The big hole in your argument is - no one does anything to protect anyone when a gang or click or posse take over a hood . Even when those hoods are entire cities . The only thing current popo do is some token arrests -BUT any Joe citizen who dares defend his own hood or protect his womenfolk is hammered .You are still not answering my question, evidently, with a religious fervor. So, you get rid of cops and use secondary or private arbitration. How will that work for you when the posses move into your neighborhood and do what they want to do, regardless of your "Rules of Robert" or even the conventions of the Queen of Attenborough?
Guess what, you are back to needing something that looks a lot like a cop who needs to earn a living because he is too busy protecting you to go and farm his own food or get his own meat.
And then, just to make sure everything is right, even by your arbitration, what does that require? A set of laws and a legal expert to decide, based on those laws.
Congratulations, you just invented police and courts. And even with your idyllic vision, there are going to be protectors or whatever you call them, that do bad things. It is the nature of the beast. All men fall short of the glory of God, even you.
The day it really started for me - the blinders really came off - when the neighbors farm was raided - for selling whole raw unpasteurized milk . SWAT - state boys - FDA - and not only destroyed the milk but smashed all the honey making stuff and the loom for angora AND took all their money they had in the house . No charges no arrests just flex and theft . And when I knew what to look for - yep I saw it everywhere.
Wasn’t the last time SCOTUS upheld “no duty to protect “ in 2018?
So no duty to protect - and they don’t so stop using that as justification for state thugs .