Ok, so I am at a loss trying to figure out why my rifle isn't shooting better. Here are the specs on the rifle, Remington 700 AAC-SD, MCM A5(pillar bedded), Jewell trigger, M5 DBM, Larue 20 MOA base, Badger rings, Bushnell HDMR scope, Badger bolt, Surefire MB. I've put about 1K through it. Cleaned it about every 250 rounds, just a wet patch twice and a clean patch two to three times. Bore is immaculate, no imperfections in rifling, crown is immaculate as well. The rifle shoots 1.25 MOA average. I set my calipers to .308, hit zero, then measure edge of furthest hole to furthest hole. All my equipment is tight and Loctited down correctly. It will shoot 3/4 moa every now and then but its never consistent, even with the same load.
At first I thought it was my scale throwing charges. However, my Brother in law has the exact same rifle with same mods, but he has an AAC brake and a Nightforce, it shoots 3/4 MOA average with quite a few 1/2 MOA groups and one .19 MOA group. We went shooting yesterday to figure out what was going on. We shot each others rifles, our own rifles, and we shot each others hand loads. All groups we shot were 5 shot, all ammo has the exact same case length and COAL. We both used a 10rd AICS mag for each group. Each group was shot in 1-2 minute gaps with a 3-5 second gap between each shot in the group, the groups did not seem to be effected by barrels heating up. However, the two best groups of the day were shot on cold bore. All shots were at exactly 100 yards to the muzzle, in 60 degree weather, zero wind(our range has a 10ft berm on left with thick trees all the way down the range and thick trees all to the right of it all the way down the range. Its about 15 yards wide. So wind is not an issue even on windy days), and at about 30 feet above sea level. We both used a Harris bipod and a Triad rear bag. Here is a little data:
Shooter: Clay(me)
Rifle: Clay's / Kevin's
Load: Lapua brass, Fed 210, 43gr AA4064, 178 Amax: NA / .959, .915 MOA
LC brass, Fed 210, 44 gr Varget, 178 Amax: 1.100 MOA / .972, .698 MOA
LC brass, Fed 210, 43 gr IMR4064, 178 Amax: 1.360 MOA / NA
Fed brass, Fed 210, 42gr Varget, 168 Nosler CC: 1.643 MOA / .421 MOA
Shooter: Kevin (brother in law)
Rifle: Clay's / Kevin's
Load: Lapua brass, Fed 210, 43gr AA4064, 178 Amax: .822. 1.314 MOA / NA
LC brass, Fed 210, 44 gr Varget, 178 Amax: 1.041, 1.519 MOA / 1.746 MOA(called flyer)
LC brass, Fed 210, 43 gr IMR4064, 178 Amax: NA / .793 MOA
Fed brass, Fed 210, 42gr Varget, 168 Nosler CC: .659 MOA / NA
Kevin's rifle average: .929MOA(with called flyer throwing data off) / .793MOA(without called flyer group), greatest deviation between groups of same load(excluding called flyer) .274MOA
Clays rifle average: 1.182MOA with no called flyers, greatest deviation between groups of same load .984MOA
So, that is all the data we collected. I know its not perfect, we should have shot two groups with every Rifle/Shooter combo. However, there is an obvious trend with his rifle shooting all loads sub MOA, with the exception of the called flyer, and mine only shooting 2 sub MOA, no matter who is shooting. I am at a loss as to what is causing my rifle to shoot so poorly compared to an almost identical rifle. Any ideas? Here are some pictures of the groups and a photo of Kevin's .19MOA 5 shot group a few days prior to the test.






This group was shot with Kevin's gun by Kevin a few days prior to the testing. Its a .19MOA 5 shot group at 100, just to show you what his rifle has done...

At first I thought it was my scale throwing charges. However, my Brother in law has the exact same rifle with same mods, but he has an AAC brake and a Nightforce, it shoots 3/4 MOA average with quite a few 1/2 MOA groups and one .19 MOA group. We went shooting yesterday to figure out what was going on. We shot each others rifles, our own rifles, and we shot each others hand loads. All groups we shot were 5 shot, all ammo has the exact same case length and COAL. We both used a 10rd AICS mag for each group. Each group was shot in 1-2 minute gaps with a 3-5 second gap between each shot in the group, the groups did not seem to be effected by barrels heating up. However, the two best groups of the day were shot on cold bore. All shots were at exactly 100 yards to the muzzle, in 60 degree weather, zero wind(our range has a 10ft berm on left with thick trees all the way down the range and thick trees all to the right of it all the way down the range. Its about 15 yards wide. So wind is not an issue even on windy days), and at about 30 feet above sea level. We both used a Harris bipod and a Triad rear bag. Here is a little data:
Shooter: Clay(me)
Rifle: Clay's / Kevin's
Load: Lapua brass, Fed 210, 43gr AA4064, 178 Amax: NA / .959, .915 MOA
LC brass, Fed 210, 44 gr Varget, 178 Amax: 1.100 MOA / .972, .698 MOA
LC brass, Fed 210, 43 gr IMR4064, 178 Amax: 1.360 MOA / NA
Fed brass, Fed 210, 42gr Varget, 168 Nosler CC: 1.643 MOA / .421 MOA
Shooter: Kevin (brother in law)
Rifle: Clay's / Kevin's
Load: Lapua brass, Fed 210, 43gr AA4064, 178 Amax: .822. 1.314 MOA / NA
LC brass, Fed 210, 44 gr Varget, 178 Amax: 1.041, 1.519 MOA / 1.746 MOA(called flyer)
LC brass, Fed 210, 43 gr IMR4064, 178 Amax: NA / .793 MOA
Fed brass, Fed 210, 42gr Varget, 168 Nosler CC: .659 MOA / NA
Kevin's rifle average: .929MOA(with called flyer throwing data off) / .793MOA(without called flyer group), greatest deviation between groups of same load(excluding called flyer) .274MOA
Clays rifle average: 1.182MOA with no called flyers, greatest deviation between groups of same load .984MOA
So, that is all the data we collected. I know its not perfect, we should have shot two groups with every Rifle/Shooter combo. However, there is an obvious trend with his rifle shooting all loads sub MOA, with the exception of the called flyer, and mine only shooting 2 sub MOA, no matter who is shooting. I am at a loss as to what is causing my rifle to shoot so poorly compared to an almost identical rifle. Any ideas? Here are some pictures of the groups and a photo of Kevin's .19MOA 5 shot group a few days prior to the test.






This group was shot with Kevin's gun by Kevin a few days prior to the testing. Its a .19MOA 5 shot group at 100, just to show you what his rifle has done...

Last edited: