• The Shot You’ll Never Forget Giveaway - Enter To Win A Barrel From Rifle Barrel Blanks!

    Tell us about the best or most memorable shot you’ve ever taken. Contest ends June 13th and remember: subscribe for a better chance of winning!

    Join contest Subscribe

..

Re: Not all comparators are equal, Sinclair v Horniday


Actually it's a non issue. It does not matter what size bore the comparator has, so long as it's say .002" smaller than bullet diameter. I ahve used many different brands and made a bunch in the lathe with just whatever drill bit seemed would work.

What DOES matter is that you develop your load and continue to use the SAME individual comp for ALL your loading for that cartridge/rifle.

It's kinda like this: say you buy a CHEAP tape measure that is actually 7/8" off. or in that much error. say you need to cut a new shelf board for your book shelf. Well so long as you measure the gap with the bad tape measure, then measure the new board stock and cut it with the bad tape measure- you'll have a perfect fit. you won't get messed up unless you throw a different tape in the mix.

and you comparing two different comps is throwing two different tapes into the mix.
 
Re: Not all comparators are equal, Sinclair v Horniday

I was curious about this also. I ordered two comparator inserts from Sinclair and there is a noticeable difference between them.
 
Re: Not all comparators are equal, Sinclair v Horniday

hey bud, I saw the title post, and was like "oh shit" someone's having the same issue that we had today! HA!!! Thanks again for the help...guess I'll go pick up that OAL gauge at Cabby's.