What say ye oh wise ones ?

Boatninja

Major Hide Member
Full Member
Minuteman
  • Sep 3, 2018
    1,118
    1,033
    Out there somewhere
    7037221
    Shot round robin style at 300 yards
     
    Put up some 1-2" dots only on blank paper (smaller aiming point)
    Reshoot it but shoot them as individual 5 shot groups and take plenty of time. (assuming RR style means 42 then 42.2 then 42.4 etc and back to 42 and back down the line)

    42 and 42.4 have the best vertical spread. Hard to say where the horiztonal is coming from, wind, getting off the gun, trigger pull, etc.
     
    Put up some 1-2" dots only on blank paper (smaller aiming point)
    Reshoot it but shoot them as individual 5 shot groups and take plenty of time. (assuming RR style means 42 then 42.2 then 42.4 etc and back to 42 and back down the line)

    42 and 42.4 have the best vertical spread. Hard to say where the horiztonal is coming from, wind, getting off the gun, trigger pull, etc.
    That is precisely how I shot those targets and that is a 2 inch dot. I went up the scale one shot with each charge weight. Then a cooling., Then down the scale the same way cooling. And then up the scale. There was a bit of a breeze from the right.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: gconnoyer
    I would test this, 42.3, 42.4, 42.5, 42.6, 42.7 just to make sure you arent seeing a fluke.
    I will try that, it will probably be next weekend before I have access to a 300 yard range. The Hogden manual showed a maximum size charge weight of 42.6, but I was showing no high-pressure signs, I had an experienced reloaded observing. In another publication I saw loads with the same powder up to 44 g, that is H4350
     
    • Like
    Reactions: gconnoyer
    Put up some 1-2" dots only on blank paper (smaller aiming point)
    Reshoot it but shoot them as individual 5 shot groups and take plenty of time. (assuming RR style means 42 then 42.2 then 42.4 etc and back to 42 and back down the line)

    42 and 42.4 have the best vertical spread. Hard to say where the horiztonal is coming from, wind, getting off the gun, trigger pull, etc.
    Yeah I would say shoot them as groups.
    If you're moving, breaking your position, etc between shots in each group there could be some variation caused by that as well.

    I am assuming that you are not familiar with the OCW method of load development. This is exactly not what he is trying to accomplish.
     
    I will try that, it will probably be next weekend before I have access to a 300 yard range. The Hogden manual showed a maximum size charge weight of 42.6, but I was showing no high-pressure signs, I had an experienced reloaded observing. In another publication I saw loads with the same powder up to 44 g, that is H4350
    You can and probably should do OCW at 100 yards in order to remove the possible influence of wind on your results.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: EXTREMEPREJUDICE
    I am assuming that you are not familiar with the OCW method of load development. This is exactly not what he is trying to accomplish.

    I'm familiar with it, I use the same process for my ladder tests.
    But if I have something that looks like his targets, I would be trying to eliminate a difference in my shooting as much as possible.
     
    If its really calm and youre confident in your abilities then shoot it at 500.
    If you arent confident that you cant blame yourself for fliers then shoot it at 100 to get a bit more confidence that it was you and not environmentals that threw the shot out wide.

    I shoot tests at 100 more frequently than I do at distance. But I always make sure it still works at 500 before I call it "done."
     
    • Like
    Reactions: lash
    None of that matters when we can see the results on his targets.

    One area looks much more promising than the others. (not denying more complete info wouldn't be helpful)


    But its also mostly in his previous posts.
     
    If its really calm and youre confident in your abilities then shoot it at 500.
    If you arent confident that you cant blame yourself for fliers then shoot it at 100 to get a bit more confidence that it was you and not environmentals that threw the shot out wide.

    I shoot tests at 100 more frequently than I do at distance. But I always make sure it still works at 500 before I call it "done."
    Asking because a 200 range is easy but longer range will be next week and I
    You guys are recommending a load without knowing the cartridge, the bullet, or the temp? Man, you guys are good!
    You guys are recommending a load without knowing the cartridge, the bullet, or the temp? Man, you guys are good!
    Just to bring you somewhat up to speed, nobody but Hogdon has recommended a load that I am loading and I find them very conservative compared to some that I have seen. I asked if anyone had a pet load on a completely different , short barrel thread totally out of curiosity, and what is the harm in sharing findings? Not that there isn't a ton of official data online, but very little in print on 6mm Creedmore. It's a balmy 70 degrees here in South Texas, you should come down and visit, it's amazing what some pleasant weather and friendly people can do for one's attitude.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Howland
    I would test this, 42.3, 42.4, 42.5, 42.6, 42.7 just to make sure you arent seeing a fluke.
    I think that Mr. Spife is right. You stopped at 42.6 and said that there is no pressure signs. You still have vertical and that suggests that you need more powder. Good groups are small and round. I would keep increasing powder in 0.1 grain increments until

    (a) you go through the node and see your groups grow or
    (b) you see pressure signs.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Boatninja
    Yep. 42.5gr and play with seating depth to see if you can find a slightly less vertical group. That will . But honestly, a .3-.5moa group at 300 might not need much tuning depending on your skill and equipment.

    If this is a custom barrel, I'd say you could likely tune a bit more. If it's a factory Ruger or someth4 similar, I'd take .5moa or better and walk away smiling.
     
    Yep. 42.5gr and play with seating depth to see if you can find a slightly less vertical group. That will . But honestly, a .3-.5moa group at 300 might not need much tuning depending on your skill and equipment.

    If this is a custom barrel, I'd say you could likely tune a bit more. If it's a factory Ruger or someth4 similar, I'd take .5moa or better and walk away smiling.
    16.5" Criterion barrel. I'm thinking node may be narrow. Which way on seating depth? Or better question what increments?
     
    Last edited:
    16.5" Criterion barrel. I'm thinking node may be narrow. Which way on seating depth? Or better question what increments?
    Well I'm not sure where you are in reference to your lands already but generally I do the following:
    First pass 4rounds ea:
    • -.010
    • -.040
    • -.070
    • -.100
    • -.130 (as long as not seating ogive past neck.)
    Then say -.040 worked best. I'd confirm with following:
    • -.025 (.015 longer than best node)
    • -.033 (.007 longer than best)
    • -.040 (best node above)
    • -.047 (.007 shorter than best)
    • -.055 (.015 shorter than best)
    It will tell you how wide the node is and I usually load to the longest oal that is still in the same node or *slightly* (maybe .003 longer.) to allow bullet to stay in node as throat moves forward. After 200-300 rounds, check distance to lands again and adjust length back to best depth if necessary.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Boatninja