I'm looking for some insight on an optic for a SCAR MK17. It will be used for deer, hog, and coyote hunting, run and gun, and just a fun gun. Thanks, ADT.
Rifle Scopes SCAR 17S Optic Choice
- Thread starter ADT
- Start date
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
I had a NXS 2.5-10 and currently have a 1.8-10, so I can offer you insight on both of those cartridges. I also had a SCAR 16s, and I would say that a 10x optic would be overkill on that platform, unless the trigger pull is not an issue for you (it definitely was a limiting factor for me.)
The NXS is a nice scope, I just prefer FFP and couldn't get used to the SFP. Get a thicker reticle if you go that route- I went with a NP-R2 and it was too thin. As for the USO, it is a really nice optic, but a bit on the heavy side. I vote ACOG because of the weight and the speed.
I had a NXS 2.5-10 and currently have a 1.8-10, so I can offer you insight on both of those cartridges. I also had a SCAR 16s, and I would say that a 10x optic would be overkill on that platform, unless the trigger pull is not an issue for you (it definitely was a limiting factor for me.)
The NXS is a nice scope, I just prefer FFP and couldn't get used to the SFP. Get a thicker reticle if you go that route- I went with a NP-R2 and it was too thin. As for the USO, it is a really nice optic, but a bit on the heavy side. I vote ACOG because of the weight and the speed.
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
10x is not overkill if you're hunting for coyotes and nice to have for hogs if you're going for a head shot. The NF and USO cover all the bases.
10x is not overkill if you're hunting for coyotes and nice to have for hogs if you're going for a head shot. The NF and USO cover all the bases.
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
I'm watching this one because I just bought a SCAR Heavy and I'm looking for a scope. I was thinking USO 1.5-6, but weight is an issue as it is with the IOR which is an option if you can put up with the potential problems you might have.
I wish Trijicon would take the Accupoint and make it battle ready and have a 1-6X model. Although I've heard that Accupoints are sometimes used in action now. I love the fact that they have no batteries, and that they are realtively light. Of course if they make it battle ready it might end up being heavier.
The ACOG is very nice, but I don't care for fixed optics, so I'd have to add a red-dot, but that is not optimal either. It would be cool if Trijicon built the Acog in variable, or built the ACOG housing with the red-dot built in and protected.
To me a 1-8X would be perfect, like the new Short Dot, but I'm not sure I want to pay that kind of money for a scope as I could buy a second SCAR and a cheaper scope for about a $1000 more.
So, I'll watch to see if a clear winner emerges, BTW I voted for the USO sn-4 1.5-6x.
CHEERS--
I'm watching this one because I just bought a SCAR Heavy and I'm looking for a scope. I was thinking USO 1.5-6, but weight is an issue as it is with the IOR which is an option if you can put up with the potential problems you might have.
I wish Trijicon would take the Accupoint and make it battle ready and have a 1-6X model. Although I've heard that Accupoints are sometimes used in action now. I love the fact that they have no batteries, and that they are realtively light. Of course if they make it battle ready it might end up being heavier.
The ACOG is very nice, but I don't care for fixed optics, so I'd have to add a red-dot, but that is not optimal either. It would be cool if Trijicon built the Acog in variable, or built the ACOG housing with the red-dot built in and protected.
To me a 1-8X would be perfect, like the new Short Dot, but I'm not sure I want to pay that kind of money for a scope as I could buy a second SCAR and a cheaper scope for about a $1000 more.
So, I'll watch to see if a clear winner emerges, BTW I voted for the USO sn-4 1.5-6x.
CHEERS--
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
I vote for anything with a max magnification over 4x on a .308 rifle. For me target identification is too slow at distances greater than 500yds with a 4x. I'd go with the nxs in 2.5 to 10x.
I vote for anything with a max magnification over 4x on a .308 rifle. For me target identification is too slow at distances greater than 500yds with a 4x. I'd go with the nxs in 2.5 to 10x.
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
agree with others, something like a 1.5-6x42 ill ret is about ideal
I am testing 2 on my 6.8 I use for hunting
S&B with flashdot 9
Kahles with circle dot reticle
both are great scopes
the Kahles is about a 1/4lb lighter and the glass between the two is very, very comparable
agree with others, something like a 1.5-6x42 ill ret is about ideal
I am testing 2 on my 6.8 I use for hunting
S&B with flashdot 9
Kahles with circle dot reticle
both are great scopes
the Kahles is about a 1/4lb lighter and the glass between the two is very, very comparable
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
I'd suggest a NF 2.5-10x24 -- I know several folks that are happy with it on that very rifle..
Kevin
I'd suggest a NF 2.5-10x24 -- I know several folks that are happy with it on that very rifle..
Kevin
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
I think the NF 2-10X is a great choice. I will throw out the IOR Spartan 2-12x as another choice. I have one on my pof308 and love it.
I think the NF 2-10X is a great choice. I will throw out the IOR Spartan 2-12x as another choice. I have one on my pof308 and love it.
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
Depends how you want to employ it. I think that the best option for it is a short dot 1-8x, but those are friggin' expensive. Short of that, I personally was planning on getting one as a battle rifle configuration with a Weaver Tactical 1-5x or the USO SN-4 1.5-6x. Something that was in keeping with the platform for very low end magnification with a moderate upper end magnification.
Depends how you want to employ it. I think that the best option for it is a short dot 1-8x, but those are friggin' expensive. Short of that, I personally was planning on getting one as a battle rifle configuration with a Weaver Tactical 1-5x or the USO SN-4 1.5-6x. Something that was in keeping with the platform for very low end magnification with a moderate upper end magnification.
Re: SCAR 17S Optic Choice
i'm also trying to select a scope for my SCAR 17s.
i've been considering the NXS 3.5-15 x 50 F1.
any reason not to go with that? i like the 15x for those 500 yard shots and the F1 seems to nice fast way to get on target quickly.
right now, that's my first choice - i can't think of any reason not to go with it - i'd appreciate any feedback.
i'm also trying to select a scope for my SCAR 17s.
i've been considering the NXS 3.5-15 x 50 F1.
any reason not to go with that? i like the 15x for those 500 yard shots and the F1 seems to nice fast way to get on target quickly.
right now, that's my first choice - i can't think of any reason not to go with it - i'd appreciate any feedback.
Ditto. Need a reasonable scope for my SCAR 17. Is the NF 2.5-10 still the go to optic? Seems like a tough optic and I love my NF-F1. I'm not crazy about the fact that the 2.5-10 is SFP only though.
