Looking at a 2.5-10x42 nsx vs the mk6 3-18 for a scar 17 in a dmr /spr role.
thoughts?
What kind of distance or "normal" engagement? The 2.5-10x42 is a wonderful scope, has parallax adjustment, its nice and light, but lacks the glass quality, FFP and tube size of the barely larger ATACR 4-16x44. If you want apples to apples on comparison, id say that's a closer game than the MK6 vs NXS. Another option since youre saving a few bucks on the 2.5-10 is mount an off set MRDS for a true 1x ability, since the 10x will get you to 1000m pending round use and skill level. I bounce back and forth on my Scar with a 1-6, 1-8, 2.5-10x, 4-16 etc because even though I "Want" it as a CQB gun, in reality, the reason I like it most is the light weight of the gun, and how simple it is to just toss a bipod on and plink to whatever distance I want, effortlessly. Its getting the new NF ATACR 1-8 now, which will likely be how it stays for a long time, but before that, I was in the same boat you were.
Cant really go wrong with any of them, I just decided even though I probably wont ever use the red dot, my OCD can rest now that I have that capability!