Best AR-15/M16 Bolt Carrier Group For The Money…Who Ya Got??
- By MontanaMan
- Semi-Automatic Rifles
- 143 Replies
That looks ass-backwards to me...............+1 on that. For those who haven’t been able to watch the video here’s a rundown:
Carriers with the following finishes are the most likely to be gas efficient: chrome, phosphate, NP3.
Next tier after that is DLC and Nitride
Next after that is the PVD type coatings (inside finish tends to be rough)
Least likely to be gas efficient & most likely to have various problems is nickel boron (also likely to have headspace issues if the bolt face is NB coated).
Coefficient of Friction (COF) is a major reason for coating BC's & in descending order of COF is DLC, PVD, NP3 (a form of NiB) Chrome, & lastly, manganese phosphate.
So all else being equal (bore for gas rings, outside contact dimensions of the carrier, fit / seal of the gas rings), the friction, or lack thereof, of the carrier plays a significant role in "gas efficiency"................whatever that term is intended to define.
This can also be determined somewhat subjectively, by "feeling" the difference in "smoothness" of various BC's when cycling the BCG by hand. The absolute smoothness of feel for me has been a JP lightweight BCG, but that may be in a great part the design, followed by DLC...............other stuff, including chrome (although I like it a lot), just doesn't cycle as smoothly.
Additionally, I really have to look at OCKS screws with a jaundiced eye as far as being any kind of efficiency improvement or even reliability component................a correctly sealed (with Permatex), unstaked gas key has been completely reliable for me whenever I've used that method, as defined & described by Young Manufacturing (Dan Young DOES know a thing or 2 about AR's) has been 100% reliable. Dan Young on Staking Gas Keys
In fact, he clearly stated (at the time) that they would not warrant staked gas keys / carriers, installed that way by the builder.
Also, where is the info coming from as to what sellers are using what actual part manufacturers, such as Microbest or Toolcraft (who only makes carrieres)? The only seller that I have ever seen to acknowledge who is making a given part is Noveske, who has actually stated the RCA was the maker of their nitrided BCG's.........don't know if that is still the case anymore though. But I have never seen any public acknowledgement from anyone else.
MM