trainer for the time being but could anyone chime in on the question quoted above?

What do you get with the Grayboe as aposed to the B&C style 6, here goes.
1) A true A5 pattern stock with a butt hook and flat section behind the hook that tracks straight in a rear bag during recoil if that's what you prefer, I do.
2) Pillers installed with an easy option for bedding as opposed to a V-Block that may or may not be straight as some have reported them being out of wack. I have an older style 2 that is dead nuts straight but still a consideration.
3) A homogenous design that is user friendly to multiple modifications such as adjustable cheek piece, flush cups without cutting into the internal aluminum structure of the B&C.
4) If bought the way I did a high quality A5 pattern bottom metal for the same price as the B&C stock alone.

The B&C stock does have an adjustable cheek piece already and pretty similar ergos but I liked the Grayboe design better and it had more of the features I wanted and feel that it is higher quality than the B&C.

I still own two different B&C stocks and like them both but I would choose the Grayboe again over them, I also have a Manners T4 and the Grayboe seems more solidly constructed but the finish isn't as refined as the Manners.

I'm sure I left some things out but that was my take on it after looking at both.
 
Greyboe is composite. McMillan is Fiberglas.
Fibeglass is a composite, made of layers of glass fiber cloth and a resin (typically a polyester or single part epoxy). Those layers could be sandwiching a light weight core made of many materials depending on the end use.

Even without seeing one, I'm going to bet Grayboe stocks are made of fiberglass.

I suspect most of Garyboe's cost reductions come from reducing the amount of labor that it takes to make their stocks. How? I don't know and they're not telling. But if I had to guess I bet it includes heavy use of pre-impregnated layups.