• The Shot You’ll Never Forget Giveaway - Enter To Win A Barrel From Rifle Barrel Blanks!

    Tell us about the best or most memorable shot you’ve ever taken. Contest ends June 13th and remember: subscribe for a better chance of winning!

    Join contest Subscribe

Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

Hey there young Marine
SemperFi Perhaps there is a "little" going on here,Okay?
From your first post, did you go over to the Reserve community after being over there. I take it from "playing in the snow" that maybe you are, really not material here just an inference gained. My younger brother was an GMGS and armorer for a Reserve Seabee battalion and used to go to Minnesota to "play in the snow", met lots of Marines there.
Point is this, you want to get into Long Range shooting, whatever that is and however it is defined, well and good. You want a good weapon's system [read here as rifle/scopes sights etc.,] that is understandable. You don't drive 16 pennies with upholsterers tackhammers. You can spend some money and I mean a "lot of money" really quickly. If that is what you want to do you really can do that. I would suggest to come at a lower stage than something really expensive. Get to know it backwards and forwards; know it's strong p[oints and it's weak points and do not try to go outside the performance envelope until you understand everything thoroughly. Some folks get into this, drop a bucket of money only to have a really beautiful well made 700, Tikka or whatever windup[ sitting in the closet dusting up and the bore pitting, what a sad waste, all for a bit of ego gratification. You may find out that this "is not" for you and that's good and if perchance it is did you ever hear of some guy who spoentan absolute mountain of money, found out he didn't like it took his super whammy slam back to the gunshop or better yet tried to sell it on line? and get his original ;principal back? Generally speaking the answer is a resounding "No", and there it sits in the close going to Hell. The mrket for this kind of weapon is a "niche market" at best. Got news for ya' the average consumer gun buyer is not a niche buyer and he's probably considering himself a "hardholder" if he gets to his R/GC once a year to site in for deer season. Chances are he doesn't put more than a dozen rounds through it a year at all. I know what I'm talking about here, am RSO at our R/GC and the number of guys I have to turn away because weapons come in fouled, dirty, "broke" yeah broken or come to the line loaded. I've seen it all, and these guys think they are "Riflemen". Now, just what does tht have to do with you? If you want to shoot L/R you have to put time into; that is far more valuable than money, than the moneyyou will spend on a weapon. I listen to this site and I hear everything from the sublime to trash. hiow many rounds do yuou want to put down range to learn this discipline? I heard one contributor say he oput out 8,000 rounds year? I think that was what I read. Well I'm not saying anything negative here as I will not quetion a man's veracity; that is extremely rude. But I can sure tell you this from '89 through '91 when I was in my "prime" and shooting on the USN National Team, wife was pissed at me as I was gone forever, I shot on average 200 rounds a week in practice either at Q'town, Fairfax, or Leujeune [?sp?] and sometimes more. That is the equivalent of four National Match 500 point Courses of fire each and every week. You've been on the range; a 500 point match can take just about all day; my whole week was gone.during competition season and tht was before I got on a MATS to go to Pedleton. Not crying here, enjoyed every minute of it and would do it all over again if I were younger. But, what Iam saying here is tht this is no "Norm Abrams New Yankee Workshop...awright out there riflemen let's all be snipers in 30 minutes..." This is going to take time; it "is not" going to be easy I don't give two shits or a damn what anybody says to youand you will have self doubts as surely as the sun rises in the morning. I suggest Savage here, but that's mine; it's my kid and my kids ain't ugly.
Others want to disagree that's fine just don't tell me kids are ugly that's when ya'get the back of my hand smartly laid on. I'm a "hard corps" Chief I "might not" be right but I am never wrong. That's hard for syphilians [ooops spelling] to understand. But, I think you understand you're a Marine. Closing out I think any website that lables you/me or anybody else as "Private First Class" as though there were some Parris Island or Great Lakes NTC pecking order has gotten something fundamentally wrong with it; I know I'm not a PFC I'm the wrong Sailor to play that with. You're not a "noob" you've been through it just like my nephew, 3rd Marines two tours. I put up with it because there is far far too much to learn from the "tech side" of this website, no opining, no silly arsed gotcha'games no time for it: just facts, stats, and tables the "come ups" for 190SMK .308 are really great. The "tech side" is a bloody gold mine. Now, have to go "Pipe Bonnie Dundee", a proper fighting song.

all the best
Anchor's Away/SemperFi
Chief Bull
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

Holy hell this thread is something.

I'd go with the 5R, agree with the "known unknown" analogy. If you're just starting out you want to leave as little to chance as possible for the sake of your enjoyment and your wallet. I had one once upon a time and it was a great gun.
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: ChiefBull</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Hey there young Marine
SemperFi Perhaps there is a "little" going on here,Okay?
From your first post, did you go over to the Reserve community after being over there. I take it from "playing in the snow" that maybe you are, really not material here just an inference gained. My younger brother was an GMGS and armorer for a Reserve Seabee battalion and used to go to Minnesota to "play in the snow", met lots of Marines there.
Point is this, you want to get into Long Range shooting, whatever that is and however it is defined, well and good. You want a good weapon's system [read here as rifle/scopes sights etc.,] that is understandable. You don't drive 16 pennies with upholsterers tackhammers. You can spend some money and I mean a "lot of money" really quickly. If that is what you want to do you really can do that. I would suggest to come at a lower stage than something really expensive. Get to know it backwards and forwards; know it's strong p[oints and it's weak points and do not try to go outside the performance envelope until you understand everything thoroughly. Some folks get into this, drop a bucket of money only to have a really beautiful well made 700, Tikka or whatever windup[ sitting in the closet dusting up and the bore pitting, what a sad waste, all for a bit of ego gratification. You may find out that this "is not" for you and that's good and if perchance it is did you ever hear of some guy who spoentan absolute mountain of money, found out he didn't like it took his super whammy slam back to the gunshop or better yet tried to sell it on line? and get his original ;principal back? Generally speaking the answer is a resounding "No", and there it sits in the close going to Hell. The mrket for this kind of weapon is a "niche market" at best. Got news for ya' the average consumer gun buyer is not a niche buyer and he's probably considering himself a "hardholder" if he gets to his R/GC once a year to site in for deer season. Chances are he doesn't put more than a dozen rounds through it a year at all. I know what I'm talking about here, am RSO at our R/GC and the number of guys I have to turn away because weapons come in fouled, dirty, "broke" yeah broken or come to the line loaded. I've seen it all, and these guys think they are "Riflemen". Now, just what does tht have to do with you? If you want to shoot L/R you have to put time into; that is far more valuable than money, than the moneyyou will spend on a weapon. I listen to this site and I hear everything from the sublime to trash. hiow many rounds do yuou want to put down range to learn this discipline? I heard one contributor say he oput out 8,000 rounds year? I think that was what I read. Well I'm not saying anything negative here as I will not quetion a man's veracity; that is extremely rude. But I can sure tell you this from '89 through '91 when I was in my "prime" and shooting on the USN National Team, wife was pissed at me as I was gone forever, I shot on average 200 rounds a week in practice either at Q'town, Fairfax, or Leujeune [?sp?] and sometimes more. That is the equivalent of four National Match 500 point Courses of fire each and every week. You've been on the range; a 500 point match can take just about all day; my whole week was gone.during competition season and tht was before I got on a MATS to go to Pedleton. Not crying here, enjoyed every minute of it and would do it all over again if I were younger. But, what Iam saying here is tht this is no "Norm Abrams New Yankee Workshop...awright out there riflemen let's all be snipers in 30 minutes..." This is going to take time; it "is not" going to be easy I don't give two shits or a damn what anybody says to youand you will have self doubts as surely as the sun rises in the morning. I suggest Savage here, but that's mine; it's my kid and my kids ain't ugly.
Others want to disagree that's fine just don't tell me kids are ugly that's when ya'get the back of my hand smartly laid on. I'm a "hard corps" Chief I "might not" be right but I am never wrong. That's hard for syphilians [ooops spelling] to understand. But, I think you understand you're a Marine. Closing out I think any website that lables you/me or anybody else as "Private First Class" as though there were some Parris Island or Great Lakes NTC pecking order has gotten something fundamentally wrong with it; I know I'm not a PFC I'm the wrong Sailor to play that with. You're not a "noob" you've been through it just like my nephew, 3rd Marines two tours. I put up with it because there is far far too much to learn from the "tech side" of this website, no opining, no silly arsed gotcha'games no time for it: just facts, stats, and tables the "come ups" for 190SMK .308 are really great. The "tech side" is a bloody gold mine. Now, have to go "Pipe Bonnie Dundee", a proper fighting song.

all the best
Anchor's Away/SemperFi
Chief Bull







</div></div>

HOLY FUCK.............
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: ChiefBull</div><div class="ubbcode-body">hiow many rounds do yuou want to put down range to learn this discipline? I heard one contributor say he oput out 8,000 rounds year? I think that was what I read. Well I'm not saying anything negative here as I will not quetion a man's veracity; that is extremely rude. But I can sure tell you this from '89 through '91 when I was in my "prime" and shooting on the USN National Team, wife was pissed at me as I was gone forever, I shot on average 200 rounds a week in practice either at Q'town, Fairfax, or Leujeune [?sp?] and sometimes more.</div></div><div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: ChiefBull</div><div class="ubbcode-body">I think any website that lables you/me or anybody else as "Private First Class" as though there were some Parris Island or Great Lakes NTC pecking order has gotten something fundamentally wrong with it; I know I'm not a PFC I'm the wrong Sailor to play that with.</div></div>WTF?
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

I edited this because I felt like an idiot for ranting online. To stick to the origional topic, if anyone knows of a good place to buy the threaded 5r please let me know. I actually have an old style 700 trigger laying around for it so the xmark is no big deal.
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

You could always buy one on gun broker and have it shipped to your local ffl. They ussually have one or two 20 inch threaded 5rs for sale on there.
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

a1c0307fffa35ff32d0023466c6058bd.jpg
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Mike</div><div class="ubbcode-body">

Two things here. One, I'm all for a great deal but a magnum is not the way to start, especially one that requires handloads-meaning no match ammo-to get started in LR.</div></div>

For an experienced reloader it was no problem at all. I almost never shoot factory ammo.

Edit: P.S. this site was particularly useful for me in my search for the right bullet, quality brass, a link to the extremely excellent, can't-live-without-it ballistics calculator at jbmballistics, etc. But being an experienced reloader I already knew what the questions were and what the answers should look like.

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Mike</div><div class="ubbcode-body">

Second, a 20" barrel will get you to 1k with no problem under almost all circumstances with match 175g ammo. </div></div>

Why just "get there"? The OP didn't say he was looking for a dual purpose rifle (e.g. "long range competition plus urban warfare"), he said he wanted to shoot long range (and maybe I assumed he meant "compete"). No one I know competes long range with a 20" rifle. It might be what he's used to, but that doesn't necessarily mean that's what he should get. A longer barrel, and a faster twist, preserves options.
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: SWRichmond</div><div class="ubbcode-body">No one I know competes long range with a 20" rifle.</div></div>Then you should make the trip to the Sniper's Hide Cup or the Rifles Only Bash and get to know some of us. At the ASC issue match everyone shot a 20" FN SPR with 175SMKs.<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: SWRichmond</div><div class="ubbcode-body">A longer barrel, and a faster twist, preserves options.</div></div>Actually a faster twist on a shorter barrel preserves options. In general, with a higher velocity you can get away with a slower twist.
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Graham</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Then you should make the trip to the Sniper's Hide Cup or the Rifles Only Bash and get to know some of us. </div></div>

I'd be delighted to start shooting tactical matches, and have sought them in my geographic area. Working on a rifle for the purpose right now.

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Graham</div><div class="ubbcode-body">At the ASC issue match everyone shot a 20" FN SPR with 175SMKs.</div></div>

The exception, of course, does not make the rule.

<div class="ubbcode-block"><div class="ubbcode-header">Originally Posted By: Graham</div><div class="ubbcode-body">Actually a faster twist on a shorter barrel preserves options. In general, with a higher velocity you can get away with a slower twist. </div></div>

Yes, and it is easier to get a higher velocity with a longer barrel, isn't it? Thus preserving <span style="font-style: italic">more</span> choices, in theory at least, than a shorter barrel would.

If the .308 / 175SMK was adequate for shooting distance, why would the military be so interested in the 300WM? In other words, why handicap oneself with that with which one is familiar?
 
Re: Just when I thought I had my mind made up!

I have a rem 5r that ive tuned up a little and i can say that the rifle DOES shoot.But i bought into the hype on these rifles and what what i really wanted was a real precision rig .

Its still a factory rig and will only take you so far , its a good trainer but it also depends on what you want to do , If your shooting steel ect. its great But if your going into comp.i would recommend get you a custom and do it right the first time .

I wish i would have just had a rig built and save me a shit load of cash

GL Friend
Keep the rubber side down