Re: Which rangefinder, Leica 1200 or Bushnell 1500 ARC
Wow, once again it's impressed on me how BADLY we need a set of STANDARD TESTS and "Targets" for LRFs.
I have a Leica 1200 SCAN. Been using it for almost 2 years. I'm disappointed in it. Unfortunely there is always a bell curve of quality, and this one seems to come from the left side of it. This may be expectations, hovever. They may be too high. As I list instances below, I'm reminded of many times it does work near max range.
THE Good
Great Optic--Can resolve bullet holes better with it than with Bushnel or Zeiss Binos in 6 to 8 X range (30 to 35 mm objectives)
(Don't really use it this way, but to be specific for its resolving ability)
I've got deer more or less broadside at 400ish yards. Early summer and the crops were only ankle high. Full Woods boardered the fields past the deer so knowing the field sizes I'm very sure the deer rangings were reasonable. Here in Michigan, it's just hard to get really long distances without something blocking the view. So this isn't saying it can't hit a deer farther, I just can't get those 'shots'.
The OK
Like the Transistor 9V battery use. This likely causes much of the short "full power" lifespan, but like this common battery over some Lituium coin or small cell types. just a preference.
The UGLY
1) Battery Life quite short before "batt low warning" (flashing cursor) happens. If you persist, it will function a LONG time in the "flashing" condition however. It consistently ranges the same object from the same point a yard or two FURTHER after flashing begins than when the battery is Good.
2) I can not range a house at 1000 + yards. The houses included (they're in a line along a road) white aluminum siding; dark brown log; board-white with limestone also; board-white. The log house looks like a barn in shape, and has a lot of roof that is very steep (so somewhat perpendicular to the LRF, likely 60 deg) covered in red asphalt (tar and small stone, many reflective) shingles. It did range the wood line about 100 yards past the buildings.
3) It doesn't range past a "screen" well. Example, Could not get a reading from a farm Silo (cement) or its top (metal, shinny, doomed--and likely skattering light away from LRF), or from a white board farm house with each about 50 yards past a SINGLE line of trees along the road in front of them. The leaves were down. Multiple shots through "holes" in the limbs have been tried, but no range comes back. The distance to the screen was about 400 yards. I have gotten occasional single pulse ranges to a board cottage across a lake about 50 yards into an Oak woods. SCAN worked well on the cottage.
4) It is very good to 500 yards on almost anything. Past that, it's not so good on "point" objects (even as large as 3ft x 6 ft).
5) It will range two same size cards (one dark, one light) 1 yard different, even though they are side by side, or different parts of the same object at SAME distance away. Actually this isn't bad, just curious.