• Watch Out for Scammers!

    We've now added a color code for all accounts. Orange accounts are new members, Blue are full members, and Green are Supporters. If you get a message about a sale from an orange account, make sure you pay attention before sending any money!

How much water should we drink?

RossTaylor

Private
Minuteman
Sep 3, 2012
5
0
36
As I have heard many stories about water making people fat and overweight, I want to know that how much water should a person drink to stay active and fit. I have friends who told me that they've gained so much weight due to drinking too much water even when they weren't thirsty.
Guys, is there any truth in this that we should drink a limited amount of water in a day?
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

I am going to assume that this is a joke. In case it is not, no you don't get fat drinking water. If you weigh yourself and drink a liter of water you will be heavier because the water has weight. However, you haven't gained fat. The second your body uses the water it needs and you take a leak the weight will be gone. I drink around 100 ounces of water a day and I have been losing weight for the last 6 months because water is a part of a healthy diet.

Now, if you replace water with soda in your question then the answer would be yes. Anything full of calories and sugar is going to cause you to gain weight if you drink enough of it. Inlcuding diet soda that replaces sugar with artificial sweeteners.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

the body will always try to maintain a state of hemostasis , if you only drink a half a gallon of water a day your body will only allow so much out unless you sweat badly , if you drink 3 gallons a day you will only maintain so much , the first couple days you may hold a little more but the body will ramp up its processing of the water and you will piss alot more.

water will not make you fat , it can't make you fat

if you get dehydrated and then down a bunch of water you will hold a good bit just as a defense tactic from dehydration.

I do alot of extensive trials with manipulation of water and carbohydrates when I compete and it's funny to talk to people in the medical field about it because they swear it is impossible but we do it several times a year
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

there is whats called water weight frankly if they actually have this issue they need to cut down on the salt intake.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Dracozny</div><div class="ubbcode-body">there is whats called water weight frankly if they actually have this issue they need to cut down on the salt intake. </div></div>

correct to a degree , if a persons sodium intake in normaly high they won't retain any more water than if it were normaly low again the body will seek a balance and eventually even out , people who eat a normal sodium diet then go feast at a shushi buffet can gain several pounds over night simply from the high sudium (and carbs) the best way to combat the nasty morning after bloat is to drink a shit load of water the whole day before eatin like that if you can and if not drink as much as possible during and after the meal , this will cause a flushing effect and help clear the sodium faster

the "water weight" is the reason that people see a massive weight drop the first two weeks into a zero carb diet , water bonds to carb molicules 3/1 so its like getting rid of a bunch of sponges when you cut your carbs.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

“I never drink water because of the disgusting things that fish do in it.”

-- W.C. Fields
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: RossTaylor</div><div class="ubbcode-body">As I have heard many stories about water making people fat and overweight, Guys, is there any truth in this that we should drink a limited amount of water in a day?</div></div>

This is 1000% true. Most modern day athletes don't drink ANY water. Interestingly, food has a similar effect on people (causing them to gain weight). That's why most athletes don't eat, either. Coincidentally, we are learning that exercise causes injury. The current fad in advanced sports medicine is not to train AT ALL. Your best bet is to listen to your friends: stop eating, dont drink anything, and don't exercise. You will weigh nothing in no time.


I kid, I kid. If water is bad for you, I give up on life in general. Your original post is the dumbest thing I have ever heard. Water doesn't cause you to gain weight, but even if it did, isn't LIVING more important than a few pounds? I mean it's only water, THE ONE THING (besides oxygen) THAT WE CAN'T LIVE WITHOUT.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

H2O =\ Carbs =\ Protein =\ Fat. H2O = WATER. Plain and simple. Protons can't become electrons, and water can't transform into fat.

Become acclimated to water and you'll shun carbo beverages, etc. H2O does the body good.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

make sure to drink the light water, diet or the zero water, all other have way too much fish poop in it that makes you fat.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

water is nothing but good for your body and much needed every day. most people dont drink enough.
by far the worst thing you can do is replace water with sodas and other junk drinks. thinking that you will get your water in the soda. big mistake! much more bad shit in those drinks like high fruitcose corn syurp.
guarantee you if you stop the junk drinks and dring more water, you will lose weight.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

I don't think you could if you tried due to you loosing it from sweating and or urinating. Once a person get's there body's H2o balanced and quit soda's alone they will most likely loose weight from that alone. I think that is the easiest weight a person can loose. I take in about 8oz an hour on lazy days when I am at work I take in 4-5gal in 12-14hours and only urinate 2 maybe 3 time's a day.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

The best answer I have is to drink as much as it takes to not get thirsty. If you ever get thirsty, you have not drunk enough.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: attherange</div><div class="ubbcode-body">make sure to drink the light water, diet or the zero water, all other have way too much fish poop in it that makes you fat. </div></div>

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

it depends on where you live. if you live out in dry, hot climate and do alot of outdoor activities, its more than someone living in the humid, cooler regions
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: RossTaylor</div><div class="ubbcode-body">As I have heard many stories about water making people fat and overweight, I want to know that how much water should a person drink to stay active and fit. I have friends who told me that they've gained so much weight due to drinking too much water even when they weren't thirsty.
Guys, is there any truth in this that we should drink a limited amount of water in a day?
</div></div>

Could be true, if your sodium intake is too high, the sodium in your body will absorb the water as retaining water weight. Nontheless, drinking adeqate amount of water is essential. You really have to watch your sodium intake. You see movie stars who get into shape before the making, they watch what they eat, sodium level. Once your metabolism level stays up, your body requires more water and calories.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

All I drink is water! Its better for than anything with sugar in it!
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

Our bodies need water, the body is nearly 60% water. You simply cannot live without it.
Carry a water bottle with you to work or wherever you go and your natural reaction will be to drink it. Try to drink 100+ oz a day, and consume through out the day too. Drink 10-12 oz first thing when you wake up.
Water is friend, drink it
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

Most of the time when I'm in places like Mexico or others the beer is generally safer than the water.

That being said if your trying to get healthy its not the best thing to drink all day.



Ive been trying very hard to drink more and more water. I quit keeping sodas in the house. As someone who used to drink 2 or 3 monsters a day plus mt dew I feel and sleep way way better without as much caffeine plus the boost in water.


That being said just plain water gets kind of old so I keep some limes or lemons in the fridge and throw them in my big old cup I keep around. A little taste plus a splash of vitamin C is great for you.


That being said it is possible to drink TOO MUCH water. It causes and imbalance in your body and can kill you. But the amount required to do that is obscene.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_intoxication
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<span style="color: #FF0000">"H2O =\ Carbs =\ Protein =\ Fat. H2O = WATER. Plain and simple. Protons can't become electrons, and water can't transform into fat.

Become acclimated to water and you'll shun carbo beverages, etc. H2O does the body good."</span>


I will try to be polite but this is a horribly misguided post. I believe your intent and message are good, but what you said to defend the point is not so good.

Protein and fat can both become carbohydrates to your cells. The Krebs cycle is part of this. Read up if you care. Ketones and such are involved. Keto and atkins style diets take advantage of these factors. I'm not endorsing it, but the idea that proteins cannot become carbs in the human body isn't quite accurate.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<span style="color: #CC0000">"The best way to judge the amount of water that you should drink is by the color of your urine. When its above 80 degrees and your exercising or working hard its hard to drink enough to urinate. But the color of the urine stream should be pale yellow not dark yellow.

http://www.livestrong.com/article/507540-the-recommended-amount-of-water-intake-if-exercising/"</span>

Many things will metabilise and change the color of your urine. If you are relatively healthy already and not taking a multivitamin the color of your urine should be pretty pale. Too many things can affect this though to be completely true. some B vitamins will do a number on the color of your piss.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

Ross being worried about water intake is a 2 sided sword. You want to make sure you drink enough to be hydrated. The flip side is you can drink enough that it will eventually leech nutrients and electrolytes.

Rule of thumb is try to get in a gallon a day.

If you exercise, especially if you are a heavy sweater like me, make sure you hydrate while and after working out above your goal of a gallon. If you want to be meticulous, weigh yourself before a work out, then after. What ever you lost, make up for with water.

All of this deals with you being kind of healthy in general. Water is one of the best things you can do for your body though, so in general... DRINK UP.
 
Re: How much water should we drink?

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: SheepsClothes</div><div class="ubbcode-body">[color:#FF0000Protein and fat can both become carbohydrates to your cells. The Krebs cycle is part of this. Read up if you care. Ketones and such are involved. Keto and atkins style diets take advantage of these factors. I'm not endorsing it, but the idea that proteins cannot become carbs in the human body isn't quite accurate.
</div></div>

The body uses glycogen for its first choice of energy , carbs are converted into glycogen for the body to use as fuel.

In a diet where no carbs are consumed the body will convert over to using ketones (taken from dietary fat) as fuel this is known as going into "ketosis" the brain will use ketones to survive though its not very effecient this is why people in ketosis seem to be a little bit "foggy" with their rational thinking at first as the body get aclimated to the new fuel.

In a diet where both fats an carbs are very restricted the body will make glucogen from protein that it breaks down from muscle in the process called glycogenisis , this is not where you want to be because the body will attack the muscle before using dietary protein thus muscle wasting and unless you are a moderate dose on an anabolic steroid and large quanities of protein you will lose muscle.

Now back to water , the body can't and won't use water for an energy source , no way shape for form. Drinking to little water is bad for you especialy when you are sweating alot , in the cold its bad because it doesn't keep the kidneys flushed , think of this like a water filter than only sees limited use , they clog quickly and become ineffecient. Drinking to much water will flush out the needed minerals to maintain healthy body function. So to little water can cause cramping due to bad electrolyte imbalance and to much water will do the same.

As i mentioned before , the body is amazingly adaptive and will always try to maintain a balance "hemostacis" , if you steadly drink alot of water you will NOT ratain musch water and if you drink very little water you will not exctreat much water as the body wants to hold it as a safety measure.

You can drink 3 gallons of water a day and double salt your food all week then suddenly stop it completely at dinner and seriously fuck yourself up from dehydration by lunch the next day because you body is ramped up to get rid off all the excessive salt and water is can't use and when you stop it doesn't learn fast enough to stop excreating it before it to late thush dehydration.

The body is an amazingly smart and adaptive unit and it doesn't like suden drastic changes so don't go from drinking 1/2 a gallon a day to drinking 3 galons a day and vice versa or you will regret it , same goes for dietary changes
 
I dont know how much water is good to drink but i know I do not like water at all, I have never liked water and probably dont drink a glass of water a month, I have never been sick or anything , I work out side in 90 degree weather all day and have never had any issues so I feel its kind of a myth you need to have it daily, thats my experience with water and have never drank any to speak of and I dont drink coke or pepsi or things like that either, I may have a cup or 2 of coffer a day and a tea and thats good in my book,
 
I don't really think there is a limit as to the amount of water we should drink everyday as long as it's not excessive (think water poisoning). I noticed I gained couple pounds when I began drinking between 60 and 100oz of water aday from drinking maybe 20oz. This is just my body retaining more water from the increased supply to get my body up to a proper level of hydration. Now that I'm drinking this much water I don't really ever feel thirsty anymore and don't urinate excessively (and it's clear) so I feel like this amount of water is good for me.

But since water has no calories, fat, carbs, protein, etc. It cannot make you gain weight besides the weight of the water that your body holds on to.
 
For anyone doing any form of systematic exercise programs or living an active life style then one oz. of water per pound of lean body weight will equate to proper hydration. Now you can go over some and under some as hydration is not an exact science but remember even the slightest level of hydration effects human performance. I know when I do a WAD and am down 10% fluid intake my time/loads suffer to the tune of around 5-8%. And that is LBM or lean body mass and not body weight, so a 180 pound male with 135 pounds of muscle should strive for 135 oz/day.

Sully
 
I dont know how much water is good to drink but i know I do not like water at all, I have never liked water and probably dont drink a glass of water a month, I have never been sick or anything , I work out side in 90 degree weather all day and have never had any issues so I feel its kind of a myth you need to have it daily, thats my experience with water and have never drank any to speak of and I dont drink coke or pepsi or things like that either, I may have a cup or 2 of coffer a day and a tea and thats good in my book,

I call bullshit.
 
mowrey1999, just because your able to function with that limited fluid intake it does not mean your functioning at 100%. It also means internally your body is working overtime and there is is more strain on the renal system and there could also be associated digestive issues. Not to get to scientific but you could be setting yourself up for problems down the road. With that said the human body is highly adaptable, just look at 100 million years of evolution and all the environments humans thrive in, BUT no population has endured without access to large quantities of water. Even desert tribes move from water to water. The human body is made of over 75% water and that is how we run. I am sure your fluid intake is coming from soda, coffee, tea etc. that all contain water as the primary medium to mix the components of the beverage. So your still getting water BUT the body is again working hard to get the H2O out of the fluid.

Try an experiment sometime and try to drink say 72 oz. of water in a day for one month. That is not a lot and should be easy to do. See how you feel overall after and perhaps you will feel and preform better? At the very least it will not hurt you.

Sully
 
Fat people's excuse to not drink water and drink soda instead because they thought both makes them fat anyway, so might aswell drink the sweet stuff haha :D

Bonus: DIET SODA drinkers will have higher risk of becoming diabetic compare to regular soda drinkers.
 
well I wanted to reply about my water intake, as I said I do not drink the recommended amout of water only because I really dont like the taste, as far as getting hydration in other things I probably get some in a cup of coffee or a glasss of tea but thats the only way I can really drink any water without getting sick, I would literally get sick if i drink a couple glasses of water , Its like if someone else drank a couple glasses of vodka I guess is what I would compare it to , as far as my health goes I am perfectly healthy, I have your regular checkups and my cholesterol is fine as well as Blood pressure and my other functions, I dont really eat junk food like fast food places and consider myself pretty healthy or a lot better shape than probably 90 % of others my age so I was just saying drinking water doesnt seem to be a necessity or at least it doesnt bother me not drinking any, I also work outside all day summer thru winter so it isnt like I am in the ac in the summer since i am not, just wanted to reply to the others who had a question,
 
If your urine is dark yellow your not drinking enough it should be clear.
 
The more water you drink, the more water your body will release. Misunderstanding water retention is the cause of people saying it makes you fat. Sodium/potassium intake, along with how much you sweat and water you consume all affect it. Somewhere along the way I read something that suggested 1.2ml per calorie. Approximately 2.5 liters of water for a 2000 calorie diet.
 
As an aside my wife is German and one of the first things she did when we had kids was to say the only liquids consumed were either Milk or Water. Occasionally we got orange juice with calcium. I grew up drinking juice and tea as a kid, and now drink water most of the day - along with some tea or coffee. But our kids (3 boys) only drink water now - with occasional splurges drinking a soda when on a trip or something. I think its a great habit to get into, and I think you would be hard pressed to drink too much water in a normal day as pretty well summed up in this thread. For special occasions - like running a marathon sure - you may not want water but instead a hydration formula but all in all - drink a lot of water - and if your hot, high and dry drink way more than you think you need - better to pee it out than dehydrate.
 
Just wanted to add what I was told when I was doing ROTC at VT: Your urine should be clear and copious. If it's not, DRINK MORE WATER!
 
Thanks for the laughs in this thread guys; somewhat related to the OP - I drink ~1.5 gallons a day if I don't do anything more strenuous than my normal cardio; if I'm working/playing outside in the Tx heat the intake easily tops 2 gallons/day. I've been told that once you start to get thirsty, you are already dehydrated, so I drink lots and often. I find that if I don't, I'll start to get a headache if I'm outside working (probably another symptom of dehydration, but I'm not a Dr.)
 
Enough water so that your urine specific gravity is less than or equal to 1.010 (reference water specific gravity is 1.000)
 
I have Congestive Heart Failure, and fluid buildup is not my friend. I weigh myself on a digital scale, usually at least twice daily, after urinating. I find my body fluctuates through the day by about 3-5 pounds, at least partly due to fluid intake and retention. When I lose too much, I get light headed (dizziness, sometimes profound) if I get up onto my feet too fast. If I retain too much, it constricts my chest so getting a full breath can be difficult.

I asked my VA Primary Care Physician about drinking extra water, and his response was that nobody had yet convinced him that extra water intake has real benefit, and that in my case, with all those blood pressure and diuretic meds my cardiac condition entails, I would do well to avoid 'common wisdom' on the subject. I've already been warned that there is some evidence that kidney failure is beginning to appear, probably triggered by the meds I need to take. Because of those meds, a dry mouth is not a reliable indicator of dehydration, and I need to apply a fluoride gel before bed because of nighttime dry mouth and its propensity for encouraging tooth decay. At least I still have most of them...

Nowadays, when I meet friend for drinks at the VFW, I often drink Cranberry Juice instead of beer.

Checking my weight, reviewing that in comparison to the darkness of my urine, is my method. Enough color to see it, but not darker. At my age (67), fluids after dinner just mean I will have to get up at least once in the night.

Greg
 
Last edited:
Greg, Your Kidney failure is due to not getting enough blood flow which is also due to your CHF. The new research suggest that people with CHF should be doing or many is the term meaning not all, due well when getting some weight training, not power lifting but some resistance is good. Please check with your Dr. before doing anything.
 
I
Nowadays, when I meet friend for drinks at the VFW, I often drink Cranberry Juice instead of beer.

With some of the extra shit in cranberry juice(High Fructose Corn Syrup, and 5% real fruit juice in some cases), versus an all natural German beer via the Reinheitsgebot(The German Purity Law stating that only water, barley, and hops could be used), the German beer would be better for you.

Enjoy.
 
Last edited:
I should also add that the Israeli Army did a study and found that a standard Army canteen of water, an hour, was the best amount for their soldiers.
 
With some of the extra shit in cranberry juice(High Fructose Corn Syrup, and 5% real fruit juice in some cases), versus an all natural German beer via the Reinheitsgebot(The German Purity Law stating that only water, barley, and hops could be used), the German beer would be better for you.

Enjoy.

I have always preferred beers that are brisk, refreshing, and unencumbered by heavier elements of taste. Right now, the beer in my fridge is plain old Busch. The most recent predecessor is Labatt's Blue.

For me, the juice gambit is more about sparing my kidneys, and avoiding drug counteraction of the alcohol with any one (or several) of the 18 meds I need to take daily. I also find that those meds can accentuate beer's intoxicating effects, and I'm really not that into the buzz factor these days. Yeah, sure; there was a time when beer and wine were sorta connoisseur pursuits, but at 67, with health issues, that stuff takes a back seat.

Thanks for trying to help, though...

Greg
 
Greg, Your Kidney failure is due to not getting enough blood flow which is also due to your CHF. The new research suggest that people with CHF should be doing or many is the term meaning not all, due well when getting some weight training, not power lifting but some resistance is good. Please check with your Dr. before doing anything.

Yes, I've allowed my physical conditioning to slide, and it's clearly a factor. This is another prod in the right direction, thanks much.

Greg