Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

81Z4ME

Sergeant
Full Member
Minuteman
Feb 14, 2010
181
0
67
VA
Guys, if you want to bitch/complain/cry about Appleseed do it someplace besides a thread where someone asked about a rifle to take to an Appleseed.

One of the things you (should have) read and agreed to when joining here was to try to keep topics on track.

Now to some of the comments on the Appleseed rifle thread (which I didn't respond to there because that threads for questions/comments about Appleseed rifles, or so I thought when I read the original post)

You think Fred needs someone to stick up for him? You really don't know Fred. You think I'm here to stick up for Fred? You don't know me. You don't like Fred? I don't care. I don't have much use for him either, so what. What has that got to do with helping a guy that's asking questions about his rifle set up?

I didn't say I was a "former instructor". I told the truth, after having cartilage removed from my left knee, two steel plates and 7 screws put in my right lower leg bones to hold stuff together, some back problems, a thing the docs call "irritable bowl syndrome" because they can't figure out what causes it or how to fix it that results in me getting up from 1 to 3 times a night to take a gassy, loose bowel dump and keeps me pretty much tired and wore out all day (on a good day I might only hit the bowl 5 times, a bad day can be 8 or 9 times)I've decided to stay at home on weekends.

When I edit a post I'll say what I edited and why, unlike one guy in the rifle thread that first agreed with my post and said he wouldn't post in that thread about Appleseed anymore but then came back and deleted all that just to go back to whining about how his age and physical condition kept him from doing what everyone else is doing. You're old and can't do the things you used to do? Join the crowd. It sure beats the alternative doesn't it?

You don't know how thankful I am that that irritable bowl syndrome stuff wakes me up in time to get to the bowl at night. Waking up beats the alternatives.

Think there's a lot of folks around here (and everywhere else) that are involved in Appleseed? This time you're right. When I started there were about 25 or 30 instructors (about 3 years ago). Today I hear there's something like 600 instructors and instructor's in training.

One rifle, expensive and difficult to set up? I had a drill sgt. once that explained what the word "assume" means. If you've been there then you already know. That was always one of the things I liked about Appleseeds, all the different rifles. FALs, SKSs, M1 carbines, M1 Garands, M1A's, AR15's, 10/22's, British Enfields, 03A3's, H&Ks/Cetmes, various bolt action hunting/varmint rifles, Marlin/Remington/Glenfield semi-auto .22s, even an occasional bolt action .22, and others I can't remember. Rifles, lots of rifles and lots of folks shooting them.

Appleseed doesn't recommend spending lots of money on your LTR. They recommend putting good sights on it (sights that mimic the military rifle sight picture - there are good reasons for this besides being a military sight picture), putting a 1&1/4" sling/swivels on it (really helps you build steady shooting positions), and 3 or 4 ten round magazines - then they recommend you spend any extra money on ammo to practice with.

Why do they recommend LTR's? Because they are cheaper to buy, cheaper to shoot and cheaper to load out to get someone else started shooting.

Look past your nose at what is being accomplished. You'll be happier if you stop wasting time holding a grudge and trying to convince everyone else to join the pity party.

I didn't come here to promote Appleseed, but my experience and the experience of my youngest son says it works so I'll give my opinion when I think it will help...about marksmanship, training, rifles, or ammo. While I'm old(er), stubborn and opionated, too, I'll try to stick with helping others when I can.

Now, I'll get back to enjoying reading what other folks here are posting about, like that pretty 03A4 sniper rifle.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

Thanks for the welcome. I don't need the pills. I'm old(er), too fat and have really good blood pressure (every time I go to the doctor they say, "hey, that's really good blood pressure for someone your size.") I just take it as a compliment and move on.

Thanks again. This seems like a pretty nice place to talk about nice rifles and shooting them. I hope to be here awhile.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

No worries. Frank and the mods let people can make what they want out of this place. Overall it's a great place.

Only thing is keep an eye out for guys here trying to get your address so they can send you gay porn.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Texagator</div><div class="ubbcode-body">It took me a while to figure out that the "LTR" referenced here is not the Remington 700 Light Tactical Rifle (normally referred to as an "LTR") but rather the Appleseed Project's "Liberty Training Rifle" which is usually a Ruger 10/22 with military style iron sights. On Sniper's Hide, when someone uses the term, "LTR," most people think they are talking about the Remington 700 version.

I've been a firearms instructor for quite a while and I have had some pretty good luck in tactical competitions. I know how to use a G.I. sling, snap in, and shoot from the classical positions. I'm also a history buff who is probably better read on the Founding Fathers and the origins of the U.S. Constitution than the average citizen. I'm a member of the NRA. The Appleseed project ought to be custom made for me. So why don't I go try it out? Because of the reckless rhetoric and commentary that I have read from those who exhibit a judgmental undertone while trying to "evangelize" the whole Appleseed concept. Because some of the online commentary from its most ardent supporters makes it sound like a cult run by crotchety old men. Of course I could be completely off base and maybe that's not what the Appleseed Project is really all about. Unfortunately, that's exactly how it comes across. That's the image that <span style="text-decoration: underline">some</span> of the Appleseed instructors are promulgating with their rhetoric. (e.g. Save the country by teaching people how to shoot .22's at 25 meters?) Much of the internet traffic about the organization has done nothing to dissuade me from that notion. Ultimately, it's enough to keep me from exploring the Appleseed Project any further.

With all due respect, I believe the Appleseed people need to do some serious image work and try to rid their organization of the perceived atmosphere of preachy condescension. There's a helluva lotta people who are both superb shooters and knowledgeable about history. Many of those people are reading the internet traffic about Appleseed and are having some of the same thoughts that I have articulated here. Fix that and I think you'd get a lot more converts. </div></div>

That really sucks. "Image work" doesn't sound all that appealing to me, but from what I can tell, you've given an honest, frank opinion that gives me something to think about.

Seriously, the biggest obstacle in marketing Appleseed is accurately conveying what it is.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

<span style="font-weight: bold">Thanks again. This seems like a pretty nice place to talk about nice rifles and shooting them. I hope to be here awhile.</span>

Hey old fart...........send me a PM and tell me about the 81Z. Anything is welcome as long as it doesn't have "Apple" in it!

And what the Hell are you bitching about? My bowels are about the only things that still work on me!

Shankster......better cover that babe up. I'm going to hurt myself.

Flash...another old fart
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

I was one of the offenders in the other thread. In my mind, the OPs question was answered. He asked why the 10/22 is the official rifle and not a bolt gun. The answer is-because Appleseed is a singularly focused program about competition and avanced marksmanship (contrary to that they advertise).


For reference, my post was ...


<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: gugubica</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Wow, single type of rifle, lots of modifications required, people having to attend multiple events to attain a badge of honor (and they are not good enough until they do), restrictive COF that often results in new shooters thinking they are not good enough and this sport is not fun...

Good work Appleseed, it sounds to me like you took a GREAT idea and fucked it up.
</div></div>

I THOUGHT that the mission of Appleseed was to attract new shooters to our sport and show them how safe and fun it can be. Appearantly, I was wrong about that. It appears that it is now a program for advanced marksmanship skills with the sole purpose of obtaining a badge of honor "rifleman patch."

All that is fine, but they really need to advertise it as such.

It is sad though, it would be nice if there were a national program that actually did atract new shooters, mostly kids, and showed them how fun shooting can be. One that tought them the history and the basics of marksmanship and them let them experience how fun and rewarding it can be instead of making them feel like they are not good enough, frustrated and exhausted. One that focused on shooting any rifle you could scrounge up well, and not a specific type of rifle that you had to buy to even hope to be competative. One that worked with the shooters that needed help instead of just letting them fail some arbitrarry challenge that is hard for even seasoned shooters to do.

See, the thing is...there are lots of competitions that shooters can test thier abilities and challenge themselves...why does a program that is supposed to be targeted at new shooters have to be another one of those?

How about getting new shooters into a setting that encourages them to keep shooting? Show them how good they can be, how much fun it can be, build up some confidence...and them let them advance thier skills in their own ways, at thier chosen competitions, in their chosen disiplines.

Texagator is very correct in the cultish public perception of the group...just look at how many of the faithful came out of the woodwork to defend the program...almost creepy.

I am not posting this to be a dick, I genuinely am disappointed. Appleseed could be a great way to get more people involved in our sport, but it seems to be doing just the opposite.

If even ONE kid walks away from one of your events discouraged about shooting because of the way the program is run, you have just commited and epic FAIL. There is no reason that that should happen.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

Hello,

One of the offenders from the other post. My deepest apologies for my part in that. I did try to keep on topic, or answer questions that were obviously direct follow-ups to the original post.

That aside...

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Quote:</div><div class="ubbcode-body">If even ONE kid walks away from one of your events discouraged about shooting because of the way the program is run, you have just committed and epic FAIL. There is no reason that that should happen. </div></div>
THIS right here is why I write anything I write with regards to Appleseed. I personally witnessed three people under age 18 walk out of the Appleseed I attended. I saw two more grown women do the same. I saw two other grown men - taking it like a man - frustrated to the same point (but, to their credit, they were men about it and did not quit).

After that, I was shocked. You see, I am a martial arts instructor of more than 20 years. I also love shooting. It hurts to see anyone soured to the shooting sports... and with kids the pain is even more unbearable - because their scar is likely for a lifetime.

So what did I do? I did research. I blogged about it. I spoke of it openly on appropriate forums. And mostly, the Appleseed Zombies (heretofore referred to as ASZ's) out there rebuked me for it. They cannot stand anything less than 100% peachy be said about their program. They see it as an end-all-be-all.

And therein lies the problem.

You see, I enjoyed attending the Appleseed. I still am considering attending another (kinda want that silly little green patch). But my shock at how some students were treated and how they reacted assaulted my personal sense of right and wrong. I knew the program was not an end-all-be-all. It is a highly stylized event... poorly marketed and with a bad understanding of what niche they need to fill.

Appleseed is not everything - it is limited in scope. It does a few things very well:
- It teaches fundamental marksmanship, with a bent toward sport shooting.
- It is geared toward an intermediate skill set.
- It decreases a shooter's time between effective shots.

Appleseed does not do everything, on the other hand. Some things Appleseed tries to do (or some people think they do) which just are not so:
- Appleseed is not tactical (they rarely if ever claim this, but many people do get the wrong impression)
- Appleseed is not a "run what ya brung" event. It is geared toward mag-fed semi-autos. Advanced shooters can challenge themselves by bringing a bolt action.
- Appleseed is not for new shooters.
- Appleseed is highly stylized. Sling-shooting helps accuracy to be sure - but is rarely field appropriate, and almost never combat appropriate.

Some faults I see with the program itself:
- Tries to market to inappropriate crowds
"Come and do an Appleseed" They say, without regards to the shooter's skill level or whether the shooter has appropriate equipment.
- Not quite sure who their target market is
This is evident in many areas: They try to be everything for everybody. Hey, increasing enrollment is good, but at what expense?
- The organization as a whole is reluctant to change.
There are some individuals out there that do not fall into this category, but even they do not challenge this fact.
- Poor instructor training.
Let me make this clear - the instructors can flat-out shoot (or at least could by the end of their IBC). What is not so uniform is their ability (or inability) to teach... and many of them make poor coaches. Roger has made some excellent remarks on this forum, my blog, and other forums with regards to this point.

And the biggest fault of all:
When ASZ's are confronted with their program's areas requiring improvement, they do the following:
- Whine
- Say "but... but"
- Make excuses
- Try to get back on one of about 4 or 5 talking points.

Sounds like a bunch of liberals to me.

What the organization <span style="font-style: italic">should</span> do is take the criticism (constructive or otherwise) and examine it. Analyze it. Evaluate it. See if the "shoe fits." See if they can make small changes to improve. But most importantly: they should resist the urge to be so anti-change.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

Hey folks, thanks for coming over here. I can't say I've never hijacked a thread (who can ?
wink.gif
but when someone is asking for help/clarification I just hate to see distractions getting in the way of helping that person.

Maybe part of the reason you saw the things you did is due to the speed the organization is growing at. They really do want to bring new shooters into the sport, that's why the let you bring your wife for free and your kids for free if they're 20 or younger.

Nothing's perfect, I know.

I can't speak for/against what happened at the Appleseeds you attended and won't try to. I've seen folks get upset and leave at some of the Appleseeds I've been to. Sometimes its the weather (too hot, too cold, too wet). Sometimes its lack of conditioning (I know from experience getting into and out of those positions will work on your joints, muscles, etc. - when I went to the RBC in Feb. 2007 I was taking 3 or 4 Aleve a day to get through it.) Sometimes its a misunderstanding mixed in with pride and stubbornness (I've seen folks show up with rifles that had scopes that cost more than my whole set up - M1A and scope - that struggled with the positions, the targets, the slings, etc. and got fed up and went home, after telling me what a great CQB shooter they were or some other shooting discipline).

Appleseed is changing, it has to to continue to grow. Not all change is good change. Sometimes it looks good, till you get there, then you find out where you were was better. It's a fact of life.

As much as I enjoy the look I see on folks faces when what they've learned starts to come together for them I'm just not going to put my old tired overweight butt through the strain of those 2 day events anymore. I may visit one in my area now and then to say hello to good folks I know and good folks I'll meet, but I'm pretty much done with hurting myself over it.

Folks, have a good one, from the "sound" of some of the posts here I think I'll get along pretty good with you as long as we don't talk/preach Appleseed.
smile.gif
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

tip of the day more important than bitching....if you have loose stool, Codine can be taken to reduce the frequency...stay away from beans and cut down on gluten and oily foods...Take miralax for occasional constpation....watch your diet and get a colonoscopy to rule out ulcerative colitis\chrone's and cancer..try live a stress free life
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

OK, so I've rattled off a lot on the problems with the Appleseed project.

One of my pet peeves is people who find fault, but offer no alternatives or feedback. I will not be like that.

On my blog, I've commented on Appleseed, its problems, and some solutions from my point of view. If anyone would like to read them, I offer:
My AAR
My suggestions for the program
Suggestions for Appleseed shooters
And even some points on how ASZ's act...

For the ASZ's reading this post - <span style="font-weight: bold">NOTICE I NEVER SAY I PERSONALLY HAD A BAD TIME</span> - Because <span style="font-style: italic">I actually enjoyed my time there</span>. However, as an experienced martial arts instructor - one who teaches and attends several martial arts seminars each year - I saw the ugly side, too. The side the ASZ's don't want to admit is true. The subject matter that the ASZ's will never directly answer.

The whole thing reminded me of one particular member of my martial arts organization. He is well meaning. He is a superb martial artist. But he has no clue how to market his product or find his niche. So when he teaches, he often frustrates students.

For those who do not wish to click the links I've provided - fair enough. This is no ad for my blog... and I don't get paid for the blog anyways. So I'll sum up my suggestions to the Appleseed project:
1. Don't try to market this to new shooters, yet.
2. Extend the timed portions of the AQT.
3. Reduce the sling use.
4. Teach supported prone.
5. Award more patches / awards that are more visible (Marksman and Sharpshooter, or similar).
6. Do not change the qualifications for "Rifleman"
7. Be accepting of criticisms & suggestions.

If the project would take parts 2-6 to heart, then it might be justifiable to market to brand new shooters at that point.

I also suggest they adopt a standard procedure for older / infirm shooters. Something that allows them to shoot comfortably.
ETA: <span style="font-weight: bold">If folks wanted a physically demanding program that teaches them how to shoot - they'd have joined the Army </span>(or Marines, etc.).

I've heard suggestions that the project should make its current course into two courses. That is not a bad idea. More instruction and a slower pace would be a good "Appleseed 1" and more AQT's and even the newer "speed" AQT (don't know the official name for the 4-minute version), along with a few more tips and/or actual long-range shooting would make for a good "Appleseed 2." This would also be good as a separate class for those without physical limitations. Meanwhile, the "Appleseed 1" could better cater to those with physical limitations.

And most importantly, the program needs to decide whom they wish to attract, and design the program and the marketing to fit that clientele.
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

I am actually thinking of attending a shoot, any opportunity to shoot is a good one. I actually think I am the kind of person they should be marketing to, not new shooters. I do think it will be a challenge with my bolt gun, why not.

I am glad I learned not to take my son though. I was originally hopeing to take him when he was old enough. I will not make that mistake now.

I fully agree with the suggestions above, there should be attainable levels. Let new shooters learn and then go test their skills. Do not make it so hard that they will leave defeated. Let them hit 80% untimed and get a "Sharpshooter" patch. Then they can come back and try to achieve the next level. They will think they have accomplished something and want to get better. Most important, they will feel good about themselves and this new sport.

As it stands now, instead of reinforcing them, if they don't make the predefined level, they are just told, "sorry, you are not good enough. Thanks for playing, go away."
 
Re: Rather than helping hijack the LTR thread.........

I was asked to go to an Appleseen shoot to become an instructor. I went to one of their shoots to observe and decided I'd stick to running my High Power Clinics. I wont go into why, to each his/her own. We all have differant ideas of what works and what dosnt. All shooters are differant, all insturctors are differant.

I will comment on Appleseed for kids. I think the 4H shooting progams are better geared for getting kids interested and keeping them interested in shooting.

I will add that Appleseed seems a bit pricy compaired to high power clinics and 4H shooting programs.

Most people arnt rich, expecially in todays economy, if you want to get more shooters (and I hope thats the goal) then you need to open it up to those who dont have a lot of money.

The lady shooter here that teaches CCW classes and gets appleseed shoots isnt really fond of me for the above reason. I dont charge for my High Power Clinics, I dont charge for my pistol defense classes, and I make a point of telling people that Wyoming CCW rules does not require a expendture of money to get the permit. You can get a Permit in Wyoming by attending a $5 Hunter Safty class (which they will wave if you dont have $5 bucks) or a DD214. Why spend a couple hundred bucks to be able to exercise your rights.

In short, lets keep shooting sports to where any one, regardless of funds can participate.

JMHO