if i was a smith and somebody brought that back to me, i would probably tell them to fuck off (assuming i wouldn't ship something like that).
And you know what.... You are totally fine to do that regardless if the barrel looked like that or not....cuz capitalism.... it's great and I like options.
Just don't be pissed when word of mouth starts hitting back assuming you did ship that barrel as is

and then told the customer to F off and possibly told him to meet you at the firing line with 5k for a good ole winner takes all shoot off if he doesn't like it cuz you won the palma worlds in 1982. You hang at least 10 sticks a year for your comp rifle and only shoot the ones that "hummer" and that the one you chambered for me will probably outshoot me any day of the week so stfu and deal with it lol

.
I agree smith should be contacted first before he shoots it, at least let him know so he doesn't pull the old well you didn't break it in properly and your nylon brush you said you cleaned it with, chewed up all this steel and left all these marks. Not my problem.
I also like the OP don't have 12 barrels being hung every year with enough components to blow in today's market trying to find out which ones will shoot and which won't. If I'm paying 6-800 for a quality barrel and chamber job, I expect it to look like a 6-800 barrel and chamber job.
It's 2021... Bore scopes are only going to get into more hands as the technology allows it love it or hate it....
Your customer service as a smith needs to adapt or your business will fail especially as word of mouth travels on social media.
I'd be interested to hear
@LongRifles Inc. opinion for the OP
LRI has always blown my expectations away as a customer with their CS